subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite map
Sun, Sep 07 2008 

Published July 18, 2008 10:58 pm - The mother of a man injured by police questioned police Chief Lane Roberts on Friday night about the use of Taser guns and other force in a case that resulted in the departure of one police officer and disciplining of two others.

Victim’s mother questions force used against son



By Debby Woodin

dwoodin@joplinglobe.com

The mother of a man injured by police questioned police Chief Lane Roberts on Friday night about the use of Taser guns and other force in a case that resulted in the departure of one police officer and disciplining of two others.

Questions about the injury of Joplin resident David Neal, 25, that resulted in the city paying a $5,000 settlement occupied the largest part of a neighborhood meeting staged by the Police Department.

The meeting was one of six the department is putting on this year to have open discussions about any issues residents want to talk about. This session was scheduled at the Jesus Headquarters church, 801 Central St.

Nearly 20 people attended the session. Among them was Angela Mitchell, the mother of Neal, who was injured April 20 when he resisted arrest.

The chief told Neal’s mother and the others that the officer who resigned, Homer Knisley, was generally regarded as a reliable and competent officer until he made the mistake of reacting to provocation and struck Neal inappropriately “whether it was accidental or not.”

The chief said he couldn’t discuss the specific act Knisley committed because it was a closed personnel matter.

But, he said, “It was a single incident in a six-year career” that will end Knisley’s career as a law-enforcement officer. He said that the state agency that certifies officers to work in law enforcement, the Police Officers’ Standards and Training (POST) Commission, will strip Knisley of his certification as a result of the excessive-force finding.

Knisley’s act against Neal followed an attempt by several police officers to arrest a combative Neal, according to police. Neal’s mother said at the meeting that Neal was intoxicated and under the influence of mood-altering drugs at the time of the altercation and his arrest during a traffic stop.

She questioned the police chief about witness statements that police used two Taser guns on Neal even when Neal held his arms out and was not moving. She also questioned the safety of using repeated Taser strikes to control a person. She said her son was struck in some areas of the body she regarded as dangerous, including the jugular vein and the temple of his head.

Roberts said officers are trained to try to strike the trunk of the body with the Taser, though the two points that dispense the electric charge can strike randomly. He said one of the Tasers malfunctioned, which prompted another officer to wield the second Taser. Neal was not struck by two Taser guns at once, the chief said.

He called on Lt. LaMonte Ratcliff, a black officer and the department’s excessive-force training officer, to discuss the use of the Taser and the use-of-force policy. Ratcliff said the officers use Tasers to avoid using more dangerous weapons like a metal club. He also said that use of force is guided by a policy developed from a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that allows enough force to be used to overcome the resistance. Force can be used if resistance doesn’t actually occur but a person’s demeanor suggests a threat to an officer, Ratcliff said.

Officers at the meeting were asked why they did not use arm or body holds solely to try to restrain Neal.

The chief said Neal was so forcefully combative that three officers could not control him by using traditional means. He said the use of Tasers and other force during the initial minutes of the arrest attempt on the street after a traffic stop were justifiable. It was after Neal was brought into the jail that the inappropriate use of force came from Knisley. Roberts did not specifically say why Knisley overreacted, except to say that an officer must resist the attempt to be provoked by name calling or actions of that type. Roberts said he could not publicly discuss the particular action that Knisley took that amounted to excessive force.



print this story    email this story    comment on this story   

Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.


Add a comment on this story





monster
wheels
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Get Our Free Pod Cast!

32 buy 1 get 1 free offers


Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!
Featured Jobs

RECEPTIONIST
part time. 20 hours per week (Saturday 8 a.m.-3 p.m./Sunday 8 a.m.-1 p.m. and fill in during the week). Phone, General A...>MORE

JOPLIN AREA LOCKSMITH BUSINESS FOR SALE
You get 2 fully equipped vans, 3 well known phone numbers, stock, EVERYTHING even training. $58,000 for all. (573)422-6...>MORE

GALENA CHILD CENTER
Galena Child Center now hiring part time help. (620)783-2349...>MORE

EXPERIENCED HELP IN FLOORING
and construction field, minimum of 4 years experience and clean personal background. Must have own transportation, clean...>MORE

DEL RIO
accepting management applications for immediate openings.
Great pay and benefits. Apply in person at any location.
...>MORE

REMODELING CARPENTER
Minimum 5 years experience. Must have tools and transportation. Call 417-262-4040 or fax resume to: 417-624-4201. ...>MORE

CLOUDS MEATS/MEAT CUTTER
CLOUDS MEAT’S Inc. is looking for a meat cutter, must have carcass and meat boning experience also retail/cold storage ...>MORE

SALES/CUSTOMER SERVICE
Full time person to handle phone orders, sales calls, customer questions, data entry, etc. for growing national nutraceu...>MORE

PRODUCTION TEAM MEMBER
This position requires good physical fitness, lifting up to 70 lbs, data logging and record keeping. Computer, forklift ...>MORE

DOMINOS PIZZA
of Webb City and Carthage are looking for friendly delivery experts. Must not be under 18, good driving record, car and ...>MORE

See all ads

Featured Transportation

STUDEBAKER
Studebaker, 1961 Lark VI, 4 door, 1 owner, 118,000 miles, very good exterior with new paint, original seat covers, good ...>MORE

GMC 1991 SIERRA 4X4
GMC, 1991 Sierra, 4x4, CD, truck box, 185,000 miles, $2500. (417)379-7601....>MORE

BUICK 1993 REGAL
low miles, cold air,
real nice, gas saver, $2450. (417)782-2151
...>MORE

MITSUBISHI 1998 3000 GT
MITSUBISHI, 1998 3000GT, pearl white, tan leather interior, $5,250, sharp car. (620)249-4969....>MORE

CHEVROLET 2005 IMPALA
1 owner, silver, 3.4L V6, 31 mpg, loaded, CD, more, mint condition. Sacrifice $8500. 540-8337....>MORE

1999 JEEP CHEROKEE CLASSIC
2 wheel drive, 66,000 miles. 417-434-3871....>MORE

1998 CHEVROLET S10
good tires, needs battery, $700. 417-434-0341....>MORE

FORD 2002 TAURUS
49,000 actual miles, super nice, loaded with options, must see to appreciate, $4800. 417-623-2011....>MORE

FORD 1987 F-250
Ford, 1987 F-250, 6.7, V8 automatic, 4x4, runs great, $850. (417)206-0930...>MORE

VOLKSWAGEN 1974 BEETLE
VOLKSWAGEN, 1974 Beetle, project, best offer. (417)782-3612....>MORE

See all ads

Featured Homes

IRON GATES
IRON GATES, 5+ building lots west of 23rd and Iron Gates Road. Selling as package. $27,500. 417-483-7883....>MORE

3 BR, 2 BA, WEBB CITY
3 BR, 2 ba, nice Webb City area, central air, garage, deck, hot tub, $640 month. 417-396-1781....>MORE

OPEN SUNDAY 9/7
OPEN Sunday 9/7 1:30-4:30 pm Completely REMODELED 512 Porter $64,900 Zero down to qualified buyers. 623-8166....>MORE

28X56 3 BR, 2 BA CARPET
28x56, 3 br, 2 ba, new carpet, all appliances, solid wood cabinets, $35,900. 417-869-5144....>MORE

OPEN SUNDAY 2 P.M.-4 P.M.
OPEN SUNDAY 2 P.M.-4 P.M., 2707 N. Ozark (North of Zora), large single story home with full finished walkout basement, a...>MORE

16x80 3 BR, 2 BA
16x80 3 br, 2 ba, vinyl/shingle, patio door, raised kitchen, large garden tub, Deliver/anchored. $21,900. 417-869-5144...>MORE

BEAUTIFUL, 8 YEAR OLD HOME
Beautiful 2035 sq. ft home, approximately 8 years old on corner lot in great neighborhood. 3-4 BR, bonus room, 2 full BA...>MORE

COMPLETELY REMODELED HOUSE
332 S. Ball, Webb City, accessible to Joplin and near 171 Highway. 1450 sq. ft. with 3 br, 2 ba, new appliances, central...>MORE

28X80 1999 5 BR 3 BA
28X80 1999 5 br, 3 ba, fireplace, needs new sheet rock and some work, $28,900 CASH. 417-869-5144....>MORE

OPEN HOUSE/2904 N. FORREST COURT
OPEN HOUSE SUNDAY 2-4 P.M., Drive by 2904 N. Forrest Court off N. St. Louis and Zora and view this newly constructed hom...>MORE

See all ads

Other Cool Stuff

BEAUTY SHOP EQUIPMENT
for sale (417)206-7859 or evenings 620-742-0740....>MORE

MINIATURE SCHNAUZER
Miniature Schnauzer puppy! AKC ,Salt and pepper female! Up to date on vaccinations and dewormings, tail docked, dew claw...>MORE

20' CHALLENGER CAR TRAILER
20’ CHALLENGER car trailer, 2007, Diamond treaded, partially enclosed, $4200 or best offer. (417)439-5330....>MORE

1000'S OF BOOKS
1,000’S BOOKS, videos, records, 50¢ each. Joplin, (417)623-3553....>MORE

EXTRA GOOD USED LUMBER
Extra good used 2x6’s, 4’ to 20’, no knots, .50¢ a foot, 4129 Missouri. (417)623-9989...>MORE

FREE TO GOOD HOME/LAB
Free to good home full blooded chocolate Lab, 3 years old, full of energy, very family friendly. Please call (417)214-52...>MORE

SHIH-TZU PUPPIES
Shih-Tzu PUPPIES, registered, wormed, shots, dew claws removed. 417-629-4371....>MORE

GOOD QUALITY MIXED GRASS HAY
GOOD QUALITY mixed grass 4x5 net wrapped round bales, $30/bale picked up. Leave message, 417-624-6484, 417-592-4636....>MORE

UNIQUE PIT BULL PUPS
UNIQUE pure bred Pit Bull pups, family friendly, variety of ages and prices, chocolates and whites. 417-358-2148....>MORE

HOT TUB 2008
60 actual water jets, 12 h.p., stereo package, LED mood lighting, therapy seat, full manufacturers warranty, cost $9,600...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2008. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index

 

 

Find A Home Find A Car