The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO


March 25, 2013

Phill Brooks, columnist: Rushing bills results in unintended consequences

JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. — During the past few weeks I’ve been wondering whether the phrase “the law of unintended consequences” will become a signature of the 2013 session of Missouri’s General Assembly.

The phrase is widely used phrase among public policy analysts to describe how a well-meaning initiative can have adverse consequences that had not been realized in the rush to implement it.

Some of the major issues before this year’s legislative session involve fixing the messes caused by laws passed years earlier.

For example, some half-dozen years ago, the Legislature put a cap on how much businesses could be assessed to fund a program that provides health care coverage for workers re-injured on the job. The consequence of that cap has been to effectively bankrupt the Second Injury Fund, leaving thousands of injured workers without coverage and the state facing a massive lawsuit.

So now lawmakers are trying to fix the mess.

They’re also trying to fix tax credits. While originally intended as relatively limited incentives for various benevolent activities, tax credits have ballooned to the point that they now cost the state more than half a billion dollars each year in lost revenue claimed by various developers and business interests.

It’s not just real estate developers who have benefited from the tax credits. Take the tax credit for adoptions. It was designed to assist families to adopt needy Missouri children. But the law was not restricted to Missouri adoptions. So for several years a number of Missouri parents have gotten thousands of dollars in tax credits for foreign adoptions that do nothing to address the needs of Missouri children without permanent families.

Fixing that was one of the first two bills sent to the governor for the 2013 legislative session.

Easing sentences for first-time, nonviolent offenders is a major issue in this year’s session. It comes in response to the costly growth in the state’s prison population, which was an unintended consequence of the anti-crime wave that swept through the Legislature years ago and led to longer mandatory sentences.

It’s been my experience watching this process over the decades that unintended consequences often arise when there is a rush to pass something without full debate and with too little time provided for legislative staff to examine the legislation.

That might be happening this year with the massive restructuring of the state’s tax system. The Missouri Senate passed the bill even though its own staff could not determine whether the tax cuts would cost the state $244 million or $431 million by the 2016 budget year.

The margin of uncertainty — nearly $200 million — is not pocket change.

It would not be the first time that a rush to cut taxes caused financial problems for future legislators. Gov. Mel Carnahan’s call to eliminate the sales tax on groceries in 1997 led to financial problems for the state that continue to this day.

A few people had warned that the high growth in tax collections, which prompted the tax cut, would not continue. But not many listened. How could lawmakers reject the idea of a tax cut offered by a Democratic governor? The tax cut won easy approval.

Just a few years later, a former state budget director, Jim Moody, warned that the state had cut its tax base so deeply as to be unable to assure ongoing support for the current level of services during lean economic years.

There is no better vindication of Moody’s prediction than the state’s failure to meet its own funding goals for reducing the vast disparity among school districts in per-student spending.

The state now is hundreds of millions of dollars below its goal for education. No fix to that mess has advanced in this year’s legislative session.

Legislative term limits play a role in all of this. Few legislators have enough years in the Statehouse to have seen firsthand the unintended consequences of seemingly simple proposals.

But then, the biggest unintended consequences I’ve seen in my time covering this place come from that Carnahan tax cut and limits on future tax increases. Those came well before voter adoption of legislative term limits.

Phill Brooks has been a Missouri Statehouse reporter since 1970, making him dean of the Statehouse press corps. He is the Statehouse correspondent for KMOX Radio, director of MDN and a faculty member of the Missouri School of Journalism. He has covered every governor since Warren Hearnes.


Text Only
  • Our View.jpg Our View: Lone holdout

    Missouri continues to be the only state in the United States that won’t allow a prescription drug database to be established.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Anson Burlingame, guest columnist: Much has changed in U.S. over 14 years

    Does anyone recall the major economic argument during the 2000 presidential campaign between George Bush and Al Gore?

    July 22, 2014

  • Our View: Vote no on Amendment 1

    Proponents of Amendment 1 — the Right to Farm Act — have not made their case. We’ve met with advocates of this amendment to the Missouri constitution and listened to their arguments, but we don’t believe they have adequately answered the central question: Who is it protecting, and from what?

    July 13, 2014

  • Your View: Amendment 5 is deception of the highest order

    Amendment 5, sponsored by Missouri Sen. Kurt Schaefer, R-Columbia, “relating to the right of Missouri citizens to keep and bear arms” provides that “any restriction on these rights shall be subject to strict scrutiny.”

    July 21, 2014

  • Other Views Other Views: No time to turn away

    With the shooting down of a commercial airliner over Ukraine and fighting that has now escalated to a ground war between Israel and Hamas in Gaza, it would be easy for most U.S. citizens to throw up their hands and turn their backs.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Your View: Power to defend

    The Globe’s editorial ‘More guns not the answer’ (July 15) was saturated with classic progressive blather.

    July 21, 2014

  • Your View: Thanks for the generosity

    Generally, all we hear about is the bad news, and obviously, there is plenty available. Our church felt this event worthy of public knowledge.

    July 21, 2014

  • Your View: How to upgrade your business

    Let’s see now. When some folks wish to improve the exterior of their properties and have other taxpayers pay for the improvements, they create a community improvement district.

    July 21, 2014

  • Our View.jpg Our view: Street smarts

    If your daily commute has been shortened because you no longer have to wait at 26th Street and Connecticut Avenue for a train to pass, thank your own tax dollars.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Other Views Other Views: Decision fails test

    With the announcement that the State Board of Education has decided not to release individual school test results because of cyberattacks and other problems this spring, educators are scratching their heads, as are taxpayers who footed the bill.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

Local News
Twitter Updates
Follow us on twitter

A state lawmaker who is one of two doctors in the Oklahoma Legislature is insisting that unaccompanied immigrant minors being housed at Fort Sill be quarantined. Do you think those kinds of measures should be taken?

A. Yes.
B. No.
     View Results
NDN Video
Disabled Veterans Memorial Nearing Completion Last Mass Lynching in U.S. Remains Unsolved Home-sharing Programs Help Seniors Ex-NYC Mayor: US Should Allow Flights to Israel Clinton: "AIDS-Free Generation Within Our Reach" Judge Ponders Overturning Colo. Gay Marriage Ban Airlines Halt Travel to Israel Amid Violence NYPD Chief Calls for 'use of Force' Retraining VA Nominee McDonald Goes Before Congress Bush: Don't Worry, Sugarland Isn't Breaking Up US Official: Most Migrant Children to Be Removed Police Probing Brooklyn Bridge Flag Switch CDC Head Concerned About a Post-antibiotic Era Raw: First Lady Says `Drink Up' More Water Courts Conflicted Over Healthcare Law Holder Urges Bipartisanship on Immigration Raw: Truck, Train Crash Leads to Fireball US Airlines Cancel Israel Flights Obama Signs Workforce Training Law Crash Victims' Remains Reach Ukraine-held City