subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite map
Sat, Nov 21 2009 

Published May 23, 2008 09:34 pm - CARTHAGE, Mo. — A lawsuit that Emma France filed against Rita Hunter, Jasper County public administrator, has been dismissed in federal court.

Federal lawsuit dismissed; attorneys at odds on effect



By Susan Redden

sredden@joplinglobe.com

CARTHAGE, Mo. — A lawsuit that Emma France filed against Rita Hunter, Jasper County public administrator, has been dismissed in federal court.

Another lawsuit filed against Hunter by Delores Forste, France’s daughter, was sent back to Jasper County Circuit Court.

Attorneys for both sides agreed Friday as to the federal court rulings, but disagreed as to what those rulings mean.

Hunter said she was notified of the federal actions on Friday afternoon, adding “they’re telling me the suit’s been dismissed, and it’s over.”

Doug Harpool, a member of the Springfield law firm representing Hunter, said the dismissal means the end of the suit filed on France’s behalf against Hunter.

He predicted the other lawsuit, filed against Hunter by Forste, also will be dismissed.

“They sent that case back to state court, where I expect it will be dismissed, though it will take a little while,” said Harpool, who is representing Hunter on behalf of the county’s insurance carrier.

Richard Crites, a member of the Springfield firm representing France and Forste, said the France suit dismissed by federal court will be filed in Jasper County Circuit Court.

“It was dismissed without prejudice for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction; what they’re saying is that it belongs in state court, not in federal court,” Crites said. “And, it’s not over; we’re just getting started.”

He said the Forste suite was moved to federal court on a motion by Hunter’s attorney.

The lawsuits were filed in January on behalf of France, 95, formerly of Carthage, and Forste, France’s daughter, of Needles, Calif. The France suit was filed in federal court and sought $1 million in compensatory damages, plus punitive damages and other costs. The suit filed in Jasper County Circuit Court on behalf of Forste seeks “fair and reasonable” compensatory damages, plus punitive damages and costs.

Both lawsuits detailed events leading up to probate-court action May 16 in which France, after losing substantial money in telephone lottery scams, was named a ward of the public administrator. Testimony in support of the appointment indicated that France was not buying food or medicine, and instead was using her money on lotteries. Hunter said Forste was contacted about her mother’s problems and would not get involved.

Forste said she spoke to her mother frequently and knew about her financial losses. But, she said she was never notified of any court hearing or plans to make her mother a ward of the county. After the court ruling, Forste took her mother to visit relatives, then home with her to California.



print this story    email this story    comment on this story   

Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.


Add a comment on this story







autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide

Announcements



Click here to VOTE!!

Click here!!

: Special Offer For New Subscribers : 32 buy 1 get 1 free offers

Click Here!




Featured Jobs

WALLER TRUCK COMPANY
Waller Truck Company is now seeking Company and Lease Drivers. Call Recruting today at 1-800-821-2196 or apply today onl...>MORE

LOCAL YARD WORK
1ST SHIFT
We are a specialized carrier seeking an individual at our Baxter Springs, KS location. Duties include F
...>MORE

BODY TECHNICIAN
Carthage AUTO PLAZA is looking for a body technician/painter. I-Car certification is required. Come by and fill out an a...>MORE

DRIVER LONG HAUL
Driver, long haul or regional, for small Joplin company, home weekly, good pay and benefits, must have 3 years verifiabl...>MORE

OWNER OPERATORS
with equipment for truck and trailer, drive in or reefer. 624-2755...>MORE

OPIES TRANSPORT
Opies TRANSPORT Now Hiring Over the Road Drivers with 2 years experience. 800-341-9963 www.opiestransport.com ...>MORE

CMA
cma with insulin certification. Whispering Pines, (417)781-0099....>MORE

EXPERIENCED FULL TIME AUTO TECH
EXPERIENCED Full time Auto Repair Tech for very busy repair shop! Apply at Iveys Service Center, 301 E. 7th, Joplin...>MORE

TAX PREPARERS
needed in Joplin, Webb City, Carthage, and Neosho. Seasonal
FREE TRAINING
For more information, call 24 hour
...>MORE

TRAVEL U.S.A.
TRAVEL U.S.A. Publication sales company hiring 18 sharp enthusiastic individuals to travel the U.S. Travel, training, l...>MORE

See all ads

Featured Transportation

OLDSMOBILE 2004 ALERO
OLDSMOBILE, 2004 Alero, 2 door, 72,000 miles great condition $5200 417-529-1657...>MORE

TOYOTA, 2004 TACOMA,
double cab, 2x4, 3.4L V6, 61,000 miles, CD, bed liner, cover, $16,500. (417)437-0013....>MORE

FORD 2003 TAURUS
FORD, 2003 Taurus, silver, 95,000 miles, premium sound, leather, sunroof, 6 CD. $3,600. 417-438-4252....>MORE

SAAB, 1999 SE,
4-cylinder, convertible, all power, 74,000 miles $4800. 417-423-0125...>MORE

JEEP, 2007 COMMANDER,
loaded, 22,000 miles, $12,950. 417-781-1409, 529-5606...>MORE

FORD 2006 RANGER XLT
FORD, 2006 Ranger XLT, 50,000 miles, power windows/locks, bed liner, tool box, etc. $12,500 or best offer (417)499-4345...>MORE

PONTIAC 2001 GRAND AM GT
pontiac, 2001 Grand Am GT Coupe, 2 door, black, automatic, 4 shift bucket seats, moonroof, $3650. (417)434-5503....>MORE

TOYOTA 1994 T100
TOYOTA, 1995 T100, extended cab, 4x4, high miles, $3950. (417)843-2613....>MORE

MAZDA 2000 B4000
Mazda, 2000 B4000 extended cab, V6, automatic, loaded-nice, $3450. 434-5503....>MORE

1993 120FL FREIGHTLINER
1993 120FL Freightliner, day cab, 572,541 miles, twin screw, 60 series Detroit, 9 speed Fuller, air ride and 2000 step d...>MORE

See all ads

Featured Homes

2802 MASSACHUSETTS, JOPLIN
2802 Massachusetts, Joplin You won't believe the price! 3 bedroom, new central heat and air, new roof, appliances.. Cl...>MORE

3BR, ALBA
3 BR, 1 ba, 1 car gar, large fenced yard, Alba $550+ deposit. Hud ok 417-540-4674...>MORE

2 BR COTTAGE
2 BR COTTAGE, small but cute, all electric, small down, $450. Owner finance. 609 W. 15th. 417-439-4104....>MORE

2 BR, 1 BA,
excellent location, 208 E. Lexington, Jasper, $325. (417)830-0873....>MORE

LEASE/PURCHASE
Executive Home, 4 br, 3 ba, 3000 sq. ft. on 5 acres. 605-521-0971...>MORE

525 E 41ST FOR SALE AT AUCTION
525 E. 41ST, Joplin, MO will be offered for sale at Auction
Saturday, December 5th 9:30 AM AAA Auctions Bob 417-
...>MORE

ATTRACTIVE 4 BR ORONOGO
attractive, comfortable 4 br, 3 ba, 2-level, 2600 sq. ft. home. Greystone Subdivision, $194,900. 103 Jason Blvd., Oronog...>MORE

Deerfield Estates
in Carl Junction, prime building sites, reduced $10,000 each. 417-825-0052...>MORE

OPEN HOUSE SUNDAY 1-5 P.M.
OPEN HOUSE SUNDAY 1-5 p.m. New construction, 3 BR, 2 BA, 3 car garage, newer neighborhood, mature trees, 3 minutes from...>MORE

See all ads

Other Cool Stuff

YORKIES AKC
Yorkie, AKC, 2 adorable males, 3 1/2 months, current shots. 620-762-0445...>MORE

ROTTWEILERS
ROTTWEILERS,champion bloodlines. Dachshunds and Boxers. All AKC 918-784-2652, 918-541-8800...>MORE

BULLDOGS-ADULT
Bulldogs- ADULT 4 female, 1 male, adult English Bulldog; 6 females adult French Bulldogs; ages 1-4; Cream/Brindle. 417-...>MORE

NICE BEAGLE PUPS,
shots/wormed, $35/$40. Delivered? (417)439-3647...>MORE

KENMORE GAS RANGE
Kenmore gas range; G.E. portable dishwasher, $150 each; both are 3 years old (417)624-4546, (417)439-9740...>MORE

DOBERMAN PUP
Doberman pup, ACA, black/tan, male, 11 weeks, neutered. (620)922-3531....>MORE

GORGEOUS OAK POOL TABLE
GORGEOUS oak pool table, 2 inch slate, pearl inlays, bear claw legs; new rare neon beer sign. (417)483-6719....>MORE

CLOSE OUT PRICES
close OUT prices on beads, jewelry, and Longaberger products. Bring this ad for 10% off beads and jewelry. Saturday, Nov...>MORE

12 GUN CABINET
12 GUN CABINET, 10 gun cabinet, new 10” miter saw; new 12” drill press. (417)359-5819....>MORE

WHITE WICKER HENRY LINK SOFA
White wicker Henry Link sofa, Pier 1 wicker love seat and chair, Singer sewing machine in cabinet, large picture, floor ...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index

 

 

The Joplin Globe Electronic Edition