|
|
Published March 15, 2008 07:37 pm - COLUMBUS, Kan. — Several drunken-driving cases are being thrown out in Cherokee County because a judge concluded the Sheriff’s Department illegally detained some of those who had been stopped.
Several DUI charges poised for dismissal in Cherokee County
By Roger McKinney
rmckinney@joplinglobe.com
COLUMBUS, Kan. — Several drunken-driving cases are being thrown out in Cherokee County because a judge concluded the Sheriff’s Department illegally detained some of those who had been stopped. Other cases are being dismissed because the Sheriff’s Department for several months last year used equipment that was not certified to measure blood-alcohol content, according to the county attorney’s office.
The Sheriff’s Department has now changed its policy, said Cherokee County Attorney John Bullard. The department also is now using equipment that will stand up in court.
Recent cases
Cherokee County Magistrate Judge Bill Lyerla on Feb. 28 dismissed a felony DUI charge against Michael Aldrighetti, 44, of Columbus, ruling that the Cherokee County Sheriff’s Department had detained him illegally.
Aldrighetti’s lawyer, Sam Marsh, wrote in a motion to dismiss that the Sheriff’s Department had violated his client’s rights because he was arrested at 6:41 p.m. on March 2, 2007, and was released at 8:42 a.m. on March 3. Marsh wrote that his client was prevented from bonding out of jail before then because of the Sheriff’s Department policy.
The felony charge against Aldrighetti alleged that he committed the crime after two previous convictions.
A felony DUI charge against Lucas Hatcher, 27, of Columbus, also was dismissed recently for the same reasons, Bullard said. Hatcher was found guilty of misdemeanor traffic charges and sentenced to probation. He also was charged with committing the crime after two previous convictions.
“There are several dismissals that will be filed in the near future and in the next few months,” Bullard wrote in an e-mail explaining the situation in the Hatcher case. “We have been going through the pending DUIs and checking with the jail to see how many were detained. I don’t know the total number yet, but it’s more than a handful.”
Yet another dismissed case is that of Becky Allgood, of Commerce, Okla. She had been charged with felony DUl also after two previous convictions. The incident from which the charge resulted happened on Sept. 9, 2007, in Baxter Springs. She was found guilty of misdemeanors and traffic infractions, ordered to pay a fine and sentenced to a year’s probation. Judge Lyerla dismissed the DUI charge on March 4, citing a 2001 Kansas Supreme Court ruling.
That case struck down the automatic, mandatory detention periods for DUI arrests. The ruling found that mandatory detention policies violate the state constitution’s requirement that defendants be allowed to see a judge and make bail “without unnecessary delay.”
The ruling states that there are varying degrees of “under the influence” and being under the influence is not necessarily the same as being intoxicated. It also states that a judge can take public safety into account when setting conditions for release. Public safety is not an issue when someone who is arrested is released into the custody of a responsible person, it reads.
No blanket policies
The Supreme Court ruling allows officers to continue to make individual determinations about detention based on personal observations, but there can be no blanket policy.
•
Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.
|
|
Announcements

: Special Offer For New Subscribers
:


 |
|
FRONT LOADER
driver needed, local routes, experienced driver preferred. Class B license required. Pay $10-$11 per hour. Call for inte...>MORE
ADMINSTRATOR/OFFICE MANAGER
ADMINISTRATOR/OFFICE MANAGER Regional Eye Center PC. Busy multi doctor optimology practice seeks office manager/adm...>MORE
TRANSPORTATION
Transportation Southwest Missouri trucking company has opening for day shift Broker/Dispatcher. Qualified person must h...>MORE
RECEPTIONIST
busy law office seeking full-time receptionist. Previous experience required, mulit-tasking, computer skills, and great ...>MORE
SENIOR ACCOUNTANT
Non-profit organization searching for Senior Accountant. Bachelor’s Degree in Accounting, 3 to 5 years combination of pu...>MORE
LPN FOR MDS COORDINATOR
LPN FOR MDS Coordinator, experience required. Apply at Seneca House, 914 Chickesaw, Seneca, MO or call Holly at 417-776...>MORE
MECHANIC NEEDED
MECHANIC NEEDED Southwest MO trucking company seeks mechanic. Pay based on experience. Apply in person, 921 N. High Str...>MORE
See all ads |
|
SATURN, 2001 SC-2
154,000 miles, $2850. (417)540-9986...>MORE
CHEVROLET, 1999 MONTE CARLO
169,000 miles, $2750. (417)540-9986...>MORE
2001 GRAND PRIX
Richard Petty Special Edition Package, $4995/offer. 417-317-2000....>MORE
PONTIAC, 1999 SUNFIRE
148,000 miles, $2750. (417)540-9986...>MORE
See all ads |
|
VALENTINES GIFT
Unique Gorgeous Valentines Gift 1112 W. 5th, Joplin. Approximaitely 2200 sq. ft, could be 4,000 sq. ft. 3 br, 2 ba...>MORE
5 ACRES INCLUDES UTILITIES
5 ACRES includes utilities + creek + paved road, near Downstream, $2,950 down, $500/month. owner finance. 800-720-8503...>MORE
1 BR, BONUS ROOM
1 BR 1 ba, bonus room, 2115 S. Pennsylvania #B, Joplin. Refrigerator, stove, small storage shed, central heat/air, $385/...>MORE
See all ads |
|
BEAUTY SHOP EQUIPMENT
Beauty shop equipment, 4 styling chairs, $100 each; 4 floor mats, $50 each; 4 shampoo bowls with faucets, $50 each; 4 sh...>MORE
GERMAN SHEPHERD PUPS
GERMAN SHEPHERD PUPS, AKC, shots, wormed, ready to go $250. (417)850-5060...>MORE
VALENTINE YORKIES
girls and boys, 8-weeks, smallest 1 lb. 7 oz., starting price $400. Home raised. All up to date. Comes with bed and carr...>MORE
AKC ENGLISH BULLDOGS
AKC English Bulldogs, quality home raised puppies, born New Year’s eve, ready just in time for Valentines Day. $1000. (4...>MORE
FOR SALE DOBERMAN PUPS
6 males and 1 female, date of birth 1-18-2010 all black and rust, mom and dad for more information please call Je...>MORE
APR FRENCH BULLDOG
14 week old female. Brindle with white markings. $900. 417-540-7490...>MORE
BLOOD PYTHONS
Blood PYTHONS Adult and juvenile Blood Pythons for sale. Adults are proven 100% het for albino. Adults are breeders and...>MORE
MINI SCHNAUZER
4 months, male, $75 with papers and accessories. (417)434-8830....>MORE
See all ads |
|
 |
|