subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite map
Sat, Nov 07 2009 

Published March 15, 2008 07:37 pm - COLUMBUS, Kan. — Several drunken-driving cases are being thrown out in Cherokee County because a judge concluded the Sheriff’s Department illegally detained some of those who had been stopped.

Several DUI charges poised for dismissal in Cherokee County



By Roger McKinney

rmckinney@joplinglobe.com

COLUMBUS, Kan. — Several drunken-driving cases are being thrown out in Cherokee County because a judge concluded the Sheriff’s Department illegally detained some of those who had been stopped. Other cases are being dismissed because the Sheriff’s Department for several months last year used equipment that was not certified to measure blood-alcohol content, according to the county attorney’s office.

The Sheriff’s Department has now changed its policy, said Cherokee County Attorney John Bullard. The department also is now using equipment that will stand up in court.

Recent cases

Cherokee County Magistrate Judge Bill Lyerla on Feb. 28 dismissed a felony DUI charge against Michael Aldrighetti, 44, of Columbus, ruling that the Cherokee County Sheriff’s Department had detained him illegally.

Aldrighetti’s lawyer, Sam Marsh, wrote in a motion to dismiss that the Sheriff’s Department had violated his client’s rights because he was arrested at 6:41 p.m. on March 2, 2007, and was released at 8:42 a.m. on March 3. Marsh wrote that his client was prevented from bonding out of jail before then because of the Sheriff’s Department policy.

The felony charge against Aldrighetti alleged that he committed the crime after two previous convictions.

A felony DUI charge against Lucas Hatcher, 27, of Columbus, also was dismissed recently for the same reasons, Bullard said. Hatcher was found guilty of misdemeanor traffic charges and sentenced to probation. He also was charged with committing the crime after two previous convictions.

“There are several dismissals that will be filed in the near future and in the next few months,” Bullard wrote in an e-mail explaining the situation in the Hatcher case. “We have been going through the pending DUIs and checking with the jail to see how many were detained. I don’t know the total number yet, but it’s more than a handful.”

Yet another dismissed case is that of Becky Allgood, of Commerce, Okla. She had been charged with felony DUl also after two previous convictions. The incident from which the charge resulted happened on Sept. 9, 2007, in Baxter Springs. She was found guilty of misdemeanors and traffic infractions, ordered to pay a fine and sentenced to a year’s probation. Judge Lyerla dismissed the DUI charge on March 4, citing a 2001 Kansas Supreme Court ruling.

That case struck down the automatic, mandatory detention periods for DUI arrests. The ruling found that mandatory detention policies violate the state constitution’s requirement that defendants be allowed to see a judge and make bail “without unnecessary delay.”

The ruling states that there are varying degrees of “under the influence” and being under the influence is not necessarily the same as being intoxicated. It also states that a judge can take public safety into account when setting conditions for release. Public safety is not an issue when someone who is arrested is released into the custody of a responsible person, it reads.

No blanket policies

The Supreme Court ruling allows officers to continue to make individual determinations about detention based on personal observations, but there can be no blanket policy.



print this story    email this story    comment on this story   

Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.


Add a comment on this story







autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
: Special Offer For New Subscribers : 32 buy 1 get 1 free offers

Click Here!



Featured Jobs

PHONE SALES
Now hiring part time for data entry and phone sales. 20 hour/week. Apply in person at 4710 E 32nd Street. Joplin....>MORE

CREDIT ANALYST/LOAN REVIEW
Credit ANALYST/LOAN REVIEW Commercial banking experience required. Send resumes to 3223 Main.Joplin 64804...>MORE

MEMBER SERVICES ASSOCIATES
The Freeman Southwest Family YMCA in Neosho, MO has two openings for
Member Services Associates.
These part-t
...>MORE

3 BOOTH RENTALS
small salon atmosphere, lots of exposure, 15th/Main. 417-529-8646...>MORE

MARS PET CARE

in Miami Ok. is now accepting applications for a Lead A position, on 2nd or 3rd shift. The position requires a hi
...>MORE

SEEKING MICROSOFT SYSTEMS ANALYST
Seeking Microsoft Systems Analyst. Candidate will assist with presales consulting, primary installation and support of W...>MORE

ATTENTION OWNER OPERATORS
we are now leasing on trucks. Call Susan at 888-379-9432 ext 102 for details. ...>MORE

HIRING HAIR STYLIST
NOW HIRING HAIR STYLIST. Fun and energetic salon. 417-845-0555, Tanya....>MORE

HAIR STYLIST
for Carthage salon.
417-388-2074.
...>MORE

SALES
NYSE and Co., opening a new division. Will train. Looking for full-time or part-time. Call Mike, (417)448-4732....>MORE

See all ads

Featured Transportation

1986 FORD MUSTANG GT
Convertible, 5 speed, 112,000 miles, $3800. 417-439-1707 or 417-439-7901...>MORE

1999 FORD F350
crew cab, 7.3 diesel, 4x4, white, Astro top, best offer. 434-3995...>MORE

TOYOTA, 2009 CAMRY LE,
excellent conditon, black/tan, 29,500 miles, bought from Fletcher, warranty, $18,900. 417-793-1613...>MORE

1993 ISUZU TROOPER
$2000 Good Interior Needs tune up. 417-396-8811....>MORE

1999 PONTIAC GRAND AM
2 door, spoiler, automatic, cold air, CD, extra nice, $2400. 1317 Schifferdecker, Joplin....>MORE

1999 DODGE NEON
5 speed, air, 92,000 miles. 417-529-4420 or 417-781-8907....>MORE

1998 OLDSMOBILE REGENCY
127,000 miles, nice and clean, $3420. 529-2207....>MORE

PONTIAC, 1997 SUNFIRE,
2 door, automatic, low miles, very nice, $2650. 434-7382....>MORE

1990 FREIGHLINER CAB OVER
set back axle, 400 Cummins, 9 speed over drive, flat top, big sleeper, 10 near new tires, new transmission, new brakes a...>MORE

2007 NISSAN MURANO
All wheel drive, 47,000 miles, leather, excellent condition, received a company car and do not need extra vehicle. $17,9...>MORE

See all ads

Featured Homes

OPEN HOUSE 2-4 P.M.
3 br, 2 ba, 2-car gar., 1660 sq. ft. with lots of amenities, 2228 W. 29th. $129,900. 417-825-0557....>MORE

3 BR, 2 BA, FIREPLACE
2 car attached, corner lot. Royal Heights area. $103,500. 417-434-0502 or 417-673-5584....>MORE

OPEN SATURDAY 9 A.M.-4 P.M.
Sunday 1-4 p.m. 3 br on 2 lots, central heat/air, vinyl siding/windows. See to appreciate. $29,900. 823 S. Sergeant. (91...>MORE

HISTORICAL ROCK FILLING STATION

on Route 66 with lots of updates This solid old building has 1200 sq. ft. on 100x100 lot, on Main Street of Carter
...>MORE

GROVE, GRAND LAKE, OK.

Beautiful 2-story 2-kitchen Lake Home with Million $$$ lakefront. Stunning Commercial Building for restaurant or o
...>MORE

819 A STREET
Charming 2 story, 2 bedroom home with a lot of character. Hardwood floors, huge screened porch, central heat and air, co...>MORE

LOMA LINDA
2 BR, 2 BA, 1 year lease, $750/$700. No pets. (417)310-0056....>MORE

DOWNTOWN JOPLIN

Commercial buildings.
For sale or lease.
For details phone
Bill Martin,
Quality Real Estat
...>MORE

1617 JEFFERSON CIRCLE
3 BR, 2 ba, gar, fence, updated electric $63,000. 629-6135...>MORE

BRIARBROOK
3 BR, 2.5 ba, 1 year lease $725/$700, no pets. 417-310-0056....>MORE

See all ads

Other Cool Stuff

COFFEE, END AND ENTRY TABLE
coffee, end and entry tables, Nordic Track Walk Fit, sewing machine desk, (417)206-4958....>MORE

2 CREMATION NICHES
2 CREMATION NICHES Ozark Memorial Park Cemetery, moving must sell quick. Call Carolyn, (417)624-3017....>MORE

KENNELL REDUCTION
Chihuahua’s and French Bulldog’s, AKC, pups to young adults, very nice, Chihuahua’s $100/up, Frenchis, $900/up. (417)394...>MORE

BOW FLEX EXTREME HOME GYM

(417)438-9041
...>MORE

CHIHUAHUAS
Chorkies, WaPoos, Shih-Tzus, just in time for Christmas. $85 to $250. Registered and shots 417-438-6057...>MORE

1950S CAVALIER COKE MACHINE
in working order, $350. (417)782-2751....>MORE

CHEAP PUPPIES
Border Terriers, Dachshunds, Italian Greyhound, Lhasas, Morkies, Norwich Terriers, Shih-Tzus, Standard Poodles (chocolat...>MORE

COUCH
full size, with pillows, light pastel colors, lavender and blue, no cats, no dogs, no kids, $150 or offer. 624-2197....>MORE

TWO LIVING ESTATE SALES, ONE SITE

Saturday, November 7, 8 a.m. - 3 p.m.
28245 Fir Road, Carl Junction, MO.
Follow signs.
Downsizing
...>MORE

2008 POLARIS TRAILBLAZER 330
2 wheel drive, like new, $2300. (918)961-8995....>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index

 

 

The Joplin Globe Electronic Edition