They say justice delayed is justice denied.
Let’s hope that’s not the case for Sheena Eastburn.
In the past week, Circuit Judge Tim Perigo denied the McDonald County woman’s appeal for a new trial, citing a technicality. We are disappointed by the ruling.
However, we also know this case is fraught with complications and unanswered questions.
Eastburn, then 17, was charged in 1992 with being an accomplice in the murder of her ex-husband. She was convicted in 1995 of first-degree murder and was sentenced to life without parole..
Tests showed that Eastburn was competent to stand trial, but that she was suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder because of sexual assaults at age 13. She also was suffering from depression. Her IQ scores ranged from 80 to 91. Mild mental retardation is an IQ of 70 to 75. Her public defenders at the time did not introduce that information during the trial.
The jury also did not hear that Eastburn allegedly was raped two times by a jailer while being held in the McDonald County Jail. The jury also was not told that Eastburn allegedly became pregnant while in jail and that her pregnancy was aborted.
Even though McDonald County Sheriff Don Schlessman was told about the rapes, no court action was taken against the jailer, Terrie Zornes, 47, of Pineville until last year, some 17 years after Eastburn’s family reported the alleged rapes. Zornes was charged in the Eastburn rape case after new evidence came to light last year. Using Eastburn’s case, prosecutors offered Zornes a plea bargain. In return for his pleading guilty to making sexual advances toward a 14-year-old girl in 2010, the rape charge against him connected to Eastburn’s allegation was dropped. He is serving four years in a state prison.
But Eastburn is serving life.
Eastburn’s primary public defender, Frank Yankoviz, has testified that he became involved in her defense two weeks before the trial. He testified that Eastburn did not receive a fair trial and that he felt “worse about this case than any other case” in his 20-year career as a public defender.
Her public defenders clearly botched the case. That was followed by gross mistreatment in the McDonald County Jail. The legal system then used Eastburn in another case and has now tossed her aside.
Earlier this year, the Supreme Court found that the Eighth Amendment forbids a sentencing scheme that mandates life in prison without the possibility for parole for juvenile homicide offenders.
If ever there was a case for a retrial, this is it.
They say justice delayed is justice denied.
Our View: Ethics reform needed
Legislators running for office aren’t likely to be as outspoken as those who are exiting Missouri’s public arena.
Marta Mossburg, columnist: On selfies and Shackleton
Leadership can mean many things to many people.
Other Views: D.C. needs No Labels
For all the gridlock in Congress we see on TV and elsewhere, many Americans might be surprised to know there is a group of about 90 members of Congress making efforts to find bipartisan solutions to the real problems facing the country.
Geoff Caldwell, columnist: John Jay, Bill of rights and the choice before us
On Dec. 12, 1745, John Jay was born in the British colony of New York.
Our View: No thanks to canned images
A movement among media to boycott the use of “official” photographs of President Barack Obama provided by White House photographers is gaining support — including ours.
Your View: Interpretation of experiences
Esther Cepeda’s column Nov. 26 pointed out that reading is an important skill that must be acquired even though it might not be fun.
Your View: Deserving recognition
In the early 1960s, two Carthage police officers, Bill Cox and Richard “Buddy” Rogers, organized the first police department Christmas party for underprivileged children.
Your View: Pay raise
In these days of cutting food stamp money for the poor and increased enrollment in reduced-price lunches for hungry children, it’s nice that city employees can give themselves a 3.6 percent pay increase.
Your View: ‘Benefits’ plan
Before Congress considers reducing food stamps, it should look at employers who use food stamps and welfare as part of their pay packages.
Our View: Running the race
Members of the Joplin City Council have voted to pull funding for the Mother Road Marathon, a race that crossed three states on Route 66. But that doesn’t mean the race has to end. Not by a long shot.
- More Opinion Headlines
- Our View: Ethics reform needed