JOPLIN, Mo. —
Cities face another round of litigation regarding disputes over the collection of sales taxes on wireless telephone services.
Previous lawsuits sought payments of local taxes on land-line and cellular telephone service. This time the lawsuit involves taxes imposed by AT&T Mobility on Internet services, which the cities have refused to refund.
This lawsuit is filed on behalf of consumers who were required to pay sales taxes on Internet services, which the suit alleges are illegal taxes.
There are more than 250 cities and St. Louis County named in the lawsuit filed Jan. 4 in U.S. District Court at Kansas City, although the petition says there may be others too numerous to list. Those cities in Southwest Missouri named are Aurora, Butterfield, Carl Junction, Carthage, Joplin, Monett, Neosho, Nevada, Pierce City and Webb City.
Joplin’s city attorney, Brian Head, said the lawsuit has not been served yet on all the cities, but he is aware that there has been a filing. Once the city is served, he said, “we’ll be reviewing it and considering our options, but we intend to defend it vigorously.”
A Jefferson City consumer, Bert Kimble, is the first listed plaintiff in the lawsuit that was filed as a class action on behalf of all Internet access customers of AT&T Mobility.
The lawsuit contends that federal law, the Internet Tax Federal Act, has prohibited imposing taxes for Internet access. The lawsuit states that Missouri has excluded Internet access from the definition of telecommunications services subject to state and city sales taxes since 1998.
According to the petition, the cities enacted ordinances imposing business license taxes on the telecommunications companies several years ago, before 2005, and the cellphone companies refused to pay the taxes, contending they were not telecommunications companies because they provided wireless services rather than traditional wired services. The cities filed lawsuits.
Then the Missouri Legislature enacted a law defining cellphone companies as telecommunication services, which resolved the basis for the lawsuits. That law reduced the business license taxes to make them revenue neutral so that they did not violate the Hancock Amendment, which prohibits tax increases without a vote of the people. However, the law was challenged and parts of it were invalidated.
As a result, the cities and the cellphone companies negotiated settlements with cities and St. Louis County on the taxes.
The new lawsuit contends that as a result of the settlements, companies such as Verizon, Sprint, T-Mobile, and U.S. Cellular did not tax Internet access in keeping with the law but that AT&T did assess taxes.
Additionally, the AT&T settlement agreements allowed it to charge its customers for the back-tax settlement and future tax payments, although customers were not a party to the lawsuits or the settlements and had no say in the decision. Those charges ranged from 50 cents to $1.99, which AT&T had said it never collected from customers.
Subsequently, a nationwide consumer class action suit was filed and settled, and AT&T Mobility quit collecting local and state taxes on Internet access in 2010. AT&T was required to request refunds from the cities of the taxes paid on Internet services but the cities have refused to give refunds, the lawsuit contends.
AT&T customers are the only cellphone and wireless users who have had to the pay the tax on Internet access, according to the lawsuit.
Tax disputes
Joplin in 2009 and 2010 received settlements of approximately $983,000 from land-line providers for taxes owed and about $2.175 million from cellphone services. The money has been used on projects such as repair and renovation of Schifferdecker Golf Course.
Carthage received about $189,000 from land-line companies and $250,000 from cell companies. Neosho received $178,000 from land-line providers and about $220,000 from cellular companies. Webb City received $341,000 in back taxes from cell companies.
Local News
Lawsuit filed against Missouri cities over Internet taxes
- Local News
-
-
Joplin sends team to help Moore
A team of public safety workers from Joplin were deployed Monday night to assist in Moore, Okla.
-
Two plead guilty to post-tornado wire theft
Two defendants pleaded guilty Monday to stealing copper wire from utility poles in the wake of the May 22, 2011, tornado that struck Joplin. Timothy M. Silveria, 45, of Joplin, and Nycoa K. Kracht, 32, of Laurel, Ind., entered open pleas of guilty in Jasper County Circuit Court to felony counts of theft from a public utility.
-
Vandals cause $37,000 in damage at Joplin business
A Joplin business owner was the victim of a weekend vandalism spree that resulted in an estimated $37,000 in damages and theft, in addition to putting the company out of service for at least two days.
-
Mike Pound: My wife hid the clutter so well, I may be missing
OK, now I’m worried. Late Sunday afternoon, my wife announced that she was going to clean up our kitchen and our family room. When she made that announcement, our 15-year-old daughter, Emma, and I laughed because, at the time, our kitchen and family room were sort of cluttered.
-
Joplin council meeting canceled due to storm forecast
Storm forecasts have caused the Joplin City Council to cancel its meeting tonight.
-
Carthage School Board meeting is postponed
The Carthage School Board meeting set for today has been postponed for due to threats of severe weather.
-
Storms cause damage throughout the Four States
Four-State Area residents hunkered down twice Monday to ride out tornadoes and powerful spring storms, then went to work cleaning up. The worst damage from Monday night’s storm was being reported in Ottawa County, Okla., near Wyandotte. That followed a report of an EF-1 tornado early Monday morning near Carthage.
-
Alan Marble, Crowder College president, to retire
After 27 years with Crowder College, President Alan Marble has announced his plans to retire on June 30, the formal end of the academic year. “It’s just the right time,” Marble, 58, said in a telephone interview Monday morning. “I’ve enjoyed, I think, every minute of these 27 years, but it’s time to move on to the next challenge.”
-
EF1 tornado hit Carthage early Monday morning
Clean-up was underway in Carthage after winds estimated at 90 to 100 miles an hour damaged buildings and toppled trees and power lines in the Carthage area just after midnight early Monday.
-
Federal agency proposes adding two Missouri mussels to endangered species list
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service will host a public meeting in Joplin Tuesday and another meeting later in the week in Southeast Missouri to provide details and answer questions about adding two freshwater mussels to the endangered species list.
- More Local News Headlines
-
Joplin sends team to help Moore
