The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO

Local News

December 29, 2012

Nation debates impact of violent video games

JOPLIN, Mo. — On a question put front and center by the recent mass shooting in Newtown, Conn., Nickie Humphrey and Ben Hinkle find themselves on opposite sides.

Humphrey, of Joplin, believes that constant exposure to violent video games is part of the problem.

“These things play a part in the progression of already-seeded issues some people may have,” Humphrey said. “They trigger an area of the brain regarding violence.

“These games, in my opinion, are a continuous onslaught to that area of the brain, and it’s not healthy.”

Hinkle, a former Missouri Southern State University student who is now a law student at Washburn University in Topeka, Kan., doesn’t believe video games should be blamed.

He noted that “Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3” sold more than 6.5 million copies within 24 hours of its launch. It broke $1 billion in sales in 16 days.

“You have probably 10 million people playing it, and two of them shot some people,” Hinkle said. “Run the percentages on that, and you will see that the percentage of gamers who decide to kill is much smaller than the percentage of nongamers who kill. Not a real issue.”

Humphrey and Hinkle were responding to a Globe online survey about the impact of violent video games. Their debate reflects not only the arguments being heard around the country, but also the passion.

Brad Bushman and Chris Ferguson are on opposite sides of the argument, too.

“Violent video games increase aggressive thoughts through physiological arousal,” Bushman said.

He is a professor of mass communication at Ohio State University. He was one of eight scholars from the United States and Japan who published an analysis in 2010 of dozens of studies conducted around the world into the effects of violent games on players’ behavior.

“Concerning public policy, we believe that debates can and should finally move beyond the simple question of whether violent video game play is a causal risk factor for aggressive behavior,” their analysis concluded. “The scientific literature has effectively and clearly shown the answer to be ‘yes.’”

The public debate “should move to questions concerning how best to deal with this risk factor,” the report said.

“People who have aggressive thoughts are much more likely to have aggressive behavior,” Bushman said. “This makes people numb to the pain and suffering of others.”

Ferguson, too, is an expert. He teaches in Texas A&M University’s Department of Behavioral, Applied Sciences and Criminal Justice. He thinks Bushman and his colleagues should not be so quick to declare the impact of violent video games as definitive. He thinks the 2010 analysis is flawed.

“There was a selection bias,” Ferguson said. “He (Bushman) and his colleagues didn’t include many studies that did not find any effects from violent media.”

Ferguson led a review of other scientific studies that he published in 2009 in the Journal of Pediatrics. He determined that “results from the current analysis do not support the conclusion that media violence leads to aggressive behavior. It cannot be concluded at this time that media violence presents a significant public health risk.”

The public debate, he concluded, would be better focused on other issues that may be triggers for violent behavior.

But Bushman said experiments demonstrate that a person who plays violent video games three days in a row shows more aggressive and hostile behavior than people who don’t play. It’s not certain what the impact would be on people who play these games for years because such testing “isn’t practical or ethical,” he said.

‘Shadow industry’

It’s still unclear what or even if any games were played by Adam Lanza, the 20-year-old Newtown shooter, but investigators are reviewing his gaming habits, and online and cellphone records for game purchases.

The CEO of the National Rifle Association, Wayne LaPierre, says it’s time that the country focus on the issue.

“There exists in this country a callous, corrupt and corrupting shadow industry that sells, and sows, violence against its own people,” he said at a Dec. 21 news conference. He cited video games “with names like ‘Bulletstorm,’ ‘Grand Theft Auto,’ ‘Mortal Kombat’ and ‘Splatterhouse.’ And here’s one: It’s called ‘Kindergarten Killers.’ It has been online for 10 years.”

He also criticized violent movies such as “Natural Born Killers” and added: “Isn’t fantasizing about killing people as a way to get your kicks really the filthiest form of pornography?”

Kevin Martin, of Joplin, disagrees.

“Blaming videos is no different than blaming guns,” he argued. “If video games are to blame, then how do you account for the millions of gamers who play those games and do not commit violent crimes?”

Eric Steele, of Carl Junction, said he considers himself a supporter of the Second Amendment. He said he supports the NRA, but he doesn’t like LaPierre’s argument.

“I am concerned about certain positions they, and many others ... have taken,” he said. “Recent statements have shown them willing to sacrifice freedoms in a desperate attempt to save the Second Amendment. While we must protect the Second Amendment, I will not advocate restricting the First Amendment by pushing for controls in the entertainment industry.”

‘Played out’

After the shooting in Newtown, some of the surviving children in that community threw away video games containing violent scenes and set up bins so others could do the same. They called their effort “Played Out: Choose Not to Play.”

An organization called GamerFitNation called for a one-day “cease-fire,” asking video game players to refrain from playing violent video games on the one-week anniversary of the Newtown shootings.

And U.S. Sen. Jay Rockefeller, D-W.Va., has asked the National Academy of Sciences to look at the impact of violent video games and movies on children.

“Some people still do not get it,” Rockefeller said. “They believe that violent video games are no more dangerous to young minds than classic literature or Saturday morning cartoons. Parents, pediatricians and psychologists know better.”

He also called on the Federal Trade Commission and the Federal Communications Commission to review the effectiveness of video game ratings.

Parental role

At Vintage Stock’s Northpark Mall location, manager Brandon Bond sees the issue not only from a gamer’s and retailer’s perspective, but also as a parent.

He said he has worked with the Entertainment Software Rating Board system since its inception, and noted that the industry is taking steps to govern the problem.

“I feel that we are a step ahead of the movie rating system in the way that there is a clearer age bracket separation,” Bond said. “Factor in that there are clear details on the back explaining exactly what caused this game to be rated the way it was.”

The ESRB rating system is voluntary, though virtually every game sold at retail is rated. But while the games are rated, the U.S. Supreme Court also has ruled that states cannot ban the sale of violent video games to children without parental supervision, which is what California tried to do in 2005.

“Our policy here at Vintage Stock is set in stone,” Bond said. “If it is a mature game, we do not sell to underage kids, period.”

Ultimately, Bond said, much of this lies in the hands of parents, who may have the most important role to play in the debate.

He said he attempts to educate parents when they inquire about the content of games and encourages them to hold a dialogue with their children on what they play.

“Parents have to play the biggest role in what their kids play, not the retailers,” Bond said. “There has to be a dialogue on what is age appropriate and what isn’t or all the ratings in the world won’t matter.”

THE ASSOCIATED PRESS and Scripps Howard News Service contributed to this report.

1
Text Only
Local News
  • Pension funding improving, actuary reports

    An extra $1 million contribution by the city of Joplin last year to the Police and Firemen’s Pension Fund boosted the funding ratio of the plan by 2 percent, the plan’s actuary told the board Thursday morning.

    April 17, 2014

  • Special counsel to be appointed in ethics complaint against Neosho council members

    The Neosho Ethics Board on Wednesday voted to ask the City Council to appoint a special counsel to provide legal advice to the board’s remaining two members as they investigate a complaint against two members of the council.

    April 17, 2014

  • Mike Pound 2010.jpg Mike Pound: Will new Earth-like planet have better cable offerings?

    When I read that astronomers have discovered the most Earth-like planet yet, I had a couple of deep scientific questions. First: What’s the Wi-Fi like? And: Are their TV channels better than ours? Hey, I didn’t get an “Incomplete” in college astronomy for nothing.

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Christian ministry plans Missouri camp expansion

    A nondenominational Christian ministry is planning a $21.5 million expansion on land it owns near Table Rock Lake in southwest Missouri, with a goal of offering gatherings beyond the traditional summer camps.

    April 17, 2014

  • 041714 School safe rooms4_72.jpg Joplin school district readies community safe rooms for storm season

    Thousands of Joplin residents will soon be able to stay safe during storms in some of the region’s newest shelters. Community safe rooms at Cecil Floyd, Stapleton, McKinley and Eastmorland elementary schools, which double as gymnasiums, and Junge Field, which will double as a field house, are expected to be open within the next few weeks, according to Mike Johnson, the school district’s director of construction.

    April 17, 2014 2 Photos

  • 041714 Treble Makers.jpg Carl Junction ‘Treble Makers’ to sing at Springfield Cardinals’ stadium

    Next month, 75 Carl Junction sixth-grade students will sing “The Star-Spangled Banner” at Hammons Field before a Springfield Cardinals game. And with more than 600 parents, family members and other residents planning to attend, the May 3 event has been dubbed “Carl Junction Day.”

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Public hearing set on posed TIF district

    Financial details of a proposed new tax increment financing district for the Silver Creek Galleria area will be discussed in detail at an April 28 public hearing, members of the city’s TIF Commission were told Thursday. Chris Williams, a TIF attorney representing the city of Joplin, told the panel the Thursday meeting was intended to walk commissioners through the public hearing steps.

    April 17, 2014

  • Volunteer projects spark two bills in Jefferson City

     moving through the Missouri House and Senate were inspired by a volunteer project in Carl Junction last year that stalled over a question of whether those volunteers had to be paid prevailing wage under Missouri law. “This bill is very simple. All it says is if someone is a volunteer, they won’t be forced to be paid prevailing wage,” state Rep. Charlie Davis, R-Webb City, told lawmakers during a hearing on his bill last week.

    April 17, 2014

  • Chairman of Neosho Ethics Board resigns

    The chairman of the Neosho Ethics Board unexpectedly resigned on Thursday as the board investigates a complaint against Neosho City Council members David Ruth and Steve Hart.

    April 17, 2014

  • CWEP receives top honor from national power group

    The Carthage Water and Electric Plant has received the top award for reliable electrical service from the American Public Power Association.

    April 17, 2014

Must Read
Sports
Photos


Facebook
Poll

Would you use a community safe room when the area is under a tornado warning?

Yes.
No.
     View Results
Opinion
Twitter Updates
Follow us on twitter