The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO

State News

Discussion

July 22, 2007

Missouri: New abortion law could provide unique court test



The Associated Press

JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. — Missouri has a long-established reputation as one of the nation’s foremost anti-abortion states.

As evidence: the abortion rights group NARAL Pro-Choice America gives Missouri an “F.” The anti-abortion group Americans United for Life had ranked Missouri the seventh-best nationally, until last year’s voter approval of a stem cell research amendment dropped the state in the group’s rankings.

So it’s probably not surprising that Missouri’s abortion laws have frequently reached the U.S. Supreme Court — sometimes being upheld, other times overturned.

Now Missouri could be poised to again test judicial precedent with its abortion laws.

A measure set to take effect Aug. 28 will require any medical clinic performing more than five first-trimester abortions a month, or any abortions later in pregnancy, to be licensed as an “ambulatory surgical center.”

That means abortion clinics will be subject to a wide-range of state health department regulations governing their personnel, equipment, cleanliness and the physical characteristics of their facilities. Missouri’s existing regulations for outpatient surgery centers even set such things as minimum hallway widths and parking lot spaces.

Planned Parenthood of Kansas and Mid-Missouri claims it could cost up to $2 million to renovate its Columbia clinic to comply with the new law. The alternative is to stop offering abortions there, leaving a St. Louis clinic as Planned Parenthood’s only site for surgical abortions in the state.

Supporters of the new law say it is intended to ensure the health and safety of women, an assertion disputed by opponents.

This is not the first time Missouri has tried to restrict where abortions can be performed.

On June 15, 1983, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down a Missouri law that required abortions after 12 weeks of pregnancy to be performed in hospitals.

The court said the Missouri law — like a similar Akron, Ohio, ordinance it struck down the same day — unreasonably infringed on a woman’s constitutional right to abortion. In the Ohio case, which served as the lead opinion, the Supreme Court said the hospital abortion requirement burdened women financially, potentially costing them twice as much money as would an outpatient clinic.

But the Supreme Court left the door open for further regulation. On that same day, it upheld a Virginia law that required second-trimester abortions to be performed either at traditional hospitals or outpatient hospitals, the description of which generally matches that of an ambulatory surgical center.

After the Supreme Court loss, Missouri lawmakers in 1986 tried again to limit where abortions could be performed. That law required any abortion at the 16th week of pregnancy or later to occur in a hospital.

But the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, citing the precedent established five years earlier, ruled in July 1988 that the 16th-week hospital requirement was little different than the 12th-week requirement. The appeals court said non-hospital abortions at those ages cannot reasonably be considered more dangerous to women than those performed in hospitals.

Missouri’s latest attempt to restrict the location of abortions takes a different approach. It follows the Virginia law by limiting abortions to both hospitals and clinics licensed as outpatient surgical centers. But it goes further by applying that limitation to clinics that provide even just a few first-trimester abortions, not only those that perform later abortions.

It’s that latter part that makes Missouri’s law a first-of-its kind, according to NARAL attorneys who track state abortion laws.

Under its Roe v. Wade precedent, the Supreme Court has generally maintained that the right to abortion is strongest in the first trimester, said Carl Tobias, a law professor at the University of Richmond in Virginia. Yet the court has allowed states to impose requirements on abortions at any fetus age, so long as they are not unduly burdensome..

“It could be that a court would find this to be an undue burden because of the first trimester aspect of this,” Tobias said, “but it’s not at all clear.”

Planned Parenthood “is looking very carefully at these issues” as it weighs whether to sue before the law takes effect, said Arthur Benson, a Kansas City attorney for the organization.

NARAL’s legal director, Cathy Mahoney, called Missouri’s regulatory reach into first-trimester abortion clinics an extreme step.

“These kinds of restrictions can largely make that right (to abortion) unattainable — if not legally, practically speaking,” Mahoney said.

Spokespeople for Missouri Right to Life and Americans United for Life said their legal experts weren’t available to talk about Missouri’s new law. But Missouri’s apparently unique approach doesn’t necessarily put it on shaky ground, said Right to Life lobbyist Susan Klein.

“Just because no other state has done it does not mean this is not good legislation. We believe it’s excellent legislation,” Klein said. “Abortion has risks with it, and the Department of Health should be able to come in and have a say so in how women are taken care of.”

Text Only
State News
  • Lions climb into share of MIAA men's basketball lead

    Without taking the floor, Missouri Southern has climbed into a first-place tie in the MIAA men’s basketball race.

    February 22, 2012

  • 2.6 magnitude earthquake recorded in Oklahoma

    The U.S. Geological Survey has recorded a 2.6 magnitude earthquake near Wellston in central Oklahoma.
    No injuries or damage is reported.

    January 19, 2011

  • Audit: $108,000 taken from Missouri Veterans Commission JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. — A former employee of the state auditor’s office embezzled nearly $108,000 while working as an accountant for the Missouri Veterans Commission, the state auditor alleged Monday.

    Stacy Griffin-Lowery was fired by the Veterans Commission in March 2008 and pleaded guilty three months later to a misdemeanor theft charge. She repaid the state $17,665, the auditor’s office said.

    But Missouri Auditor Susan Montee on Monday accused Griffin-Lowery of swiping an additional $90,192 by getting reimbursed for cash advances and purchases made on her personal credit card.

    April 12, 2010

  • Race in Kansas’ 2nd District could heat up for GOP incumbent TOPEKA, Kan. — A conservative Kansas legislator said Monday he will announce in a few weeks whether he will challenge freshman U.S. Rep. Lynn Jenkins in the Republican primary.

    State Sen. Dennis Pyle’s actions in recent months suggest the Hiawatha farmer, who’s served in the Legislature since 2001, is running against Jenkins in the Aug. 2 primary. He set up a campaign organization in November and has a Web site featuring a brief video of him on his farm, asking viewers for support.

    April 12, 2010

  • Oklahoma tea party leaders, lawmakers envision militia OKLAHOMA CITY — Frustrated by recent political setbacks, tea party leaders and some conservative members of the Oklahoma Legislature say they would like to create a new volunteer militia to help defend against what they believe are improper federal infringements on state sovereignty.

    Tea party movement leaders say they’ve discussed the idea with several supportive lawmakers and hope to get legislation next year to recognize a new volunteer force

    April 12, 2010

  • Missouri: Senate panel cuts $500 million from proposed budget JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. — A Senate committee declared Thursday that it has sliced more than $500 million from Missouri’s proposed budget for next year — meeting a target set by Gov. Jay Nixon to bring it in balance.

    April 8, 2010

  • Kansas: Wichita-area casino in doubt after governor’s decision TOPEKA, Kan. — A proposed casino south of Wichita was in doubt Thursday after Gov. Mark Parkinson refused to grant its developers a regulatory reprieve. Partners in the $225 million Chisholm Creek project wanted to delay a state board’s decision on their plans.

    April 8, 2010

  • Oklahoma: Groups oppose education spending initiative OKLAHOMA CITY — A coalition of business and labor groups said Thursday it will work to defeat a ballot initiative to dramatically increase spending on public education that coalition members said would devastate the budgets of many other state services and possibly force tax increases.

    April 8, 2010

  • Missouri: Gov. Nixon affirms support for tuition freeze COLUMBIA, Mo. — Missouri Gov. Jay Nixon has no plans to sit idly while lawmakers consider whether to preserve a tuition freeze deal he assembled before the state’s dire financial status was fully known.

    April 7, 2010

  • Kansas: Agency uses YouTube to illustrate road woes TOPEKA, Kan. — It’s one thing to hear about potholes and state budgets. It’s another to see how the two are connected. That’s part of the thinking behind a new video presentation on YouTube this week from the Kansas Department of Transportation.

    April 7, 2010