The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO

National News

September 10, 2012

In Facebook court cases, high tech and free speech collide

WASHINGTON — “Like” the First Amendment? Then prepare for a fight, as courts and employers figure out whether a simple click on Facebook deserves free speech protection.

It’s 21st-century technology meets an 18th-century Constitution, and the real-world implications are starting to erupt.

In rural Mississippi, two firefighters and a police officer are serving 30-day suspensions because they hit “like” on a controversial Facebook post.

In Virginia, a sheriff’s department employee said he was fired for “liking” a page sponsored by the sheriff’s political rival. One federal appellate court already is being asked to weigh in; others surely will follow.

“As we continue to develop new media and new means of expression, it is important to ensure that they are constitutionally protected,” Rebecca Glenberg, a lawyer with the American Civil Liberties Union of Virginia, said in an interview.

When users click “like” on a Facebook post, their names are displayed next to the post. They’re also visible to other users.

The Virginia-based 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals is considering the case of Hampton, Va., sheriff’s department employees allegedly fired for using Facebook and other means to back their boss’s rival. One employee communicated the support by clicking “like.” Another wrote a Facebook post.

A trial judge concluded last April that “merely ’liking’ a Facebook page is insufficient speech to merit constitutional protection.” He said it wasn’t the kind of “substantive statement” that courts traditionally have protected.

The subsequent appeal is the first to consider whether a Facebook “like” falls under the First Amendment, Glenberg said.

Underscoring the case’s importance, the ACLU and Facebook have filed separate friend-of-the-court briefs urging free speech protections.

“I am not aware of any other instances of an employee being fired for ’liking’ something,” Glenberg said. “There is, however, a trend toward employers monitoring employees’ social media use, so the potential for this sort of thing is certainly there.”

The potential for conflict is so great, in part, because social media are so omnipresent. In its 26-page amicus brief, prepared by attorney Aaron Panner, Facebook - with 800 million users worldwide - says that “over 3 billion likes and comments” are posted daily.

In Columbus, Miss., for instance, city officials suspended firefighters Damon Estes and Erik Minga and police Officer Lance Luckey after the men “liked” a Facebook post by firefighter Brad Alexander. Alexander had written critically about the whereabouts of a woman whose 2-year-old child was hit by a car.

Alexander subsequently apologized and resigned. As first reported by the Columbus Dispatch newspaper, the Columbus City Council then voted 4-3 on Tuesday night to suspend the three public safety officers who’d “liked” Alexander’s posting.

“When you start talking about social media, it’s a new frontier,” Columbus City Councilman Kabir Karriem said Friday in a telephone interview.

Karriem, who voted against suspending the officers, said they could appeal their suspensions to the city’s Civil Service Commission.

For all their high-tech origins, Facebook posts appear to be the kind of speech the First Amendment envisioned; they consist, after all, of words and pictures.

Dana Mattingly, for instance, was working in December 2010 for the Saline County Circuit Clerk’s office, in eastern Arkansas, when she posted several sentences that voiced sympathy for workers whom the newly elected clerk had just fired. The clerk then fired her.

Mattingly sued, and a judge upheld her posts as protected speech.

“A public employer may not fire an employee for speech relating to a matter of public concern where that speech causes no disruption to the workplace,” U.S. District Judge J. Leon Holmes concluded.

Clicking “like,” though, might seem more akin to applause or a thumbs-up gesture than to traditional speech. It might even defy literal meaning altogether, as some click “like” simply to acknowledge that a Facebook post has been seen; others, to ensure continued access to related information.

Judges now must sort out the meaning of the site’s various icons and metaphors, a 21st-century puzzlement that our founders never could have envisioned.

Philadelphia-based U.S. District Judge Gene K. Pratter, for instance, briefly considered during a 2009 corporate dispute what it meant to be identified as a Facebook “friend.” Observing in a footnote that “friendships on Facebook may be as fleeting as the flick of a delete button,” Pratter said Facebook’s “selection of icons or labels offer no substance” that helped in resolving that particular dispute.

In its amicus brief in the Virginia case, Facebook said clicking “like” “generates statements and communicative imagery” on various other pages; some are the “21st-century equivalent of a front-yard campaign sign,” according to the brief.

The First Amendment does protect wordless expression. In 1984, notably, Gregory Lee Johnson set an American flag on fire in front of Dallas City Hall. He was convicted of violating a state law that prohibited desecrating the flag and was sentenced to a year in jail. In a 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court struck down the state law.

“The First Amendment literally forbids the abridgment only of ’speech,’ but we have long recognized that its protection does not end at the spoken or written word,” Justice William Brennan wrote in the 1989 decision.

ACLU attorneys note, as well, that even hard-to-understand expressions have been protected.

When the South Boston Allied War Veterans Council wanted to exclude gay marchers from a 1993 St. Patrick’s Day parade, the Supreme Court unanimously recognized that marching as a form of expression protected by the Constitution. Otherwise, the court reasoned, ambiguous expressions such as the “Jabberwocky verse of Lewis Carroll” would lie outside the First Amendment as well.

All of which could help shape what judges do with the Facebook “like.”

“A ’like’ might be only a tiny bit of speech,” said Andy Sellars, a staff attorney with the Harvard Law School-affiliated Digital Media Law Project, said, “but clicking a ’like’ is still a statement.”


Text Only
National News
  • Salmonella decline seen in food poisoning report

    The government’s latest report card on food poisoning shows a dip in salmonella cases but an increase in illnesses from bacteria in raw shellfish.

    April 18, 2014

  • Judge in gay marriage case asks pointed questions

    A judge in Colorado who will play a pivotal role deciding whether gays should be allowed to wed in the United States asked pointed questions Thursday about whether Oklahoma can legally ban the unions.

    April 17, 2014

  • Obama shows skepticism on Russia in Ukraine

    President Barack Obama conveyed skepticism Thursday about Russian promises to de-escalate a volatile situation in Ukraine, and said the United State and its allies are ready to impose fresh sanctions if Moscow doesn’t make good on its commitments.

    April 17, 2014

  • Cyber cops: Target hackers may take years to find

    Secret Service investigators say they are close to gaining a full understanding of the methods hackers used to breach Target’s computer systems last December.

    April 17, 2014

  • Court to weigh challenge to ban on campaign lies

    As political campaigns begin to heat up, the Supreme Court is deciding whether false accusations and mudslinging made during an election can be punished as a crime.

    April 16, 2014

  • Auto Show Nissan Hot _Cast.jpg Hot models at this year’s New York Auto Show

    With more than 1 million visitors annually, the New York International Auto Show is one of the most important shows for the U.S. auto industry.

    April 16, 2014 3 Photos

  • Transportation Blues 2.jpg Congress is giving states the transportation blues

    On the road in a tour bus this week, the U.S. transportation secretary is spreading some bad news: the government’s Highway Trust Fund is nearly broke.

    April 15, 2014 2 Photos

  • Report: Russia withheld intel before Boston attack

    A yearlong review of information the U.S. intelligence community had prior to the Boston Marathon bombing found that the investigation could have been more thorough.

    April 11, 2014

  • Obama Health Secretary.jpg Obama announces Sebelius resignation, successor

    President Barack Obama praised outgoing Health and Human Secretary Kathleen Sebelius for helping to steer his health care law’s comeback after a rocky rollout, even as he nominated a successor aimed at helping the White House move past the political damage.

    April 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • Police seek driver in deadly Florida day care crash

    As mourners trickled by Thursday to honor the 4-year-old girl who was killed and 14 others injured in a crash at a Florida day care, authorities scoured the state for the driver they said fled in the vehicle that caused the fatal wreck.

    April 10, 2014


A Missouri Senate committee has endorsed a 1-cent sales tax increase to fund transportation projects. The proposed constitutional amendment passed the House earlier this month. If passed by the full Senate, the measure would head to the November ballot for voter approval. Would you vote in favor of it?

     View Results

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
NDN Video
Captain of Sunken SKorean Ferry Arrested Raw: Fire Destroys 3 N.J. Beachfront Homes Raw: Pope Presides Over Good Friday Mass Raw: Space X Launches to Space Station Superheroes Descend on Capitol Mall Man Charged in Kansas City Highway Shootings Obama Awards Navy Football Trophy Anti-semitic Leaflets Posted in Eastern Ukraine Raw: Magnitude-7.2 Earthquake Shakes Mexico City Ceremony at MIT Remembers One of Boston's Finest Raw: Students Hurt in Colo. School Bus Crash Raw: Church Tries for Record With Chalk Jesus Raw: Faithful Celebrate Good Friday Worldwide Deadly Avalanche Sweeps Slopes of Mount Everest Police Arrest Suspect in Highway Shootings Drought Concerns May Hurt Lake Tourism Vermont Goat Meat Gives Refugees Taste of Home Calif. Investigators Re-construct Fatal Bus Cras Mayor Rob Ford Launches Re-election Campaign Appellate Court Hears Okla. Gay Marriage Case