JOPLIN, Mo. —
A magazine I read regularly is "The Christian Century," a bi-weekly publication that bills itself as "thinking critically, living faithfully." In the February 20th issue, the following headline jumped out at me: "Lutherans warn Vatican against luring their unhappy members."
The story begins: "Lutheran leaders have warned the Vatican that the creation of a structure to lure conservative Lutherans into the Catholic Church would harm dialogue and damage ecumenical relations."
The fact that one denomination singles out disgruntled members of another, then the offended denomination responds with a warning, is indicative of the pressure churches and denominations feel about the need for membership. Anyone deeply involved with their church can understand the pressure of enlisting new members and the sense of loss when members leave.
Alongside this is the growing concern by some denominational leaders about the trend of baptizing children at increasingly younger ages.
Are these children mature enough, or are they too young to grasp the meaning of exercising faith in God? The fear is that this trend is more about numbers than about ministry. It is one thing to grow an organization; it is another to grow a church.
The more institutionalized a church becomes, the more important its numbers become. Growing an institution involves gaining additional members. It's as simple as that.
Soon, however, as the institutional demands increase, the question becomes "How do we keep the need for members from becoming paramount?"
When membership becomes paramount in the church, bad things begin to happen. It becomes too difficult to lose members, and bad attitudes ease their way into our minds.
We unwittingly increase the pressure on prospective new members to join our church. Often, we resort to gimmicks. Ideals that are uniquely Christian become secondary to increasing the enrollment.
In short, rather than maintaining our identity as a church, we become just another institution fighting for its life, striving to grow, and scheming to compete in the marketplace for members.
The more institutionalized the church, the more important it is for the church to understand its identity, its objective and the measures by which it determines success. This is a difficult and ongoing task.
Rather than accepting the challenge of this task, we borrow from the business world and use numerical and monetary growth as our standard of success. This translates into "bigger is better," and so the bigger the enrollment Ñ plus the budget, the staff, and the building Ñ the more successful we feel.
The church is not alone in making this mistake. Educational institutions have done the same.
The truth of the matter is that neither churches nor universities are businesses.
Their objectives are totally different. There is nothing inherently wrong with starting a business, but not all institutions are businesses and, therefore, should not function like businesses.
Resisting the standard for success offered by the business model requires a determined diligence. We are reluctant to reject it because we are so accustomed to the positive feelings of self-worth it offers us.
The truth of the matter is that the moment we adopt the business model, we handicap the church. The nature of a church and its objective are not the same as that of a business.
The purpose of church is to usher the Kingdom of God into this world. If our church experiences growth while honoring that purpose, then so be it. If our church membership declines while honoring that objective, then so be it.
What should be said of a church cannot be said of business: The will to survive ensures death; the will to serve ensures life.
Craig Tally is the senior minister of First Community Church in Joplin. His column appears bi-weekly. He can be reached at ctally7740@gmail.com.
Lifestyles
Related Photos
-
Craig Tally
Discussion
Craig Tally: Business models not fit for churches
- Lifestyles
-
-
Amanda Stone: Do-it-yourself popsicles can be made from fruit, yogurt
It all started with a little white lie involving the blasted ice cream truck. I may have led my innocent toddler to believe that it is a music truck.
-
Cheryle Finley: Vidalia onion worthy of its own festival
Vidalia onions, the state vegetable of Georgia, are grown in season during late spring and early summer. First grown near Vidalia, Ga., in the 1930s, these onions are becoming more popular each year.
-
Benji Tunnell: Outside of the theater, movies are still entertaining
Every once in a while, I like to take a break from the weekly movie grind and explore some other entertainment avenues. Being a movie geek, I often gravitate toward film-related stuff.
-
Jeremiah Tucker: New Vampire Weekend album has shades of 'Pet Sounds'
The New York band's third full-length release, "Modern Vampires of the City," an instant classic and the best album of the year, feels like a sequel to that song. It is a record about being on the cusp of real, out-of-your-20s, unromantic adulthood and the terror that accompanies the narrowing of your options.
-
Joe Hadsall: Grilling cookbook packed with inspiration
With a healthy supply of flat irons, I've been able to experiment with a new grilling cookbook that has turned out to pretty handy and comprehensive.
-
Craig Tally: Science, theology can coexist
It doesn't seem to matter that there are scientists who express faith in God, and there are religionists who have a high regard for science. Indeed, there are many people of faith who embrace the discoveries of science without fear and trembling.
-
Joplin church among United Methodists participating in worldwide event
Byers Avenue United Methodist will be among churches around the globe uniting for Change the World, the fourth annual such event that has spread like wildfire throughout the United Methodist denomination.
-
Jeana Gockley: Library lines up reading club books
The Joplin Public Library's annual Summer Reading Club kicks off on Tuesday, May 28, so in preparation for a great summer of reading, I have been digging for titles that fit with this year's "Dig Into Reading" theme.
-
Frankie Meyer: Information is only as good as its source
Those details later become crucial as contradictory information is found, which it will be. How can one decide which detail is correct if the sources of the details are unknown?
-
Ryan Richardson: Groups give tips for preventing dog bites
When I was a teenager in the '90s I had an unfortunate incident with my neighbor's dog, a Brittany, that I had grown up with. It took a chunk out of my thigh when I went into the neighbors' yard to retrieve a ball.
- More Lifestyles Headlines
-
