Mon, Oct 06 2008
|
|
Published December 16, 2006 09:59 pm - Few issues reveal the souls of those in power more than the fate of Medicaid, a monstrous but necessary program begun in the fervor of the 1960s and the push for the Great Society. Edgar Simpson: Battle over core principles looms with Medicaid reportBy Edgar Simpson
Globe Editor Few issues reveal the souls of those in power more than the fate of Medicaid, a monstrous but necessary program begun in the fervor of the 1960s and the push for the Great Society. As with most government programs, it began with the best of intentions, serving as a safety net for those whose only hope rested with the goodness of others. Since then, it has become entwined in the universally renounced welfare system and the ongoing struggle on how to define a hand-out versus a hand-up. Missouri Gov. Matt Blunt, a Republican, cut Medicaid a little more than a year ago, through lowering the income ceiling for eligibility and cutting some direct services. At the time, the Department of Health and Human Services concluded the changes would kick about 90,000 Missourians off the assistance program. The legislation that enacted the cuts included a mandate to kill Medicaid in 2008 unless the program was reauthorized. It is a remarkable strategy. No one seriously considered ending Missouri Medicaid, but the law does ensure a massive battle this legislative season on how to redraw it. A task force appointed by Blunt has released a report, the health-care version of the Iraq Study Commission, that will no doubt form the basis of debate. The report contains 14 “transformation” recommendations. Many are procedural, but taken together would fundamentally alter the way services are delivered. The plan contemplates changing the focus of Medicaid from treating illness and disability to promoting “healthy behavior.” Those receiving assistance would receive points by “taking part in an approved list of healthy behaviors” that could then be used to, essentially, buy Medicaid services, which would be renamed Mo HealthNet and Mo Healthnet Plus. The Democrats have responded to the report with some amount of horror. They are now estimating that 177,000 fewer residents, including 70,000 children, are being served by Medicaid, nearly twice the number of the initial guess. They are proposing no radical reform, but rather a restoration and extension of Medicaid services. Their plan “recognizes that access to basic health care is a right, not a reward for healthy living,” the Democrats said in a statement issued late last week. “The primary goal of any changes to the state health-care system must be a responsible expansion of coverage to those who need it the most,” state Rep. Judy Baker, D-Columbia, said in the statement. “By following these simple principles, we can craft a health-care delivery system that serves Missourians’ needs.” While the two plans are fundamentally different in philosophy, they do agree on some basic things. Democrats would address prevention through establishing a state surgeon general “to promote policies that encourage healthier living and prevent the spread of disease.” Both plans also recognized the need for wider private health insurance coverage. The Democrats would achieve this by refusing tax breaks to companies with more than 500 employees that do not offer health-care coverage to their workers. (That is directly aimed at Wal-Mart.) The Republicans, ironically, would do this through offering tax breaks to small businesses that offer health insurance and expanding Medicaid services to more children. The governor’s plan, overall, contemplates tap-dancing through a minefield of social issues. Is it possible to force Medicaid recipients to, for example, give up smoking? If a single mother of two falls into the Medicaid net through an addiction to meth, would she or her children be denied some services if she can’t kick the habit? 
![comment on this story](http://community.cnhi.com/eve/ubb.x?a=dl&f=55410432
&x_id=local_story_350215935.html&x_subject=<img+src=http://www.joplinglobeonline.com/onlineextra.jpg+border=0>+Edgar+Simpson:+Battle+over+core+principles+looms+<font+color="#ff0000">with+Medicaid+report</font>&x_link=http://www.joplinglobe.com/columns/local_story_350215935.html)
•
Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.
More from the Columns section
Mike Pound: Recital dancers may make playoffs Wally Kennedy: Intersection ready for spring work Zach Ewing: Some cures for your fall-sports hangover |
Print this story
E-mail this story
Post to del.icio.us
![Add a comment on this story](http://www.joplinglobeonline.com/zope/add_comment.php?section_id=columns&story_id=local_story_350215935.html&headline=<img src=http://www.joplinglobeonline.com/onlineextra.jpg border=0> Edgar Simpson: Battle over core principles looms <font color="#ff0000">with Medicaid report</font>&portal_url=http://www.joplinglobe.com&portal=joplinglobe){kind=link}
 |
 |
 |
||||||||
|
||||||||
 |
The Joplin Globe Publishing Company 117 East Fourth Street, Joplin, MO 64801 Using our site is your agreement to the terms and conditions. News: news@joplinglobe.com • (417)623-3480 Advertise with the Joplin Globe Copyright © 2006 The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO All rights reserved. |
Popular Business directory links - Joplin Apartments | Joplin Attorneys | Joplin Auto Dealers | Joplin Auto Parts | Joplin Auto Repair | Joplin Beauty Salons | Joplin Car Rental | Joplin Dentists | Joplin Doctors | Joplin Flowers | Joplin Hotels | Joplin Insurance | Joplin Loans | Joplin Mortgages | Joplin Movers | Joplin Pizza | Joplin Realtors | Joplin Restaurants | Joplin Storage | Joplin Tax Preparation | Joplin Travel | Joplin Featured | More...
|
|
Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc. • CNHI Classified Advertising Network • CNHI News Service |