The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO

Local News

April 8, 2013

Legal battle between Neosho, TDD has cost more than $250,000

Legal expenses likely to climb

NEOSHO, Mo. — The city of Neosho and the Neosho Transportation Development District so far have spent more than a quarter-million dollars combined of taxpayer money in their legal battle with each other.

There may be more to come.

The city has spent $55,228.10, according to documents obtained through a Missouri open-records law request by the Globe.

Invoices from the St. Louis law firm Cunningham, Vogel and Rost list amounts of $32,116.47; $988.47; $9,795.27; $11,158.14; and $1,169.75. The invoices began on Aug. 31, 2012, and ended on Dec. 31. The Globe request had included any expenses through February of this year.

City officials requested a formal open-records request when they were asked about the legal fees.

The TDD, meanwhile, has spent $205,551.68 on legal fees, according to information provided by Chairman Ray Stipp. The TDD didn’t require a formal, written, open-records request.

The legal fight has caused the Missouri Department of Transportation to halt plans for nearly $7 million worth of proposed TDD projects. The costs would be shared, with the TDD paying $4.5 million financed by a half-cent sales tax within the district and MoDOT paying $2.4 million.

The TDD began collecting the tax in January 2012 from sales within the district, which includes the Wal-Mart Supercenter, Lowe’s and other retailers.

The proposed projects are along a retail area of U.S. Highway 60. Only a project to install a traffic signal and make other improvements at U.S. Highway 60 and Kodiak Road has begun.

Legal challenges

The city last year in Newton County Circuit Court challenged the formation of the TDD, alleging that the district was formed under the wrong state statute and that the statute under which it was formed allows only residential owners within the TDD to be voters. The Neosho TDD, formed in 2010, is a retail area with no permanent residents.

Associate Circuit Judge Kevin Selby in November ruled against the city, saying that the city had waited too long to challenge the TDD’s formation.

The city also had contested an election in July 2012 of TDD board members, with the election decided by those who own property within the boundaries of the district. Property owners receive a vote for each acre of land within the district.

A judge in August ordered the TDD to redo that election, ruling that adequate notice for the election wasn’t provided. He also ruled that the Missouri Highways and Transportation Commission, which governs the Missouri Department of Transportation, shouldn’t have participated in the July election.

In that election, incumbent board member Jim Cummins defeated Steve Roark, who was backed by the Neosho City Council. Roark fell short by 58 votes, but city leaders took issue with the 93 votes that were cast by the state highway commission.

The TDD was ordered to hold the election again, without the highway commission’s participation this time. Roark was chosen in the second election.

Neosho Mayor Richard Davidson said that when the city’s attorneys concluded that the state law regarding the TDD contained the flaw, the city couldn’t pretend that it wasn’t there and had to take action.

“The right people didn’t vote for that tax,” he said, referring to the vote in September 2011, in which the property owners within the boundaries imposed the half-cent sales tax on shoppers within the district.

Davidson said the city offered compromises that would have limited the legal expenses for both sides, including restructuring the TDD as a community improvement district. A CID generally involves property owners in the district paying a fee that funds projects and activities.

“It’s unfortunate that we had to spend that amount of money,” Davidson said. “If the TDD had accepted some of the compromises, we wouldn’t have had to.”

Roark said the TDD board accepted one of the city’s offers, but the City Council wouldn’t allow the TDD to continue while the CID was being established.

Roark also said the TDD was defending itself from the city’s challenge.

“The city literally challenged the whole existence of the TDD,” he said. “It’s expensive to litigate. The city of Neosho, they also have incurred fairly significant costs. It’s too bad we’ve had to spend the money we’ve spent.”

Future legal costs

The legal battles apparently are not over. Both sides are considering filing — and may be facing — additional lawsuits.

The city is considering appealing the November court ruling that allowed the TDD to continue. It faces an April 18 deadline.

“There has not been a conversation on the appeal that doesn’t include the cost,” Davidson said. “We are conscious that this could be an expensive measure.”

The TDD board, meanwhile, is considering a lawsuit against any attorneys or firms that were involved in doing the work that set up the TDD initially, Roark said. Such a lawsuit would be filed to try to recover the TDD’s legal expenses.

Roark said that if there is a flaw in the creation of the TDD, the attorneys who were involved in its creation could be held responsible.

“We also believe we have a fiduciary responsibility to the taxpayers who pay the tax on this,” Roark said. “We could have avoided almost all of this.”

A third source of legal costs for both sides could be a taxpayer lawsuit proposed against the Neosho TDD. The Globe had incorrectly reported last week that an unidentified taxpayer was threatening a lawsuit against a TDD in another jurisdiction.

Joplin attorney Bill Fleischaker said he has been contacted by a person who has paid sales tax within the Neosho district about filing a lawsuit challenging the local TDD.

Fleischaker said because of his full schedule, he may not get to the lawsuit for a few weeks. He said he didn’t know his potential client’s motivation. He also said he hasn’t contacted anyone with the city or with the TDD about his plans.

Davidson has cited the lawsuit threat as the reason the City Council has delayed making a decision on appealing the November court ruling.

Next election

THE NEOSHO TRANSPORTATION DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT will hold an election for two members of its board of directors at 3 p.m. Tuesday, April 30, at the Neosho Area Chamber of Commerce office.

Text Only
Local News
  • Pension funding improving, actuary reports

    An extra $1 million contribution by the city of Joplin last year to the Police and Firemen’s Pension Fund boosted the funding ratio of the plan by 2 percent, the plan’s actuary told the board Thursday morning.

    April 17, 2014

  • Special counsel to be appointed in ethics complaint against Neosho council members

    The Neosho Ethics Board on Wednesday voted to ask the City Council to appoint a special counsel to provide legal advice to the board’s remaining two members as they investigate a complaint against two members of the council.

    April 17, 2014

  • Mike Pound 2010.jpg Mike Pound: Will new Earth-like planet have better cable offerings?

    When I read that astronomers have discovered the most Earth-like planet yet, I had a couple of deep scientific questions. First: What’s the Wi-Fi like? And: Are their TV channels better than ours? Hey, I didn’t get an “Incomplete” in college astronomy for nothing.

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Christian ministry plans Missouri camp expansion

    A nondenominational Christian ministry is planning a $21.5 million expansion on land it owns near Table Rock Lake in southwest Missouri, with a goal of offering gatherings beyond the traditional summer camps.

    April 17, 2014

  • 041714 School safe rooms4_72.jpg Joplin school district readies community safe rooms for storm season

    Thousands of Joplin residents will soon be able to stay safe during storms in some of the region’s newest shelters. Community safe rooms at Cecil Floyd, Stapleton, McKinley and Eastmorland elementary schools, which double as gymnasiums, and Junge Field, which will double as a field house, are expected to be open within the next few weeks, according to Mike Johnson, the school district’s director of construction.

    April 17, 2014 2 Photos

  • 041714 Treble Makers.jpg Carl Junction ‘Treble Makers’ to sing at Springfield Cardinals’ stadium

    Next month, 75 Carl Junction sixth-grade students will sing “The Star-Spangled Banner” at Hammons Field before a Springfield Cardinals game. And with more than 600 parents, family members and other residents planning to attend, the May 3 event has been dubbed “Carl Junction Day.”

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Public hearing set on posed TIF district

    Financial details of a proposed new tax increment financing district for the Silver Creek Galleria area will be discussed in detail at an April 28 public hearing, members of the city’s TIF Commission were told Thursday. Chris Williams, a TIF attorney representing the city of Joplin, told the panel the Thursday meeting was intended to walk commissioners through the public hearing steps.

    April 17, 2014

  • Volunteer projects spark two bills in Jefferson City

    Bills moving through the Missouri House and Senate were inspired by a volunteer project in Carl Junction last year that stalled over a question of whether those volunteers had to be paid prevailing wage under Missouri law. “This bill is very simple. All it says is if someone is a volunteer, they won’t be forced to be paid prevailing wage,” state Rep. Charlie Davis, R-Webb City, told lawmakers during a hearing on his bill last week.

    April 17, 2014

  • Chairman of Neosho Ethics Board resigns

    The chairman of the Neosho Ethics Board unexpectedly resigned on Thursday as the board investigates a complaint against Neosho City Council members David Ruth and Steve Hart.

    April 17, 2014

  • CWEP receives top honor from national power group

    The Carthage Water and Electric Plant has received the top award for reliable electrical service from the American Public Power Association.

    April 17, 2014

Must Read


Would you use a community safe room when the area is under a tornado warning?

     View Results
Twitter Updates
Follow us on twitter