subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite map
Sun, Jul 05 2009 

Published May 29, 2007 08:43 pm - JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. — Although the state labor department initially advised otherwise, a judge has ruled that food servers, bellhops and other tipped employees were due a pay raise when Missouri’s minimum wage rose this year.

Circuit judge: Restaurants owe tipped workers $3.25 an hour



From AP, staff reports

JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. — Although the state labor department initially advised otherwise, a judge has ruled that food servers, bellhops and other tipped employees were due a pay raise when Missouri’s minimum wage rose this year.

The ruling by Cole County Circuit Judge Patricia Joyce could result in several hundred dollars of back pay for each tipped employee whose boss relied on the state’s faulty interpretation.

Missouri’s minimum wage rose from $5.15 to $6.50 an hour Jan. 1 as a result of a ballot measure approved last year by voters.

Supporters of the law said tipped employees were entitled to base pay of at least half that amount, or $3.25 an hour. But the state Department of Labor and Industrial Relations originally advised on a Web site that tipped employees were due only the federal minimum of $2.13 an hour, so long as their tips pushed their total pay to at least $6.50 an hour.

That changed March 14, when Gov. Matt Blunt declared that the department had gotten it wrong and ordered it to advise employers to pay $3.25 an hour to their tipped workers.

Several restaurants sued the labor department, seeking a declaration that the proper wage was $2.13 an hour, or alternatively asking that they be exempt from providing back pay at the $3.25 threshold between Jan. 1 and the date of Blunt’s decision.

Joyce rejected those arguments, dismissed the restaurants’ lawsuit and said tipped employees were due $3.25 an hour from Jan. 1 onward.

Mike Wiggins, owner of Granny Shaffer’s restaurants in Joplin and Webb City, was among those who filed the lawsuit. Wiggins said the judge invalidated the lawsuit, saying the restaurant owners didn’t have the authority to sue the labor department because it didn’t make the law, Missouri voters did. Wiggins said he cannot sue Missouri voters, so he’s not sure what to do next.

“We’re between a rock and a hard place,” Wiggins said Tuesday.

The suing restaurants “cannot take advantage of initially incorrect advice from the department, especially in the face of a contrary statute and regulation, to obtain legal sanction for insufficient wages paid to tipped employees who were entitled to the full benefit of the minimum wage law,” the judge said in her ruling.

St. Louis attorney John Renick, who represented the restaurants, said Tuesday that the ruling likely would be appealed.

Renick said it seemed inconsistent for the labor department to offer advice, then change it based on a governor’s order, then maintain that its advice really didn’t mean anything. If the law and regulation were so clear, the department should have just referred people to the language of the regulation instead of offering its initial interpretation, Renick said.

Wiggins said he hadn’t talked with his attorneys or the Missouri Restaurant Association. He said his options are appealing the decision to a higher court, filing a different lawsuit with a new defendant or forgetting the whole thing. He said he already has spent $75,000 on the lawsuit, and he isn’t sure how much more of his time and money the issue is worth.

As a result of the judge’s decision, the labor department plans to start investigating 21 complaints it has received about businesses not paying enough to tipped employees between Jan. 1 and March 14, said department spokeswoman Tammy Cavender.



print this story    email this story    comment on this story   

Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.


Add a comment on this story





monster
autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Click here!!

We Blog!
We Pod Cast!

We Twitter!

: Special Offer For New Subscribers : 32 buy 1 get 1 free offers

Click Here!

TV LIsitngs



Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!
Featured Jobs

LOCAL DRILLING COMPANY
needs a rock driller. Must have experience in hydraulics. Company vehicle provided. (417)662-7267...>MORE

DRIVERS WANTED
DRIVERS WANTED Drivers needed for Waste Corporation of Joplin, a growing company in the Joplin and surrounding areas. ...>MORE

ACCOUNTANT.

Expanding CPA firm: full time, degree/ computer skills required. Audit/tax experience preferred. Send resume to P
...>MORE

EMERGENCY SERVICE WORKER
EMERGENCY SERVICE WORKER/ EMERGENCY ROOM ADVOCATE Part-time position in women’s treatment/ trauma program. This positio...>MORE

LIFEGUARDS
All shifts available, Apply in person at either Joplin Family Y location.
www.joplinfamilyy.org.
...>MORE

TRUCK MECHANIC

needed for Waste Corporation of Joplin. Competitive pay and benefits package. Requires candidate to own hand tools
...>MORE

CHILD CARE WORKER
CHILD CARE WORKER Part-time position working with children 0-6 at Discovery Center childcare center. Day and evening h...>MORE

REVETER WANTED
EXPERIENCED for brake manufacturing. Please apply in person at 3215 E. 20th, Joplin, MO. ...>MORE

CNA AND CMT
CNA AND CMT Joplin Healthcare Center is looking for CMT for day 12 hour shift. Also a CNA for night 12 hours shift. Exc...>MORE

GREAT BUSINESS OPPORTUNITY
Located on US Business. 60
7 acres with 3 BR house on Hickory Creek
3 buildings with 20 10 x 15 units each
...>MORE

See all ads

Featured Transportation

1999 CHEVROLET TAHOE
2 door, 2 wheel drive, barn door rear, lowered, custom paint/grill/wheels, asking $5500. (417)781-1932, or cell (417)437...>MORE

2005 HONDA SHADOW VLX 600
2,000 miles, color white, $3950. (417)673-3860....>MORE

YAMAHA 1999 ROAD STAR
Yamaha, 1999 Road Star 1600 excellent condition, less than 10,000 miles, saddle bags and highway lamps. $3500. Cell phon...>MORE

NEED 2 DRIVERS
with 3 years plus $ miles with turn arounds back to Joplin, MO. Home often. 417-325-7320....>MORE

CHEVROLET 1997 TAHOE
CHEVROLET, 1997 TAHOE LT, 4X4, Maroon, air, excellent condition, leather seats, power everything, $2500 or best offer Pl...>MORE

1990 GMC HIGH SIERRA
short wide bed, 2 wheel drive, V-8, power windows/locks, air, CD, tinted windows, chrome wheels. $2,000 or best offer. (...>MORE

FORD 2001 ESCORT
FORD, 2001 Escort, 4 cylinder, automatic, good condition. $1800. (417)437-5682....>MORE

1957 CHEVROLET
2 door post, project, rust free Texas car, no motor or transmission, good Missouri title, $7500.
Bob 417-781-1932
...>MORE

LEXUS 2002 ES
LEXUS, 2002 ES 300, silver/gray leather, navigation, heated seats, second owner, 94,000 miles, $10,900. 620-856-2804, 41...>MORE

1979 CHEVROLET CORVETTE
350 automatic, $5000 or trade consider. (620)230-0459...>MORE

See all ads

Featured Homes

OPEN HOUSE
OPEN HOUSE 7/5/09 1:00-4:00 2281 sq. ft. Updated kitchen 4 br + bonus room 2 living areas Metal roof. Stapleton school ...>MORE

INVESTORS OR START-UP
INVESTORS OR START-UP 1217 Central. $67500 2 bedroom, 1 bath, very nice,room to build more. See more at homesbyowner.co...>MORE

OWNER FINANCE
OWNER FINANCE. $650 down, $435 monthly. 201 N. Washington, Joplin, 3 BR, garage, Full price $32,500. 417-359-4113. ...>MORE

LAKE FRONT MOBILE
Lake Front Mobile Grove, OK 1972 14 X 46 1 Bedroom, 1 bath lake front mobile home weekend getaway. Complete with furn...>MORE

OPEN HOUSE
405 Keeney Street, Carl Junction. Sunday July 12 • 2 p.m.-4 p.m.
This home is owned by Carl Junction R-1 School Di
...>MORE

HANDYMAN SPECIAL
Handyman Special, only $500 down, owner financing, 11% interest, $345/ month, priced at $23,900. 1120 W. 12th Street (41...>MORE

2-3 BR
Basement, newly remodeled, oak cabinets, nice wood floors, privacy fence. $79,200. 2525 N. Ozark. (417)483-0900....>MORE

See all ads

Other Cool Stuff

INDEPENDENCE DAY BLOW OUT SALE

20% off all grocery items
20% off all cleaning supply items
20% off all refrigerators, dishwashers, deep
...>MORE

PATTERN TORCH
Industrial, $500. (417)781-1932....>MORE

MINIATURE DACHSHUND PUPPIES
6 weeks old, $100. (417)781-4099....>MORE

LAB PUPPIES
lab puppies, AKC 1 chocolate male 1 chocolate female 1 black male 1 black female Master, senior, and junior hunters on ...>MORE

24' BAJA OUTLAW
24’ BAJA Outlaw beautiful closed bow boat, 454 Mag, all options, excellent condition, low hours with 2005 trailer, $16,0...>MORE

MALTIES PUPS
$150-$300; Yorkies, $300; Morkies-$200. 592-7827, leave message....>MORE

ATTEMPTING TO LOCATE
realitives of late father, Aziel Murphy, who married Maxine Steele, of Oklahoma, on June 10, 1929. Contact Tresa Collins...>MORE

AMPLIFIER
1953 Gibson BHR, $250. (417)437-9942....>MORE

YORKIE-CHORKIE
Yorkie-Chorkie, 6 weeks, weight 12 oz. and up. 417-358-4202....>MORE

MINI SCHNAUZERS
8 weeks AKC house breaking underway, vet checked/healthy. rsfieker@yahoo.com 417-235-3168....>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index

 

 

The Joplin Globe Electronic Edition