Fifth suspect charged in ‘wrong Muller’ case

Local News

Discussion

February 5, 2010

Anonymous The Joplin Globe Fri Feb 05, 2010, 09:57 PM CST

By Jeff Lehr

jlehr@joplinglobe.com

NEVADA, Mo. — A Nevada contractor has been charged with concealing his involvement in a Missouri home invasion and a subsequent errant abduction of a New Jersey man.

Roy A. Slates, 55, was arrested Thursday at the Vernon County sheriff’s office and charged with concealing a felony and hindering prosecution. He posted $5,000 bond and was released.

Court documents allege that Slates was a second key figure behind three men’s alleged armed invasion of the home of Charles and Linda Scammell on Nov. 9 in rural Vernon County, and the abduction last month of New Jersey pet store owner Jeffrey Muller.

Douglas Stangeland, 46, of Nevada, and Lonnie Swarnes, 44, and Swarnes’ nephew, Andrew Wadel, 21, both of Rich Hill, were apprehended Jan. 9 in Lake Ozark after allegedly abducting Muller in New Jersey and bringing him back with them to Missouri. They subsequently also were charged with the home invasion during which Scammell was shot in the hand.

A fourth suspect and reputed ringleader, William J. Barger, 48, of rural Nevada, was arrested a few days later and charged with directing the others to commit the home invasion. Barger is also believed to have sent them to New Jersey to grab Muller, but the pet store owner proved to be the wrong Muller.

Money motive

Sheriff Ron Peckman told the Globe that it all appears to have started with Slates’ desire to recover $400,000 he lost in a business deal with a different man named Jeffrey Muller on a building project in Utah.

“Stangeland and Slates were sitting around a bar one night talking about how each of them had lost money,” the sheriff said. “So Stangeland went to Barger about it and they came up with an idea how to recoup Slates’ money and make some money themselves while doing it.”

A probable-cause affidavit filed Thursday states that Scammell, the owner of a construction business in the Kansas City area, also was involved in the deal that lost Slates’ money. The affidavit states that Barger struck a deal with Slates to try to get his money back for a 25 percent share of whatever was recovered.

Peckman said that deal led to the home invasion and the shooting of Scammell.

“We had spoke to (Slates) after the home invasion and he said he didn’t know anything about it,” the sheriff said.

That denial allegedly came in an interview with sheriff’s investigator Steve Schlup on Dec. 31.

Following his arrest Jan. 9, Stangeland told investigators that Slates gave Barger $10,000 to finance a trip to New Jersey, which became a prelude to Muller’s abduction, according to the affidavit.

That information jibes with something the pet store owner’s son told reporters following his father’s kidnapping. He said his father recalled seeing two of the suspects loitering about his store several weeks prior to the abduction.

Slates was interviewed a second time at the sheriff’s office on Jan. 15 and admitted to a role in the whole affair, the affidavit alleges.

‘Big plan’

“I guess when they came up with their big plan he was all for it,” the sheriff said.

But he told investigators that he did not know they intended to invade Scammell’s home.

“He said he didn’t want anybody to get hurt,” Peckman said.

He said Slates told them that after the home invasion, he started wanting out of the deal and told the other suspects that. The sheriff did not know exactly when Slates claims to have bailed out. The affidavit alleges that he admitted to giving Barger $10,000 toward the New Jersey trip before doing so.

‘Right’ Muller

The Jeffrey Muller that a group of Missouri men reportedly tried to locate to recoup $400,000 lost in a business deal remains a shadowy figure in a two-state investigation.

The Vernon County sheriff said he has been told where the “right Muller’’ is. The sheriff declines to say if that Muller has been questioned by any investigators about the matter.

Text Only

Local News

Water company cites reconnections
The May 22 tornado has caused a dramatic drop in water usage for the Missouri American Water Co., but things are starting to turn around — one reconnection at a time.

February 10, 2012 1 Photo
Survivor of ’78 Connor collapse dead at age 64
A big story in the history of Joplin was the 1978 collapse of the Connor Hotel at Fourth and Main streets. Alfred Summers, the man at the heart of that story, died at 6:41 a.m. Friday at St. John’s Mercy Hospital in Joplin after an illness. He was 64.

February 10, 2012
County asks for dismissal of sheriff’s suit
The Jasper County Commission is the final authority in budget allocations, including those from the county’s Law Enforcement Sales Tax fund, county lawyers have argued in a motion recently filed in Jasper County Circuit Court.

February 10, 2012
Winter weather back in forecast
The arctic front that passed over Missouri on Friday will bring cold temperatures to the region tonight.

February 10, 2012
Weather service upgrading radar at Springfield station
The National Weather Service radar station at Springfield will be out of service for about two weeks to permit the installation of dual-polarization technology.

February 10, 2012
MSSU, PSU to conduct financial-aid events
Missouri Southern State University in Joplin and Pittsburg (Kan.) State University each will conduct events Sunday to help high school seniors with completing the Free Application for Federal Student Aid.

February 10, 2012
Authorities term deaths of teens murder-suicide
Authorities say a teenage woman apparently shot her estranged boyfriend several times before turning the gun on herself and taking her own life.

February 10, 2012
Mike Pound: One man in America wants his robo call
I like to think I have pretty thick skin. If I didn’t, all the emails I get with the subject lines that read “Hey moron” would bother me. But they don’t, so I do.

February 10, 2012
Proposed Kan. abortion ban blocked by abortion foe
An influential anti-abortion legislator is blocking the push for a ban on abortion in the Kansas Constitution, highlighting a split among abortion opponents over tactics and frustrating the group advocating the “personhood” proposal Friday.

February 10, 2012
Kansas House GOP issues tax plan
House Republican leaders are proposing a plan to cut Kansas income taxes, removing one key objection to an earlier proposal from Gov. Sam Brownback.

February 10, 2012
More Local News Headlines

Water company cites reconnections

Local News

Search Results

Discussion

Fifth suspect charged in ‘wrong Muller’ case

Eliminating the state income tax and increasing sales tax was debated during a press day on Thursday at the Missouri Capitol. Do you favor that proposal?

Site Map

Contact Us