The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO

Campaigns and Politics

October 14, 2008

The Swing Vote: ‘Bradley Effect’ could impact election

When a voter says one thing to an election pollster and then does another thing in the anonymity of the voting booth, it is called a curious flip-flop.

But when one candidate is black and the other is white, and the results don’t reflect polls favoring the black contender, it is called the Bradley Effect.

The tag comes from the 1982 California governor’s race when polls showed Democrat Tom Bradley, the black mayor of Los Angeles, with a comfortable lead over Republican George Deukmejian right up to election day. When the votes were counted, Deukmejian won by a narrow margin.

Like it or not, there’s reason to believe the Bradley Effect could impact the outcome of November’s presidential election between Democrat Barack Obama and Republican John McCain.

A hint of that probability emerged in interviews last week with 36 undecided voters from eight swing states. The interviews were conducted by reporters for CNHI newspapers in Ohio, Michigan, Minnesota, Iowa, Pennsylvania, Indiana, Missouri and New Hampshire.

Ten of the 36 said the United States had not come far enough in race relations to elect an African-American to the presidency. Twenty-four respondents said race would make no difference and two did not answer the question.

The replies might not seem significant or even surprising until you do the math. More than one-fourth of the undecided said race would matter — and in a tight election, it could be the factor that determines the winner.

A recent CBS poll concluded that about 20 percent of the nation’s registered voters still haven’t made their final decision about Obama and McCain. If that’s true, undecided voters in the swing states would appear to hold the key to who becomes our next president and thus they bear watching and polling.

The problem is determining their true preference once they start embracing one candidate or the other. They might tell the pollsters they prefer Obama because of the economic crisis, and yet end up voting for McCain because of racial motivation.

Obama, whose father was from Kenya, Africa, and whose mother was white, may already have experienced the Bradley Effect in the New Hampshire presidential primary. The polls showed him with a double-digit lead over Hillary Clinton but the Democratic voters gave her the state by three points.

New Hampshire is an overwhelmingly white state with a history of conservative views on social and economic issues, although the 2006 election indicated that characterization may be out-of-date due to a steady influx of new residents from liberal Massachusetts. Democrats now occupy the governor’s office and both of the state’s U.S. House seats.

It is also entirely possible that white primary voters who told pollsters they preferred Obama decided to switch to Clinton because she waged an effective and emotional campaign in the final days of the New Hampshire contest.

Concealed racial bias among American voters has never been directly tested in a presidential election. And no matter who wins Nov. 4, we may not know for sure if it affected the outcome. Exit polls to determine the motivation for voting cannot be trusted on the question of race. Most voters with anti-black sentiments aren’t likely to admit it was a factor in who they voted for.

Most pollsters contend there’s no pre-election evidence that race could be a deciding issue in the Obama-McCain contest. They say voters are largely focused on the crippled economy and which candidate can best restore confidence and stability to the nation’s financial system.

Sandy Quarles, 72, a black Republican businessman from Kokomo, Ind., who said he's an undecided voter, certainly feels that way. He told the Kokomo Tribune the economy is in “the worst mess we’ve been in since 1929” and voter concern about it will transcend race, age and gender.

But a recent survey by the Associated Press and Yahoo News said one-third of white Democrats harbor some negative views toward blacks, creating a potential obstacle for Obama in a very close race.

This down side, of course, could be more than offset by a strong turnout of blacks and young people who support Obama. They are not undecided and they have registered to vote in record numbers.

“One of the reasons I want to vote for Obama is that he is not a white male,” said Barb Larson Taylor, 37, St. Peter, Minn. “I’m not opposed to white males and would not vote for him if I didn’t agree in part with some of his policies.”

Taylor told the Mankato Free Press the November election offers Americans a historic opportunity to “move beyond race, religion and gender in selecting our president. It is time as a country that we focus on qualifications and character.”

William B. Ketter is the vice president of news for Community Newspaper Holdings Inc. He has been observing presidential elections as a journlist since 1964.



Text Only
Campaigns and Politics
  • Missouri voters endorse state Proposition C

    Missouri voters on Tuesday overwhelmingly rejected a key provision of President Barack Obama’s health care law, sending a clear message of discontent to Washington and Democrats less than 100 days before the midterm elections. With about 70 percent of the vote counted late Tuesday, nearly three-quarters of voters had supported the measure.

    August 4, 2010

  • Neosho voters say ‘no’ to property tax

    A proposal to levy a property tax to help bail the city of Neosho out of its financial meltdown failed to muster even 40 percent approval from voters in Tuesday’s election.

    August 4, 2010

  • Jasper County choose incumbents for posts

    Voters in Jasper County on Tuesday tabbed the incumbents for two positions, Linda Williams as circuit clerk and John Bartosh for the Republican nomination as presiding commissioner.

    August 4, 2010

  • Pittsburg voters reject sales tax increase

    A proposed quarter-cent city sales tax increase in Pittsburg for street repairs was defeated Tuesday by voters, 1,243 to 1,031. The margin was 55 percent “no” votes to 45 percent “yes” votes. The totals are based on complete, but unofficial, returns from the Crawford County clerk’s office.

    August 4, 2010

  • Ruestman receives GOP nod; Krueger prevails in circuit clerk bid

    Republicans in Newton County on Tuesday overwhelmingly selected a state lawmaker to be their nominee for presiding county commissioner, according to complete but unofficial returns. Current state Rep. Marilyn Ruestman, of Joplin, with a total of 6,125 votes, led a field of four GOP hopefuls.

    August 4, 2010

  • Hunter McCleary Bill White beats Shelly Dreyer for nomination

    An intense and costly battle for the Republican nomination for Missouri’s 129th District House seat concluded Tuesday with a lopsided victory for William “Bill” White, who is seeking to fill the seat being vacated by Ron Richard.

    August 4, 2010 1 Photo

  • Moran holds lead in tight Kansas race

    Western Kansas U.S. Rep. Jerry Moran held the lead over Todd Tiahrt late Tuesday night in a contentious battle for the Republican nomination for a U.S. Senate seat from Kansas.

    August 4, 2010

  • Calloway defeats Titterington in 3rd District GOP race

    Terry Calloway defeated Chad Titterington Tuesday in the Republican primary race for the 3rd District seat of the Kansas House of Representatives.

    August 4, 2010

  • Former legislator leads race for Senate seat

    A former legislator and sheriff from the Bolivar area had a wide lead for the Republican nomination for the Missouri Senate District 28 seat, according to incomplete returns Tuesday night. Mike Parson, 54, of Bolivar, the former state representative in House District 133, was the leader with 12,723 votes.

    August 4, 2010

  • Billy Long Long, Eckersley win nods in 7th district

    Billy Long, a Springfield auctioneer, real estate salesman and former radio talk show host, won the Republican nomination for Congress from Missouri’s 7th District on Tuesday, while the Democratic nod went to Scott Eckersley, an attorney from Kimberling City who at one time worked for former GOP Gov. Matt Blunt.

    August 4, 2010 2 Photos

House Ads
AP Video
Business Marquee
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Popular Searches
Powered by Local.com
Parade
Magazine

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
Facebook
The Joplin Globe on Facebook
Poll

One of the first bills that Gov. Jay Nixon has signed into law this year is one that redirects casino fees to nursing homes for military veterans. Do you think this is a good bill?

Yes.
No.
     View Results
Stocks
Community Calendar
Loading…
Events by eviesays.com
Featured Comment