subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite map
Tue, Nov 24 2009 

Published November 18, 2008 10:37 pm - This letter is about the article by Greg Grisolano (Globe, Nov. 13) with regard to two Kansas students winning a national award for their film about concentrated animal-feeding operations.

Voices: Documentary criticism



This letter is about the article by Greg Grisolano (Globe, Nov. 13) with regard to two Kansas students winning a national award for their film about concentrated animal-feeding operations.

The article is about two young Pittsburg State University men who won first place in Collegiate Broadcasters Inc., a national organization that recognizes student achievement in media. This award was won with a documentary they did about CAFOs, Roaring River, and the environment called “Everyone Lives Downstream.’’

Everyone living in this area should be proud of their achievement.

Online, under the comments section to this story, there are a couple of people who wrote in criticizing the documentary and myself for complimenting them in the article. One quote is about “the Riedel guy, who has put out volumes of misinformation before.’’ I am that Riedel guy. I have written articles concerning our water supply and all the impaired streams and rivers in Southwest Missouri. Volumes might be a slight exaggeration.

The two people with negative comments also talk about it being one-sided and that “a film that only shows one side of an issue isn’t a documentary.” These two people did not see the film or they would know better. The Department of Natural Resources and the Missouri Conservation Department are interviewed. As to the comment “they should have interviewed the people with the CAFO in Roaring River,” the owners were given an opportunity to participate, and they declined.

Do any of you readers out there think it is strange that we have two documentary experts in the area that can negatively critique a documentary without seeing it and yet a group of professionals who judge documentaries from all over the United States can give a first-place award to these Pittsburg State students?

Could it be they are concerned about the awareness this documentary is bringing to the public about CAFOs?

James Riedel

Eagle Rock



print this story    email this story    comment on this story   

Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.


Add a comment on this story







autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide

Announcements


Click here to VOTE!!

Click here!!

: Special Offer For New Subscribers : 32 buy 1 get 1 free offers

Click Here!


Featured Transportation

2005 SUZUKI TWIN PEAKS 700,
4x4, Vtwin, automatic, $5,000/offer 417-451-8860....>MORE

CHRYSLER 1998 TOWN AND COUNTRY
$1775
loaded, front/rear heat and air. 437-4424.
...>MORE

SUBARU, 1994 IMPREZA,
great mpg, runs excellent, needs paint, $1200. 434-8591....>MORE

See all ads

Featured Homes

Deerfield Estates
in Carl Junction, prime building sites, reduced $10,000 each. 417-825-0052...>MORE

See all ads

Other Cool Stuff

MAHOGANY DROPLEAF TABLE
Duncan Phife mahogany dropleaf table and 4 chairs, great condition, $400 or offer. (417)782-2565, (417)782-2771...>MORE

2007 CUB CADET LT1050,
leaf bagger, 50” deck, $1150/best offer (417)451-8860....>MORE

ENGLISH BULLDOG PUPS, AKC

Champion bloodlines. Family raised. Would make great Christmas presents. Ready to go now! $800-$1000.
417-52
...>MORE

CHIEFS TICKETS
KANSAS CITY CHIEFS TICKETS FOR SALE. 417-438-8988....>MORE

SHIH-TZU/LHASA,
female, 6 months, all shots, $75. (417)776-8215....>MORE

SHIHZORKIEPOO PUPS
(2) 8 week old female Shihzorkiepoo pups. mom is Imperial Shih-Ttzu, dad is a Yorkiepoo. 1st shots and dewormer. paperwo...>MORE

STORY & CLARK PIANO,
lots of sheet music and books, $500 or best offer. (417)649-6174, (417)438-9432...>MORE

DIAMOND SOLITAIRE
Pear-shaped, one carat, diamond solitaire in gold setting. $2,000. Please call 417-825-3238...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index

 

 

The Joplin Globe Electronic Edition