|
|
Published March 15, 2008 07:37 pm - COLUMBUS, Kan. — Several drunken-driving cases are being thrown out in Cherokee County because a judge concluded the Sheriff’s Department illegally detained some of those who had been stopped.
Several DUI charges poised for dismissal in Cherokee County
By Roger McKinney
rmckinney@joplinglobe.com
COLUMBUS, Kan. — Several drunken-driving cases are being thrown out in Cherokee County because a judge concluded the Sheriff’s Department illegally detained some of those who had been stopped. Other cases are being dismissed because the Sheriff’s Department for several months last year used equipment that was not certified to measure blood-alcohol content, according to the county attorney’s office.
The Sheriff’s Department has now changed its policy, said Cherokee County Attorney John Bullard. The department also is now using equipment that will stand up in court.
Recent cases
Cherokee County Magistrate Judge Bill Lyerla on Feb. 28 dismissed a felony DUI charge against Michael Aldrighetti, 44, of Columbus, ruling that the Cherokee County Sheriff’s Department had detained him illegally.
Aldrighetti’s lawyer, Sam Marsh, wrote in a motion to dismiss that the Sheriff’s Department had violated his client’s rights because he was arrested at 6:41 p.m. on March 2, 2007, and was released at 8:42 a.m. on March 3. Marsh wrote that his client was prevented from bonding out of jail before then because of the Sheriff’s Department policy.
The felony charge against Aldrighetti alleged that he committed the crime after two previous convictions.
A felony DUI charge against Lucas Hatcher, 27, of Columbus, also was dismissed recently for the same reasons, Bullard said. Hatcher was found guilty of misdemeanor traffic charges and sentenced to probation. He also was charged with committing the crime after two previous convictions.
“There are several dismissals that will be filed in the near future and in the next few months,” Bullard wrote in an e-mail explaining the situation in the Hatcher case. “We have been going through the pending DUIs and checking with the jail to see how many were detained. I don’t know the total number yet, but it’s more than a handful.”
Yet another dismissed case is that of Becky Allgood, of Commerce, Okla. She had been charged with felony DUl also after two previous convictions. The incident from which the charge resulted happened on Sept. 9, 2007, in Baxter Springs. She was found guilty of misdemeanors and traffic infractions, ordered to pay a fine and sentenced to a year’s probation. Judge Lyerla dismissed the DUI charge on March 4, citing a 2001 Kansas Supreme Court ruling.
That case struck down the automatic, mandatory detention periods for DUI arrests. The ruling found that mandatory detention policies violate the state constitution’s requirement that defendants be allowed to see a judge and make bail “without unnecessary delay.”
The ruling states that there are varying degrees of “under the influence” and being under the influence is not necessarily the same as being intoxicated. It also states that a judge can take public safety into account when setting conditions for release. Public safety is not an issue when someone who is arrested is released into the custody of a responsible person, it reads.
No blanket policies
The Supreme Court ruling allows officers to continue to make individual determinations about detention based on personal observations, but there can be no blanket policy.
•
Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.
|
|
: Special Offer For New Subscribers
:
|
 |
|
MEDICAL OFFICE
seeking Insurance Clerk. Coding experience required. Will pay for experience. Benefits. Send resume: Globe Box 94, 117 E...>MORE
ACCOUNTANT.
Expanding CPA firm: full time, degree/ computer skills required. Audit/tax experience preferred. Send resume to P...>MORE
LIBRARY SPECIALIST
Crowder College Lee Library, 25 hours a week. For complete information, see www.crowder.edu, employment section, or call...>MORE
TEAMS NEEDED
SIGN-ON BONUS $3000 Benefits and West Coast $$ Scheduled Raises $$ HIGH MILES WEEKLY 72hrs...>MORE
LIFEGUARDS
All shifts available, Apply in person at either Joplin Family Y location. www.joplinfamilyy.org....>MORE
GREAT BUSINESS OPPORTUNITY
Located on US Business. 60 7 acres with 3 BR house on Hickory Creek 3 buildings with 20 10 x 15 units each ...>MORE
NURSING PROGRAM COORDINATOR
for Crowder College in Cassville. Requires Master‚s in Nursing and two years of experience within the last five ye...>MORE
PCA 'S AND CNA'S
PCAs and CNAs In Joplin and surrounding areas. Call 417-206-7878....>MORE
UP IN FLAMES
WOOD FIRE PIZZA AND PASTA now hiring MANAGERS, SERVERS, BARTENDER Apply 1612 S. Madison, Webb City, behind Subway...>MORE
LIFEGUARDS
all shifts available, Apply in person at either Joplin Family Y location. www.joplinfamilyy.org....>MORE
See all ads |
|
LEHMAN TRIKE
LEHMAN TRIKE, 2007, excellent condition, rider has health problems. $20,500. Serious inquires only. (417)529-9554....>MORE
1990 GMC HIGH SIERRA
short wide bed, 2 wheel drive, V-8, power windows/locks, air, CD, tinted windows, chrome wheels. $2,000 or best offer. (...>MORE
NEED 2 DRIVERS
with 3 years plus $ miles with turn arounds back to Joplin, MO. Home often. 417-325-7320....>MORE
LEXUS 2002 ES
LEXUS, 2002 ES 300, silver/gray leather, navigation, heated seats, second owner, 94,000 miles, $10,900. 620-856-2804, 41...>MORE
1999 CHEVROLET TAHOE
2 door, 2 wheel drive, barn door rear, lowered, custom paint/grill/wheels, asking $5500. (417)781-1932, or cell (417)437...>MORE
FORD 2001 ESCORT
FORD, 2001 Escort, 4 cylinder, automatic, good condition. $1800. (417)437-5682....>MORE
2005 HONDA SHADOW VLX 600
2,000 miles, color white, $3950. (417)673-3860....>MORE
YAMAHA 1999 ROAD STAR
Yamaha, 1999 Road Star 1600 excellent condition, less than 10,000 miles, saddle bags and highway lamps. $3500. Cell phon...>MORE
GMC, 2006
2500 4x4, regular cab/bed, 133,000 miles, $9850. (417)214-0022....>MORE
2006 CHEVROLET HHR LT
automatic, 40,000 miles, loaded with options, $6200. (417)434-2949....>MORE
See all ads |
|
HANDYMAN SPECIAL
Handyman Special, only $500 down, owner financing, 11% interest, $345/ month, priced at $23,900. 1120 W. 12th Street (41...>MORE
INVESTORS OR START-UP
INVESTORS OR START-UP 1217 Central. $67500 2 bedroom, 1 bath, very nice,room to build more. See more at homesbyowner.co...>MORE
2-3 BR
Basement, newly remodeled, oak cabinets, nice wood floors, privacy fence. $79,200. 2525 N. Ozark. (417)483-0900....>MORE
OPEN HOUSE
OPEN HOUSE 7/5/09 1:00-4:00 2281 sq. ft. Updated kitchen 4 br + bonus room 2 living areas Metal roof. Stapleton school ...>MORE
LAKE FRONT MOBILE
Lake Front Mobile Grove, OK 1972 14 X 46 1 Bedroom, 1 bath lake front mobile home weekend getaway. Complete with furn...>MORE
OWNER FINANCE
OWNER FINANCE. $650 down, $435 monthly. 201 N. Washington, Joplin, 3 BR, garage, Full price $32,500. 417-359-4113. ...>MORE
See all ads |
|
24' BAJA OUTLAW
24’ BAJA Outlaw beautiful closed bow boat, 454 Mag, all options, excellent condition, low hours with 2005 trailer, $16,0...>MORE
AMPLIFIER
1953 Gibson BHR, $250. (417)437-9942....>MORE
ANTIQUE RADIO
ANTIQUE Radio; hanging lamps; china cabinet; carnival glass; Singer featherweight machine; 2 ladies and men diamond ring...>MORE
MALTIES PUPS
$150-$300; Yorkies, $300; Morkies-$200. 592-7827, leave message....>MORE
NASCAR
Indy Brick Yard 400, 7/26/09, 2 at $90. 417-483-1460....>MORE
SHIH-TZU PUPPIES
$125 each; Shih-tzu adults free to a good home, (417)439-5568....>MORE
MINIATURE DACHSHUND PUPPIES
6 weeks old, $100. (417)781-4099....>MORE
INDEPENDENCE DAY BLOW OUT SALE
20% off all grocery items 20% off all cleaning supply items 20% off all refrigerators, dishwashers, deep...>MORE
LAB MIX
black female, spayed, 3 years old, and 2 puppies, male/female, up to date vet care, $35 each. Refundable with proof of s...>MORE
LOST: 10 YEAR OLD YELLOW LAB
Goldie has on a flea collar, lost 6/28 between Oak Grove and Tipton Ford. PLEASE call 417-438-2828....>MORE
See all ads |
|
 |
|