(MCT) NEW YORK — A federal judge who rejected the government’s first bid to settle civil charges against Bank of America Corp. showed little enthusiasm Monday for a new proposed settlement.
U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff sharply questioned the merits of the latest proposal, which calls for the company to pay $150 million to resolve allegations that it lied to shareholders at the height of the financial crisis about its pending acquisition of brokerage Merrill Lynch.
Last fall, Rakoff threw out an initial, $33-million settlement between the company and the Securities and Exchange Commission, calling it a “contrivance designed to provide the SEC with the facade of enforcement.”
At a hearing Monday on whether he should approve the new proposed deal, Rakoff asked whether the SEC had been forceful enough in the case. He noted the latest proposal, like the first one, would not punish individual Bank of America executives.
The judge referred repeatedly to a lawsuit filed last week in state court by New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo that deals with much of the same conduct.
Cuomo’s case goes further than the SEC’s in seeking to punish Bank of America’s former chief executive, Ken Lewis, along with another executive as well as the bank itself. Although Rakoff poked fun at the angry rhetoric in Cuomo’s complaint, the judge said it put forth “a great many allegations that seem far more suggestive of potential fraud than anything presented by the SEC.”
“Weren’t you operating from the same evidence?” Rakoff asked the SEC’s lawyer.
The SEC initially accused Bank of America of lying to shareholders about its plan to pay billions of dollars in bonuses to Merrill Lynch employees after its acquisition of the brokerage was completed. More recently, the SEC also alleged that the Charlotte, N.C., banking giant did not disclose the size of Merrill’s losses before a shareholder vote on the acquisition.
Cuomo last week said that his new case was working in concert with the SEC, which announced its settlement minutes before Cuomo announced his lawsuit. But rifts between Cuomo and the SEC were clear Monday, particularly regarding Cuomo’s allegation that Bank of America fired a lawyer because he questioned the withholding of information from shareholders.
“We do not credit that as accurate,” said the SEC’s lawyer, George S. Canellos.
The reason for the firing, Canellos said, was that the bank’s board wanted to name Brian Moynihan general counsel. Moynihan, who at the time of was head of investment banking at BofA and is now the company’s CEO, was afraid that he would be pushed out after the acquisition by Merrill’s then-CEO, John Thain, Canellos said.
Rakoff also went into some broader hot-button issues that the case has brought up — particularly those surrounding executive compensation. Under the latest proposed settlement, Bank of America would have to hire an independent compensation consultant. Referring to the “endemic problem” of “the incredibly bloated compensation of too many executives in too many American companies,” the judge asked whether a compensation consultant hired by the bank would have a strong enough mandate and suggested that the court should approve of the choice.
“It is my obligation to make sure it is for real, and not just a bell or whistle added on,” Rakoff said.
Rakoff said he would decide soon whether to approve the settlement or force the case to trial.
Legal experts described Rakoff’s challenging of the SEC as highly unusual. The agency’s cases typically end in the kind of settlement that it proposed last fall. In rejecting that accord, Rakoff wrote that he did not want to provide more “rubber stamps.”
Business
<img src=" http://www.joplinglobeonline.com/images/zope/tuesday.gif" border=0> New SEC-Bank of America settlement faulted
- Business
-
-
Obama call for manufacturing revival a tough goal
President Barack Obama is making a strong election-year push for an economic revival “built on American manufacturing.” But he faces an uphill slog, with little consensus even within his own party on how to do it.
-
Stocks fall sharply as Greek deal is held up
Stocks are closing their worst day this year after Greece hit a roadblock on its way to a critical bailout.
-
Budget deficit drops to $27 billion in January
The budget deficit fell sharply in January compared to a year earlier, as an improving economy lifts income tax revenue.
-
Feds slap CA utility for San Onofre ammonia leak
Federal regulators say an ammonia leak that caused an emergency alert at Southern California’s San Onofre nuclear plant was caused by employees who failed to recognize degraded equipment and fix it.
-
Chicago officials make plans for potential massive protests of G-8, NATO summits
In Wisconsin, a group of environmentalists plans to bicycle to Chicago’s G-8 and NATO summits to protest an economy that relies too heavily on fossil fuel.
-
Obama praises Italian leader’s economic efforts
Eager for Europe to contain its economic troubles, President Barack Obama praised Italian Premier Mario Monti on Thursday for his efforts to lead Italy out of its fiscal quagmire.
-
Consortium in South wins federal approval for 2 new nuclear reactors
A consortium of utilities in the South won government approval Thursday to construct two new reactors at an estimated cost of $14 billion, the strongest signal yet that the three-decade hiatus of nuclear plant construction is finally ending.
-
Stocks fall at the open as Greek deal is held up
U.S. stocks opened lower Friday after Greece’s bailout deal was put on hold, a day after it seemed that the country had satisfied its creditors.
-
Asia stocks slip as Greek bailout remains in limbo
Asian stock markets dropped Friday after Europe’s finance ministers demanded more spending cuts from Greece before clearing a (euro) 130 billion ($170 billion) bailout to stave off the country’s bankruptcy.
-
Google’s first employee leaves to join education nonprofit
Google Inc.’s first hired employee, Craig Silverstein, is leaving the tech giant, where he’s worked since its founding, to sign on with the rising education startup Khan Academy.
- More Business Headlines
-
Obama Scraps Birth Control Mandate
US Airmen's Killer Sentenced to Life in Germany
Navy Names Ship for Gabrielle Giffords
Raw Video: Deadly Blasts in Syria
Romney Slams President Obama at CPAC
Gingrich: Pres. Obama 'waging War on Religion'
5 Killed in Wrong-way Crash on I-10 in La.
Uzbek Man Pleads Guilty in Plot to Kill Obama
Denver's Largest-Ever Drug Bust Nets Dozens
Marines: No Punishment for Nazi-like Flag
Vets Look to Translate Military Skills Into Jobs
Raw Video: School Bus Burst Into Flames
LA School Reopens Amid Sex Abuse Scandal
$25B Settlement Reached Over Foreclosure Abuses
Pentagon: Allow Women Closer to Front Lines
LA School in Sex Abuse Scandal Reopens
Raw Video: Italy's Mount Etna Bursts Into Life
Greeks March; Angry Despite Debt Deal
Air Force Airlines: Leaders Get Polished Service
Ga Girl Fights Off Kidnapper at Walmart
