By Susan Redden
sredden@joplinglobe.com
Changes to state odor rules, including reducing the odor threshold and bringing more concentrated animal feeding operations under state regulation, were debated Wednesday by Missouri’s Air Conservation Commission.
The board discussed proposed revisions in more than two hours of deliberations, and the issue is on the agenda for the board’s formal session today in Jefferson City.
“They are looking at dropping the odor threshold, not to punish, but to trigger additional oversight by the state,” said Rebecca Birke, a spokeswoman for state’s air-pollution-control program.
Odors now must register as offensive in a 7-to-1 dilution in equipment used by state inspectors to qualify for citations. Carthage city officials have been among those most persistent in seeking a lower threshold because of odor problems the city has attributed to Renewable Environmental Solutions, a plant in the industrial bottoms that converts poultry byproducts from Butterball Inc. into types of fuel.
The plant has been the subject of a state shutdown, and a public-nuisance lawsuit filed by the city and the Missouri attorney general’s office.
Carthage officials are looking to the state for a lower odor threshold, Tom Short, city administrator, said Wednesday.
“We and our citizens will be disappointed if they don’t,” he said. “The odors are definitely a nuisance, but they’re not a violation according to state standards” set by the Department of Natural Resources.
He said a lower threshold that triggered notices of violation would tie in with a bill proposed by state Sen. Gary Nodler that specifies that operations cited for violating state odor rules more than three times in a year would be subject to additional fines.
But the proposal being debated by the commission would lower the threshold to a 4-to-1 ratio to trigger additional state oversight, but odors would have to register at 7-to-1 or above to trigger a violation, Birke pointed out. Odors exceeding the lower level would prompt the DNR to contact the plant and direct officials to develop a plan to correct the problem.
The Carthage RES plant added more odor controls as a result of a consent judgment after the lawsuit filed by the city and state. Though odors still bother residents, the plant has not been cited recently for violations.
The commission is considering new odor rules based on proposals from a work group assembled last summer by DNR officials to determine if changes were needed in state regulations. Carthage officials and residents, and some residents near large CAFOs attended the discussions to lobby for stricter rules.
The proposals from the work group and the attorney general’s office recommended lowering the state’s air-dilution standard to 2-to-1 from 7-to-1. The attorney general’s office recommended a technology-based approach that would focus first on working with businesses to help them get into compliance.
A different proposal fashioned by the DNR staff recommends that the dilution standard be lowered only after more data collection and training. The agency is suggesting more comprehensive data collection, including a new protocol that measures odor intensity, rather than just checking to see if it reaches the 7-to-1 ratio. It also recommends that information about the complaint, weather at the time and other conditions be gathered.
The largest 20 CAFOs — the equivalent of at least 7,000 beef cows or 385,000 turkeys — now come under state odor rules. Including the next largest class would add 41 operations, based on current state counts. That class is for animals equivalent to 3,000 to 6,999 beef cows or 30,000 to 69,999 turkeys.
In board discussions Wednesday, made available via telephone, some members questioned how new rules might affect industry and said additional DNR staff would be needed to enforce any new rules.
Long procedure
Rule changes normally take between 18 and 24 months to complete, as recommended changes are written up, then revised, then submitted for public comment and debate before a final version is approved, said Rebecca Birke, with the state’s air-pollution-control program.
Local News
Air commission debates changing state odor rules
- Local News
-
-
City wants to buy weather radios for those without
Phil Jones had been working on a construction project outside his house all day on May 22 and was unaware that a tornado watch had been issued. Once he was inside, though, his weather radio went off, and he learned that a warning had been issued.
-
Cold air headed this way
The Arctic front that passed over Missouri this morning will bring dangerously cold temperatures to the region tonight and Saturday.
-
Miami, Okla., man dies along I-44
A 27-year-old Miami, Okla., who appeared to be walking along I-44 in an attempt to get help after wrecking his car, is dead after being hit by a pickup truck.
-
Mo. presidential primary sets low mark in turnout
Just 8 percent of Missouri’s registered voters cast ballots in this week’s presidential primary.
-
Okla. court upholds man’s life sentence in deaths
An Oklahoma appeals court has upheld the life in prison sentences of a man convicted of two counts of first-degree murder for the shotgun slayings of two men at a Sperry residence.
-
Architects present preliminary JHS plans at community meeting
Reaction appeared mostly supportive Thursday night among the roughly 50 people who attended a community meeting at which architects presented their preliminary site plans for the future combined Joplin High School and Franklin Technology Center.
-
Confessed shooter testifies against co-defendants in Pittsburg murder case
Rickey Smith testified Thursday that as he came in the back door of Ryan Bailey’s home in Pittsburg with a 9 mm pistol in his hand, Bailey looked up from the couch in his living room.
-
School district’s proposed street-closing plan questioned
Plans to close some streets near the proposed Joplin High School drew questions, including a challenge from a former Joplin mayor, during a public hearing this week.
-
Mike Pound: Spirit of competition evident during double-overtime game
When I played basketball in high school, I played in several very close games.
Now, some people who may have known me in high school are probably laughing right now and saying, “What Mike meant to say is that when he was in high school, he came very close to playing in some games.” -
Neosho council approves new golf cart contract
The purchase of golf carts was back on the agenda this week for the Neosho City Council. City Attorney Steve Hays said there were errors in the financing terms that were part of a bid approved last month for the purchase of 55 gas-powered carts from E-Z-Go for $144,195, so the purchase of a new fleet was rebid.
- More Local News Headlines
-






