Some people overthink TV advertising.
It seems to me that if you want to sell a product on TV, you hold up whatever it is you’re selling, and tell people it’s good and explain why it’s good. If people believe you, then your commercial worked. If they don’t, it didn’t.
The thing is, the best way to sell something — again it seems to me — is to be confident that what you’re selling is worth selling. If you’re not confident, you have to resort to what a former TV boss of mine used to call “weasel words.” When you resort to those, it’s easier to overthink your advertising strategy.
One of the most famous cases of overthinking advertising strategy occurred in the 1960s, when some ad agency folks thought it would make a cool commercial if they put a car they were trying to sell on a tall rock tower in some desert out west. It did make for a cool commercial, but there was one problem: Everyone was so taken by the fact that someone was able to get a car on the rock tower that no one could remember anything about the car except that it was on the tower.
That’s overthinking your advertising strategy.
I mention this because lately I’ve been seeing another car commercial in which, I think, advertising strategy has been overthought.
Although I’ve seen the commercial many times in the past few weeks, I have no idea who makes the car, which is sort of a problem.
In the commercial, the car is carrying four people. A guy in the passenger seat looks at the woman driving and says, “We’re going to be late!” The woman smiles, says that they won’t be late, puts the car in gear, drives a few feet and then somehow makes the car fly through the air and land on a train. Because the car is riding on top of a train, the driver beats all the traffic and gets to her company parking lot in time for work.
The first time I saw the commercial, I remember thinking: “Wow, that car can fly and land on a train. I need to get two of those.”
But, the second time I saw the commercial, I noticed a message on the bottom of the screen. The message said something like this: “Cars can’t land on trains. Don’t try this.”
At first I was disappointed, because I had always wanted to land a car on a train and ride it across town. But then I was sort of irritated. I thought to myself: Why would someone make a commercial that basically says, “You should buy this car because it can ride on the top of a train,” and then, in the same commercial, say, “Cars can’t ride on trains”?
Have you ever seen a commercial where a guy in a bar orders a beer, takes a few sips and then suddenly starts flying around fighting crime like Superman while an announcer says, “Drink Super Suds. It will make you fly like Superman,” while at the same time a message appears on the screen that says, “People can’t fly like Superman. Don’t try this”?
Of course not. And do you know why you haven’t seen a commercial like that? Because it would be stupid, that’s why. And there would also be a liability issue because sometimes people who drink too much beer do really stupid things.
But I think you get my point.
Now, if there are any advertising executives out there who disagree with this column and feel an urge to dash off a nasty email, you probably should stop for a second.
You’re overthinking this column.
DO YOU HAVE AN IDEA for Mike Pound’s column? Call him at 417-623-3480, ext. 7259, or email him at email@example.com. Follow him on Twitter @mikepoundglobe.
Some people overthink TV advertising.
- Local News
Carthage board member arrested on DWI charge
Mark Westhoff, a member of the Carthage School Board, was arrested on a misdemeanor charge of driving while intoxicated early Sunday in Newton County.
Carl Junction Chamber to manage annual bluegrass festival
After 17 years, Carl Junction’s annual bluegrass festival is changing.
Deadly hog virus arrives in Missouri; experts forecast higher pork prices this summer
Hog farms across Missouri have been struck by porcine epidemic diarrhea, a fast-spreading virus that can kill 80 percent of piglets that contract it. In some cases, entire nurseries containing thousands of piglets have been wiped out overnight.
Jo Ellis: Emily Newell Blair’s autobiography offers insight on region, national affairs
Congratulations to the students, teachers and judges who took part in History Day on Friday. I was happy to see Carthage High School students carry home prizes, especially in the senior divisions. I was impressed with the wide range of entries based on the theme of rights and responsibilities, but I disappointed that I didn’t see anything related to women’s rights.
Baseball team naming contest continues; announcement to be made at end of March
oplin’s new independent baseball team still is nameless, but not for long. Owners have extended the contest through this month and will make an announcement on the new team name at the end of the month, said Shawn Suarez, a partner in the team’s ownership group, WLD Suarez LLC. The original deadline had been March 4.
Kansas lawmaker seeks to limit fees charged for public record requests
A proposal to limit fees that state and local government agencies in Kansas can charge people who seek public records cleared the state Senate last week and is awaiting approval from the Kansas House of Representatives.
Area businesses cater to market for replica, restored classic cars
In 2007, a 1966 Shelby Cobra sports car sold at auction for $5.5 million. If that’s too rich for your blood, Barry McGill has a couple of options. You can buy a replica built by McGill Manufacturing for around $40,000 or a kit car for even less.
Andra Bryan Stefanoni: Pittsburg native marching to beat of his own drums
Once upon a time, there was a man named Milo Sharp, a longtime area music teacher, high school band director, instrument repairman and piano tuner. He and his piano-playing wife, Katie, had four children: first Frances, then Craig, then Gayleen and finally Derek. They named them so that with their initials — I am not making this up — they would be F. Sharp, C. Sharp, G. Sharp and D. Sharp.
Susan Redden: Secretary of state pushing for OK for early voting
Secretary of State Jason Kander said last week he still is hopeful that the Missouri General Assembly will consider changes in state election law that he believes would make it easier for residents to make their choices at election time.
MAP: Construction in area tops $1 billion since 2011 tornado
Recovery began the morning after the tornado. Now, approximately 34 months later, Joplin and Duquesne have broken through a barrier that looked a long way off on the evening of May 22, 2011. As it stands now, Joplin has racked up $997.3 million in repairs and new construction across all categories.
- More Local News Headlines
- Carthage board member arrested on DWI charge