The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO


February 18, 2013

Script for 'Identity Thief' presumed stolen

JOPLIN, Mo. — Every once in a while, talented actors are paired with a skilled director to create what's anticipated to be a successful comedy, but the mix just doesn't work.

Take, for instance, "Identity Thief." It stars Justin Bateman of "Arrested Development" fame (sure, he's done other stuff, but that's where it starts and stops for me) and Melissa McCarthy ("Bridesmaids"). Toss in director Seth Gordon, who made the documentary classic "The King of Kong," as well as the serviceable "Horrible Bosses," and one would expect hilarity.

But you can't make a decent movie without a good script, which is exactly what "Identity Thief" is lacking.

"Thief" follows Sandy Patterson (Bateman) as he has just accepted a new, much higher-paying position. On his way in to his first day at the new gig, his credit card is declined at the gas station, then he is arrested for missing a court date in Florida. Problem is, Sandy lives in Denver.

After a mug shot shows the offender to be a middle-aged, unattractive woman, Sandy is released. But the Denver police can't apprehend the identity thief until she is directly in front of them.

That leads to a convoluted idea in which Sandy will travel to Florida, convince the thief to come back to Colorado and tell Sandy's boss that she's the one who stole his identity, thus allowing police to arrest her and letting Sandy continue his upward mobility at the new job.

But wait: It seems that the thief, whom I will refer to as Florida Sandy, has also alienated a powerful drug kingpin by selling him bad credit card numbers, which is apparently what drug kingpins deal in. So, he sends two hapless hit people after her.

At the same time, a bounty hunter is sent after Florida Sandy as well, tasked with bringing her in to collect a $50,000 bounty, which seems a little excessive for someone who hasn't killed anyone or starred alongside Ashton Kutcher.

The failure of the movie rests almost entirely with the script. Written by Craig Mazin, of "Rocketman," "Senseless" and the "Scary Movie" franchise, the story is a moronic, drawn-out mess that asks viewers to suspend disbelief with the promise of outlandish behavior and hilarious jokes. Problem is, none of this is delivered upon, leaving the viewer to sift through nearly two hours of derivative, unfunny sludge.

The movie latches onto an idea that it thinks is funny, then just continues to repeat it, regardless of impact. Early on, it is established that Sandy is a girl's name. Then the movie goes back to variations of that same joke again and again.

Same with Florida Sandy's affinity for throat punching. And doing horrible renditions of once-popular songs. They weren't funny the first time around, and bringing them back makes them look even flatter.

Also holding the film back are the two subplots involving the hit men and the bounty hunter. It seems obvious that the story would not be enough to fill a feature length film and that filler would have to be added, but the two plots only drag down the momentum and pace of the film.

Another issue: Florida Sandy is just an all-around horrible person. She's a thief, she assaults people, she ruins lives. Yet, the movie feels the need to temper her, trying to humanize her and give justification to her awful behavior because of a bad childhood. It is a cop-out, and it is not credible at all.

I haven't even touched on the performances of the film, and I guess that is for the best for all involved. I really like Bateman, and he has done some stuff that I truly love, but his namby-pamby portrayal of Sandy renders him a weak and sad man. And McCarthy, who garnered an Oscar nomination in "Bridesmaids," seems only to be playing a variation of that character. Previews for her upcoming film "The Heat" show a character in the same vein, which leads me to believe that she may just be the female Vince Vaughn.

Text Only
  • r070714palacedrinks2.jpg Spirits school: Drink-making lessons taught at downtown bar

    Some patrons have dubbed it "Drinks with Daniel," but the official name is "Cocktails 101," which has been attracting "students" for the last several weeks.

    July 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • 071114_steve cindy head.jpg New exhibit combines works of married couple

    Steve and Cindy Head create different types of art, which means they can be each other's best mentor. Steve makes mixed media works assembled from photographs, headlines and more; Cindy paints vivid patterns and fanciful scenes with bold color palettes.

    July 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • Tantric tours in support of latest studio album

    "37 Channels," the latest album from Hugo Ferreira's band, features a lineup of guests including Hinder's Austin Winkler, Shooter Jennings, 3 Doors Down drummer Greg Upchurch, Uncle Kracker guitarist Kevin McCreery, Saving Abel guitarist Scott Bartlett and Leif Garrettt.

    July 11, 2014

  • mug_joe-hadsall-112613.jpg Globe Phone Test: Concept is clever, but transitions tricky with Asus PadFone X

    It's kind of embarrassing to point this out, but "Candy Crush Saga" is one of the best ways to illustrate how well the Asus PadFone X, a smartphone and tablet combo really works.

    Anyone who has more than one device will understand this situation completely: Let's say a player fires up "Candy Crush" on his tablet computer and really digs the game. A lot. So much so that he downloads it to his smartphone.

    Only there's one problem: All the progress made on the tablet is stuck on the tablet. The smartphone has a completely separate path of progress, meaning the player has to play each level twice. This makes progress through the game twice as long. (This problem can be fixed by signing up for the game on Facebook, but no one really wants their Facebook friends to know they spend so much time crushin' candy.)

    The Asus PadFone X is the dream solution to this nightmare of a problem.

    Available exclusively from AT&T, the device is actually two devices. A standalone smartphone can be plugged into a tablet computer, meaning the owner can take his pick of how he wants to play the game, and all the progress he makes is saved on one device's hard drive.

    AT&T loaned us a device that we tested for more than two weeks -- didn't like having to send it back -- and we found a lot of its qualities and quirks.

    July 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • 071014_sugar rush1.jpg Sweet summer: Candy factory opens floor for tours, tasting

    When family from Kansas City came to visit Christy Albertson in her family's Webb City home, she wanted to find something entertaining for five kids.

    July 10, 2014 1 Photo

  • images_sizedimage_108172906 Benji Tunnell: 'Transformers' reaches new level of terrible filmmaking

    Then there's "Transformers: Age of Extinction," a film so bereft of originality, spontaneity and life that one would assume its creator must be a talentless hack. That's when you remember that it was directed by Michael Bay.

    July 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • Marta-mug.jpg Marta Churchwell: Crystal Bridges' coup makes art world cry foul

    I find Eastern art snobs insufferable. I have little patience for their pretentious eyebrow-raising over anything unworthy of their refined tastes.

    July 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • Jermiah-Tucker-020812.jpg Jeremiah Tucker: Power pop plays perfectly for Fourth of July

    One of the best bits from the long-running -- and sadly now defunct -- "Best Show on WFMU" with Tom Scharpling was the character Power Pop Pop Pop. The independent call-in and comedy radio show explored this menacing, Godfather-like figure of the power pop community via one of his minions, played by the brilliant indie rock drummer and comedian Jon Wurster.

    July 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • mug_joe-hadsall-112613.jpg Joe Hadsall: Found-footage tornado movie may be terrifying

    Funny how all it takes is one little thing to bring back the full onslaught of tornado-related dread, desolation and depression. This time, it was a movie trailer.

    July 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • aisha-sultan-mug.jpg Aisha Sultan: Study shows popular kids peak too early

    It was, of course, a popular mean girl who made my life miserable in middle school.

    July 10, 2014 1 Photo

Speaking of Gardens


A study, to be reported on in Sunday’s Globe, recently reviewed the market conditions across the region. Do you think this is a good time to start a business?

     View Results

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
Twitter Updates
Follow us on twitter