The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO

Local News

March 27, 2013

Groups explain arguments for, against gay marriage

As the Supreme Court on Wednesday wrapped up two days of arguments on gay marriage, residents and regional groups laid out their own reasons for supporting or opposing the issue.

Jennifer Katzer, a junior English major and president of the gay-straight alliance at Pittsburg (Kan.) State University, said she supports legalizing gay marriage. Addressing one of the issues considered by the court, Katzer said gay and lesbian couples who want to be married should have the same right to financial and social benefits that married heterosexual couples have. The disparity creates an unbalanced social system, she said.

“Without the legalization of gay marriage, people in the U.S. have, more or less, social permission to treat LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender) people as second-class citizens,” she said.

Katzer said many gay and lesbian couples have strong personal reasons for wanting their union to be legal. Among them, she said, are the desires to validate a defined relationship and to place the same meaning on their relationship that married heterosexual couples place on theirs. That kind of acceptance from society can be critical for same-sex couples, she said.

“There’s the benefit of sitting in a room and having your family members and friends ask about your ceremony or your honeymoon,” she said. “It’s feeling like your union matters within the community, and that it makes a difference with your family and friends. You can say you have been together for 50 years, but it doesn’t have the same connotation as being married for 50 years.”

Additionally, Katzer said, the legal paperwork issued to a married couple by the government would serve a number of practical purposes, including protecting a couple’s children should one parent die and allowing individuals to have family access to their partners in a case such as a hospital visit.

Focus on the Family, a Christian organization based in Colorado Springs, Colo., supports marriage as between one man and one woman, spokeswoman Carrie Gordon Earll said. She said the organization is concerned primarily about gay marriage’s impact on children.

“Biology gives every child a mother and a father, and we need to pay attention to that because the research for decades has found children do best when they’re raised by their married mother and father,” she said.

She also said the group thinks the legalization of same-sex marriages could infringe upon the First Amendment rights of small businesses or individuals who could be required to do business with gay or lesbian couples despite having religious beliefs that don’t support gay marriage.

Earll said the legalization of gay marriage would have a “ripple effect” across the country.

“It redefines marriage for everybody, and that includes people who hold a conservative biblical view or a moral view,” she said. “This doesn’t prevent any adult from having any relationship they want; it’s about how is government going to define marriage.”

Phillip Cosby, state director of the Christian-based American Family Association of Kansas and Missouri, said his organization also supports “traditional marriage” between one man and one woman, as mentioned in the Bible. He voiced a concern expressed Tuesday by Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, who had cautioned against a broad ruling in favor of gay marriage because the issue is “newer than cellphones or the Internet.”

“To rush in and embrace it (gay marriage) would be an error,” Cosby said. “We don’t even know the long-term effects yet.”

But Katzer said she holds out hope that same-sex marriages will one day be legalized nationwide.

“No matter what they (Supreme Court justices) rule, it will set up a pattern of ruling for future cases,” she said. “I am hoping they will rule in favor of same-sex marriage and same-sex love because even if it doesn’t change the United States now, it could potentially change the course for how future rulings will go.”

Missouri voters overwhelmingly adopted a constitutional amendment in 2004 defining marriage as between a man and a woman, and voters in Oklahoma that year approved a constitutional ban on same-sex marriages. The following year, voters in Kansas approved a similar constitutional amendment barring gay marriage.

Text Only
Local News
  • Ballot issues dominate GOP event

    A maze of campaign yard signs lined the sidewalk at Big Spring Park, leading up to a line of local candidates for public office with rolled-up sleeves shaking hands with potential voters.

    July 24, 2014

  • Mike Pound: It’s time for some football

    The arrests, the announced suspensions and the contract disputes can mean only one thing: Somebody is ready for some football.

    July 24, 2014

  • Landfill opponents seek answers

    The Baxter Springs High School auditorium was filled with hundreds of Cherokee County residents Thursday night as Galena city officials answered questions and listened to comments regarding a proposed landfill at Riverton.

    July 24, 2014

  • Hanaway says leadership missing under Gov. Nixon

    When Republican gubernatorial hopeful Catherine Hanaway walked into the banquet room at Granny Shaffer’s Restaurant this week, she was greeted by some of Joplin’s more prominent business leaders.

    July 24, 2014

  • Neosho athletes bring home silver

    For 19-year-old Dominque Dechant, it was the trip of a lifetime. She and three other athletes from Neosho traveled last month to Newark, New Jersey, as part of the Missouri Special Olympics girls basketball team.

    July 24, 2014

  • r072414msw.jpg VIDEO: Carterville company expands to third generation

    What began as Ray “Mac” McCoy’s side job in his home 55 years ago has grown not only in square footage and reach, but in generations. This summer, a third generation took over the reins of MSW — Mac’s Specialty Woodwork — that now exceeds 90,000 square feet and creates custom furniture for chain restaurants coast to coast.

    July 24, 2014 2 Photos

  • Shrine Bowl band, cheerleaders, players arrive in Pittsburg this week

    Band members were the first Kansas Shrine Bowl participants to arrive at Pittsburg State University this week.

    July 24, 2014

  • Galena council rescinds landfill decisions

    The Galena City Council voted Wednesday to rescind decisions it made two weeks ago regarding a proposed landfill at Riverton.

    July 23, 2014

  • Miami council waives fees for barbecue event

    The Miami City Council voted Tuesday to waive $3,750 in usage fees for Miami Elks Lodge No. 1320 for an upcoming barbecue championship at the Miami Fairgrounds.

    July 23, 2014

  • Carthage prepares for Marian Days

    The 37th annual Marian Days celebration will start in two weeks, and planning is well under way for the event that will bring tens of thousands of Catholics of Vietnamese descent to Carthage.

    July 23, 2014

Must Read
Sports
Photos


Facebook
Poll

Amendment 8 in Missouri proposes a special lottery ticket to help fund state veterans homes. How will you vote?

For it.
Against it.
     View Results
Opinion
Twitter Updates
Follow us on twitter