The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO

Local News

May 10, 2012

Mo. voters to decide on changes to judge selection

JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. — Missouri lawmakers on Thursday sent voters a proposed constitutional amendment that would bolster the governor’s power in picking state appellate judges, capping off years of complaints about the process.

The amendment, which will appear on a statewide ballot later this year, would allow governors to appoint an additional person to the special state commission that nominates finalists for openings on the state Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court. In addition, governors would get an extra nominee from which to choose in appointing a new judge.

Under Missouri’s current judge selection plan, a nominating commission with three attorneys, three gubernatorial appointees and a Supreme Court judge submit a panel of three finalists for the governor to fill vacancies on appellate courts. Whomever the governor appoints stands for periodic retention elections, in which people decide whether to keep the judge in office without another candidate appearing on the ballot.

Some Republican lawmakers and other groups complain that attorneys have gained too much influence in choosing judges and that adding another gubernatorial appointee would provide more accountability to the public.

“Lawyers don’t choose judges. The power to choose the judges rests with the people,” said Rep. Stan Cox, who sponsored the measure in the state House.

Cox, R-Sedalia, said the current system gives Missouri governors little more than ministerial authority in the appointment of judges. He said increasing the power of the chief executive would give someone voters could hold responsible when bad decisions are made in selecting judges.

The state House gave the measure final legislative approval 84-71 — just barely more than the minimum needed to approve the measure — and senators last week passed the measure 19-12. The constitutional amendment also must be approved by voters to take effect.

The measure would replace the Supreme Court judge who currently serves on the nominating commission with an additional person selected by the governor. That would allow governors to appoint a majority of the panel responsible for weeding out the judicial finalists. A former appellate judge would serve on the nominating commission as a nonvoting member.

Opponents contend the changes would reverse reforms that have improved Missouri courts, and the Missouri Bar has argued the proposed changes would politicize the courts.

Rep. Rory Ellinger said the changes remove safeguards and gives governors too much power, calling it a “radical destruction of the judiciary.”

“Where are the checks and balances now? You eliminate them,” said Ellinger, D-University City. “You eliminate your safeguard of the law if the executive overreaches.”

The state adopted its current process for picking judges in 1940 in an effort to reduce the role of politics in the judiciary and lessen the influence of urban political machine bosses. But its critics have argued that politics still plays a role. Criticism intensified in 2007 when Republican former Gov. Matt Blunt considered rejecting all three nominees for an opening on the Supreme Court. Blunt eventually appointed Judge Patricia Breckenridge, but the governor’s chief of staff worked with conservative legal organizations to criticize the selection plan and to try to derail Breckenridge’s appointment.

In 2010, Better Courts for Missouri backed a proposed ballot initiative that would have scrapped Missouri’s current judicial selection method and replaced it with partisan elections. However, the organization failed to gather enough signatures to get the measure before voters. A spokesman for Better Courts for Missouri said Thursday the most recent proposal is a step forward.

“By increasing citizen accountability and reducing the influence of liberal special interest groups, these modest reforms will help improve the judicial selection process and ensure our courts serve all Missourians, not just the litigation industry,” spokesman Rich Chrismer said.

Missouri uses a similar appointment process to select trial judges in St. Louis city and Jackson, Clay, Platte, St. Louis and Greene counties. The proposed constitutional amendment would not affect how those nominations are handled.


Text Only
Local News
  • Pension funding improving, actuary reports

    An extra $1 million contribution by the city of Joplin last year to the Police and Firemen’s Pension Fund boosted the funding ratio of the plan by 2 percent, the plan’s actuary told the board Thursday morning.

    April 17, 2014

  • Special counsel to be appointed in ethics complaint against Neosho council members

    The Neosho Ethics Board on Wednesday voted to ask the City Council to appoint a special counsel to provide legal advice to the board’s remaining two members as they investigate a complaint against two members of the council.

    April 17, 2014

  • Mike Pound 2010.jpg Mike Pound: Will new Earth-like planet have better cable offerings?

    When I read that astronomers have discovered the most Earth-like planet yet, I had a couple of deep scientific questions. First: What’s the Wi-Fi like? And: Are their TV channels better than ours? Hey, I didn’t get an “Incomplete” in college astronomy for nothing.

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Christian ministry plans Missouri camp expansion

    A nondenominational Christian ministry is planning a $21.5 million expansion on land it owns near Table Rock Lake in southwest Missouri, with a goal of offering gatherings beyond the traditional summer camps.

    April 17, 2014

  • 041714 School safe rooms4_72.jpg Joplin school district readies community safe rooms for storm season

    Thousands of Joplin residents will soon be able to stay safe during storms in some of the region’s newest shelters. Community safe rooms at Cecil Floyd, Stapleton, McKinley and Eastmorland elementary schools, which double as gymnasiums, and Junge Field, which will double as a field house, are expected to be open within the next few weeks, according to Mike Johnson, the school district’s director of construction.

    April 17, 2014 2 Photos

  • 041714 Treble Makers.jpg Carl Junction ‘Treble Makers’ to sing at Springfield Cardinals’ stadium

    Next month, 75 Carl Junction sixth-grade students will sing “The Star-Spangled Banner” at Hammons Field before a Springfield Cardinals game. And with more than 600 parents, family members and other residents planning to attend, the May 3 event has been dubbed “Carl Junction Day.”

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Public hearing set on posed TIF district

    Financial details of a proposed new tax increment financing district for the Silver Creek Galleria area will be discussed in detail at an April 28 public hearing, members of the city’s TIF Commission were told Thursday. Chris Williams, a TIF attorney representing the city of Joplin, told the panel the Thursday meeting was intended to walk commissioners through the public hearing steps.

    April 17, 2014

  • Volunteer projects spark two bills in Jefferson City

     moving through the Missouri House and Senate were inspired by a volunteer project in Carl Junction last year that stalled over a question of whether those volunteers had to be paid prevailing wage under Missouri law. “This bill is very simple. All it says is if someone is a volunteer, they won’t be forced to be paid prevailing wage,” state Rep. Charlie Davis, R-Webb City, told lawmakers during a hearing on his bill last week.

    April 17, 2014

  • Chairman of Neosho Ethics Board resigns

    The chairman of the Neosho Ethics Board unexpectedly resigned on Thursday as the board investigates a complaint against Neosho City Council members David Ruth and Steve Hart.

    April 17, 2014

  • CWEP receives top honor from national power group

    The Carthage Water and Electric Plant has received the top award for reliable electrical service from the American Public Power Association.

    April 17, 2014

Must Read


Would you use a community safe room when the area is under a tornado warning?

     View Results
Twitter Updates
Follow us on twitter