subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite map
Sat, Jul 05 2008 

Published March 11, 2008 12:10 am - A Las Vegas pianist is seeking more than $300,000 in economic damages for a back injury he claims to have suffered when a sauna bench collapsed beneath him two years ago at the Holiday Inn in Joplin.
A Jasper County jury was selected Monday to hear the lawsuit of David Osborne, 49, an accomplished pianist at the Bellagio Hotel in Las Vegas, against John Q. Hammons Hotels, the owner of the Holiday Inn in Joplin.


Pianist blames hotel for back pain



By Jeff Lehr

jlehr@joplinglobe.com

A Las Vegas pianist is seeking more than $300,000 in economic damages for a back injury he claims to have suffered when a sauna bench collapsed beneath him two years ago at the Holiday Inn in Joplin.

A Jasper County jury was selected Monday to hear the lawsuit of David Osborne, 49, an accomplished pianist at the Bellagio Hotel in Las Vegas, against John Q. Hammons Hotels, the owner of the Holiday Inn in Joplin.

Osborne, who was raised in the Miami, Okla., area, and his son and daughter were staying at the Joplin hotel in December 2005 when the injury allegedly was incurred.

His lawyer, Joplin attorney Roger Johnson, told jurors during opening statements that his client lay down on a wooden bench in the hotel’s sauna after working out, and that it collapsed beneath him in splinters. Johnson said Osborne landed on the floor of the sauna, injuring his back and left hand.

Johnson told the jury that the back injury eventually forced his client to curtail the number of shifts per week he was performing at the time as a pianist in the restaurant of Caesar’s Palace in Las Vegas. The injury causes Osborne pain when he sits to play the piano, and the pain increases with extended periods of performance, Johnson said.

He said Osborne’s back pain is chronic, severely hampering his earning potential. He said Osborne eventually took his current job at the Bellagio, where he could work fewer shifts per week.

Johnson said the injury cost his client $13,000 per year in lost wages because of the need to cut back on his number of shifts per week, and that it will continue to cost him in the foreseeable future because his problem cannot be helped by surgery.

The plaintiff maintains that the sauna bench was in poor condition, and that the Holiday Inn failed to keep it safe for guests’ use. Johnson told jurors that the bench had never been replaced since the hotel opened, that there is no record of any maintenance or repair of it, and that there is no record of any daily inspections of the sauna by hotel employees as required by company policy.

“It was apparent to both David and Joshua (Osborne’s son) when they looked at it afterward that the bench had become dilapidated,” Johnson told jurors.

But Grant Haden, a Springfield attorney representing John Q. Hammons Hotels, told jurors that there is no evidence the sauna bench was in poor condition. He said Osborne’s lawsuit was “built on a house of cards.”

“That bench was made out of redwood,” Haden said. “It was in a dry sauna.”

Redwood is known for its resistance to rotting, he said.

Haden said the sauna was regularly inspected. He told jurors that an employee who examined the bench after the incident thought it appeared that the legs of the bench were kicked out. Haden suggested that some sort of damage may have been caused the previous night by other guests, and that the legs may have been propped back under the bench in an effort to hide the damage.



print this story    email this story    comment on this story   

Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.


Add a comment on this story





monster
wheels
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Get Our Free Pod Cast!

In Sundays Print Edition Only!

32 buy 1 get 1 free offers


Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!
Featured Jobs

HOME WEEKLY
Over the road truck driver position. Minimum 3 years experience. Must have mechanical knowledge. Good mileage rate, drop...>MORE

HILTON GARDEN INN
•Hiring for Houskeeping • Front Desk
•Server • Cook • Full Time Laundry
Please apply at 2644 E. 32nd Street
...>MORE

CENSUS IS GROWING!
Now hiring qualified CMA’s. Will train the right person. Apply in person at 2030 Zora Avenue, Joplin. ...>MORE

NOW HIRING MANAGEMENT
for Webb City Shake’s Frozen Custard. Apply at Joplin location 1441 Range Line. 782-6997. ...>MORE

EXPERIENCED CARPENTER
Must have excellent proven track record of running jobs. Good people skills, neat appearance is a must. Apply in person ...>MORE

STORE MANAGERS WANTED
movie Gallery Now Hiring Store Managers in Joplin area. Competitive pay. Great benefits package. Fax resume and cover le...>MORE

BEST WESTERN OASIS INN
3508 S. Range Line Road. Now hiring for the following position: *Front desk with flexible hours *House keeping. Competit...>MORE

BOOKKEEPER
BOOKKEEPER, Payroll, accounts payable, accounts receivable experience required. Medical billing or insurance experienced...>MORE

MILE+MONEY+HOMETIME
Equals a unique hiring event
TLocal small company
T2700 to 3300 miles per week Lots of home time
...>MORE

DRIVERS WANTED
DRIVERS WANTED, Drivers needed for Waste Corporation of Joplin, a growing company in the Joplin and surrounding areas. C...>MORE

See all ads

Featured Transportation

DODGE 1995 DAKOTA
dodge, 1995 Dakota Sport Extended Cab, V6, 4 wheel drive, cold air, automatic, tilt, cruise, nice truck, $2350. 434-7382...>MORE

NISSAN, 1995 FRONTIER
147,000 miles, 4 cylinder, 5 speed, $3750. 417-843-2613. ...>MORE

1999 MAZDA
mazda, 1999 B4000, 4X4, SE cab plus 4 door, very good shape, 99,000 miles, $5,000. 417-455-0180....>MORE

KIA, 2002 SPORTAGE
$3500 or best offer. Call after 6 p.m. (417)624-4386. 540-5284....>MORE

CLASSIC CHEVROLET AND FORD
Chevrolet, 1948 Fastback, complete project car with title. $2000; 1930/31 Ford truck, 1 ton chassis, pickup bed, extra f...>MORE

FORD 2006 ESCAPE XLT
ford, 2006 Escape XLT, 4X4, 14,000 miles, sunroof, appearance package, running boards, leather. $14,500. 358-0605....>MORE

OLDSMOBILE, 1997
88, nice, 71,000 actual miles, very good on gas. 626-0178....>MORE

1991 MERCURY GRAND MARQUIS
Mercury, 1991 Grand Marquis, parts car, $800 or best offer. 417-540-7300...>MORE

FORD 2006 LARIAT SUPER
ford, 2006 Lariat Super F350, 4X2, diesel dully, 15,000 miles, like new crew cab, lots of extras, $27,500. 417-782-5536 ...>MORE

GMC, 2000
1500 4X4 extended cab, 191,000 miles. $4250. (417)214-0022...>MORE

See all ads

Featured Homes

GRANBY, NICE OLDER HOME
3/4 acre, 2 br, 1ba, large utility, kitchen, appliances. Possibe owner financing. (417)451-1291...>MORE

LOG HOME
log Home for sale by owner. 11.66 acres, 3 car garage, barn, 2800 sq. ft. home. 3 br, 3 ba, office, hobby/4th br, firepl...>MORE

LOG HOME FOR SALE BY OWNER
log Home for sale by owner. 11.66 acres, 3 car garage, barn, 2800 sq. ft. home. 3 br, 3 ba, office, hobby/4th br, firepl...>MORE

3 BR, 2 BA, COLUMBUS, KS
newly remodeled interior, $525/month. (417)629-7352. ...>MORE

WEBB CITY SCHOOLS
3 br, 2 1/2 ba, new construction, great location, near park, Walnut Ridge, $119,000. 417-206-4532. ...>MORE

LEASE WITH OPTION TO PURCHASE
Complete renovation in NW Joplin, 4 br, 3 ba including master suite with jacuzzi, new stainless steel appliances and cus...>MORE

BEST BUY!
BY OWNER 219 N. JACKSON. Remodeled 4 BR, 2 BA, 2 Story, large living, formal dining, laminate flooring, new central air,...>MORE

GREAT FAMILY HOME
(3221 E. Zora) 4 br, 2 ba, with large fenced yard, $126,000. (417)206-4532....>MORE

See all ads

Other Cool Stuff

BOBCAT SKID LOADER
753C diesel, front loader bucket with pallet forks and other accessories, $10,000; backhoe 416B Cat diesel extendahoe, n...>MORE

CHIHUAHUA PUPPIES
shot hair. Home raised. No checks. (417)438-6922 or email farmchik_1@yahoo.com...>MORE

CREATION COLLECTOR PLATES
set of 12, call (417)781-6556...>MORE

FAST PITCH TEAM TRYOUTS
12U Championship
Fast pitch Team to add players.
12U Championship team located in Bentonville, AR is adding p
...>MORE

DACHSHUNDS
1 year male and female; male puppy $150 each. (417)673-4559. ...>MORE

TABLE/REFRIGERATOR
Table/4 chairs, $150; refrigerator, $200; both 6 months old, (417)437-7506....>MORE

PAPPILON, MALE
pappilon, male, 13 weeks, APRI, small, ears up, shots current, $200. 548-2433....>MORE

BABY FURNITURE
Baby FURNITURE Nodaway crib and 4 chair chest, $120; Cosco high chair, $30; new bassinet, $30; Sears umbrella stroller, ...>MORE

TWIN OAKS CUSTOM CABINETS
Quality cabinet builders/assemblers needed. Detail oriented, ability to read tape measure accurately, woodworking backgr...>MORE

TWO CREMORIAL NICHES
at East side Garden of Faith cremorial at Ozark Memorial Park. Both for $1200. Call (417)529-0619....>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2008. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index

rc
 

 

Find A Home Find A Car Find Anything