JOPLIN, Mo. —
What does a trillion look like?
Gaze up at the sky on a clear night. A trillion is more stars than there are in the entire Milky Way galaxy.
Twelve zeroes. That’s a trillion.
Multiply that trillion with its 12 zeroes by 14. That’s the U.S. debt load.
And it’s a number Joshua Gordon and Steve Winn watch closely. So does Brian Riedl.
Gordon is policy director for the bipartisan Concord Coalition; Winn is the group’s spokesman; Riedl is a research fellow in federal budget policy for the conservative Heritage Foundation.
“We are on course to have the national debt quadruple between 2012 and 2020,” said Riedl. “At that point the interest on the national debt is so huge you have choked off everything else government could do.”
In a decade, the nation’s debt also will exceed its gross domestic product, which is the value of all goods and services the country produces. In other words, the nation’s debt will be larger than the entire U.S. economy.
Gordon and Riedl spend a lot of time trying to educate Americans about the debt, what it means, what needs to be done and what happens if the country doesn’t change course.
Deficit vs. debt
The first lesson they give when educating Americans about financial overload is the terminology. Specifically, two terms: “debt” and “deficit.”
“The debt is the total amount we owe as a result of the annual deficit we run every year,” Winn said.
This year, the country is expected to take in $2.2 to $2.3 trillion in revenue of all kinds, but U.S. spending is projected at $3.6 to $3.7 trillion per year.
Alden Buerge, chairman and CEO of First State Bank in Joplin, said people who show up with those kinds of numbers at his bank are not “bankable.”
Regulators — federal regulators included — would take to the woodshed any banker who made a loan based on those levels of income and debt. Bankers want $1.20 or $1.30 in income for every dollar in expenses before lending them money, he said.
According to Riedl, the annual deficit went over $1 trillion in 2009 for the first time and has continued at that level every year since.
“By my calculations, if we stay on current policy trends the deficit will never fall below $1 trillion again,” he added.
Winn said that right now, interest on that borrowed money is low. But, he warned, it will rise. When it does, the cost to the United States government of borrowing that money will go up, too.
“A lot of the federal debt is financed over the short term,” he explained.
This year, payment of interest on that debt is estimated at $225 billion, Gordon said. He and Riedl point to Congressional Budget Office projections indicating that without any change in spending, interest on the national debt will hit $1.1 trillion a year by 2021.
At that point, it will exceed what the country will be spending on national defense.
“By 2025, revenue will be able to finance only interest payments, Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security. Every other federal government activity — from national defense and homeland security to transportation and energy — will have to be paid for with borrowed money.”
That’s from The National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform, which was appointed by President Barack Obama and co-chaired by Erskine Bowels, chief of staff for former President Bill Clinton, and Alan Simpson, a conservative former U.S. senator from Wyoming. They released their report this spring.
“The escalation was driven in large part by two wars and a slew of fiscally irresponsible policies, along with a deep economic downturn. We have arrived at the moment of truth, and neither political party is without blame.”
Claim on Social Security
Riedl and Gordon both said there are two pieces of that $14 trillion national debt.
The first is debt held by the public, meaning money borrowed from financial markets. That’s around $10 trillion, they say. The rest, more than $4 trillion, is money owed to the Social Security Trust Fund that was supposed to be set aside to fund the retirement of baby boomers — money that Congress went ahead and spent, leaving behind IOUs.
But the money will be needed soon.
In fact, Social Security expenditures exceeded tax receipts last year for the first time since 1983, when Social Security was last reformed, the trustees for Social Security noted in their annual report last year.
If the economy improves, Social Security may be back in the black, but not for long.
By 2014, Social Security deficits are expected to “grow rapidly,” the trustees reported, as baby boomers retire in large numbers and the number of Social Security beneficiaries outpaces the number of workers.
Buerge notes that the baby boom began in 1946, and the first of those boomers turn 65 this year. Which means the claim on Social Security is due.
“It has already started,” Riedl said.
Working both sides
How does one pay off a $14 trillion deficit?
“Realistically, we’re not going to,” Riedl said.
The alternative, he said, is to hold that debt in check — to “stabilize” it — until the economy grows and interest and the debt become a smaller piece of an expanding pie.
“As the national income grows, the interest becomes affordable,” Riedl said.
Gordon said Americans need to do two things simultaneously: They need to control annual deficits at the same time they need to get the U.S. economy cooking again.
“We clearly have to have both of those things working for us.”
But the problem occurs when the medicine for one actually makes the other worse.
Raising taxes, for example, increases revenue, but Gordon notes that some economists and many conservatives would argue that raising taxes too high or raising the wrong taxes can choke off economic growth.
‘Are we prepared?’
Riedl said: “The question is: Will we wait for a crisis to occur? We didn’t take on terrorism until 9/11. We didn’t take on levees until Katrina.”
Gordon thinks the public gets it. He’s not sure politicians do.
“Politicians think in two-year increments. They don’t think in the long term,” he said. “It will require politicians of both parties to come off long-held assumptions. The public really understands the need to move off their long-held beliefs.
“Historically there has not been the political will to take this on,” said George O’Connor, professor and head of the department of political science at Missouri State University in Springfield. That may be changing.
“We are bringing a serious conversation about debt reduction into Washington and into Joplin for the first time.”
Both the president and House Republicans are laying out plans to cut spending, but the best scenarios only reduce the deficit years from now.
Having a conversation is the easy part. The tough part comes when the cuts made in Washington cause bleeding in Missouri, for example.
“You really have to get into entitlements. We are going to have to get into the big-ticket items,” O’Connor said. “When those details come out, that is when the American people will have to make choices. Are we prepared to give up the things the deficit has brought us?”
United States arrives at ‘moment of truth’
JOPLIN, Mo. —
What does a trillion look like?
- Local News
MSSU board meets today in open session
The Board of Governors executive committee at Missouri Southern State University will meet at 2:30 p.m. today.
Missouri man accused of exploiting teen in Georgia
A Vernon County man is being held on charges that he talked a 16-year-old girl from Georgia into sending him pornographic images of herself and solicited men to have sex with her. Curt L. Bowman, 42, was arrested Friday at his home near Nevada based on information developed by investigators with the Cobb County Police Department in the Atlanta area.
Joplin assistant superintendent position to go unfilled
The recently vacated assistant superintendent position with the Joplin School District will not be filled. That decision is natural now that the district is returning to a more normal operating state nearly three years after the May 2011 tornado damaged or destroyed 10 of its buildings, Superintendent C.J. Huff told the Globe when asked for an update on the vacancy.
Former agency employee pleads guilty in tornado fraud case
A former employee of the Economic Security Corp. in Joplin pleaded guilty Monday to defrauding a disaster relief program that assisted victims of the 2011 tornado. Herlana L. Latham, 32, a former resident of Joplin now living in Memphis, Tenn., pleaded guilty in U.S. District Court in Springfield to conspiracy to commit mail fraud.
Long, cold winter could prompt more disconnects this spring
Vett Spain, of Joplin, uses both electricity and natural gas to heat her home during the winter. During extremely cold winter months — and this winter has been among the coldest for the area — it can cost her almost $500 a month to heat her home.
Mike Pound: Watoto Church brings mission, music to area
What began as a small mission church in Uganda has become home to thousands of children orphaned and women widowed by years of conflict in the African nation. Watoto Church was founded in 1980 in Uganda by Gary and Marilyn Skinner.
New library to be built separate from movie theater
The new Joplin Public Library will be constructed separately from a new movie theater at 20th Street and Connecticut Avenue, the Joplin City Council was told Monday night. Plans had called for the movie theater to be built as a second-floor addition to the library, but interim City Manager Sam Anselm made the announcement of the change at a special meeting of the council.
Carthage board member arrested on DWI charge
Mark Westhoff, a member of the Carthage School Board, was arrested early Sunday in Newton County on a misdemeanor charge of driving while intoxicated. According to the Missouri State Highway Patrol, Westhoff, 56, of Carthage, also has been charged with failing to yield to an emergency vehicle displaying red lights and siren, and failing to drive on the right half of the roadway.
Joplin Memorial Run to hold new event
A new event, the “Walk of Silence,” will be held this year in conjunction with the Joplin Memorial Run. Run organizers also will give out newly designed medals and T-shirts, announced Audie Dennis, chairman of Active Lifestyle Events Inc., the organization that annually stages what has become a run to remember the 161 people who died as a result of the 2011 tornado and to help rebuild Joplin.
Carl Junction Chamber to manage annual bluegrass festival
After 17 years, Carl Junction’s annual bluegrass festival is changing.
- More Local News Headlines
- MSSU board meets today in open session