The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO

Top Stories

June 1, 2012

Blacks still more prone to being stopped in Missouri

A report released Friday shows that officers in Missouri continue to stop black drivers at significantly higher rates than other racial or ethnic groups, although Joplin’s police chief believes the local numbers do not necessarily reflect racial profiling.

The Missouri attorney general’s office released a report on about 1.7 million vehicle stops conducted by 631 law enforcement agencies across the state in 2011.

The figures show black drivers are about 72 percent more likely to be stopped than white drivers. While blacks were the lone racial or ethnic group more likely to be stopped than whites, the figures show minority drivers in general more likely to be searched and arrested than whites.

Annual reports on vehicle stops in Missouri going back to the year 2000 suggest that the disparity in stops of black drivers has increased in 10 of the past 12 years. While Attorney General Chris Koster called the increases “a disturbing trend,” he warned that the data for individual communities is “not conclusive evidence of racial profiling.”

“One of the best uses of these reports is as a springboard for dialogue and communication between law enforcement agencies and the communities they serve,” Koster said. “It is vital that Missouri law enforcement agencies continue to review the rates of stops and searches, and to continue their outreach efforts.”

The data reported by law enforcement agencies is used to calculate disparity indexes comparing the proportion of vehicle stops for drivers of a particular race or ethnic group with the proportion of the state or local population of that group. A value of 1.0 represents no disparity, values under 1.0 indicate underrepresentation of the group in stops made and values above 1.0 indicate overrepresentation.

The statewide disparity for blacks was 1.63 with respect to vehicle stops in 2011, compared with 1.61 in 2010. By comparison, the statewide index for whites was 0.95, for Hispanics 0.65, for Asians 0.50, and for Native Americans 0.20.

In Joplin, the blacks disparity index was 1.66 last year, which was down from 1.76 in 2010. The index for Hispanics in Joplin was 0.50, for whites 1.05, for Asians 0.21 and for Native Americans 0.12.

Joplin police Chief Lane Roberts cautioned that the report’s statistical data lacks analysis and that there are numerous factors other than racial profiling that may have a bearing on why blacks are stopped at a disproportionate rate. For example, there are socioeconomic and income factors that may play into the data, he said. There also are circumstances particular to individual communities, such as the displacement of people Joplin saw in the aftermath of last year’s tornado, he said.

Roberts said he does not know how any of that may have affected the numbers with respect to vehicle stops.

“My role is not to analyze what causes the disparity,” he said. “My role is to ensure our law enforcement activities are based on conduct, not race.”

He said he is confident that racial profiling is “not one of those causes in Joplin because we watch that very carefully.”

Mayor Melodee Colbert-Kean had not had a chance to review the report but expressed confidence in Roberts addressing any problem it might reveal.

“The chief is very proactive in making sure something like that is not going on,” she said of the possibility of racial profiling.

The mayor said that on a police force the size of Joplin, there is always the possibility of isolated instances. But she feels confident “if there is something like that going on, it will be brought forward and dealt with by the chief — because our tolerance for that is zero.”

Ruthie Cox, president of the Joplin branch of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, believes the numbers speak for themselves.

“Racial profiling has been here for a long time, and I don’t see it disappearing,” Cox said.

Cox believes young black residents of Joplin and women of all races are more prone to being stopped by police. She said she would be interested in knowing how many of the vehicle stops are repeated stops of the same person.

The report also tracks search rates and arrest rates for vehicle stops. Hispanic drivers were 1.72 times more likely than white drivers to be searched in Missouri, while blacks were 1.53 times more likely. That’s despite data showing that both Hispanics and blacks were actually less likely than whites to have contraband found during searches. The “contraband hit rate” for whites was 24.42, compared with 13.51 for Hispanics and 18.42 for blacks.

Cox views that as a telling detail.

“It seems to me they’re concentrating on African-Americans,” she said. “If they don’t produce as much contraband, which ones should you be stopping? They can say it isn’t racial profiling, but it is.”

Joplin police Lt. Brian Lewis said Joplin’s search rate numbers were reported incorrectly to the state initially. The city’s corrected search rate figures for 2011 are 3.80 for whites, 7.67 for blacks, 7.59 for Hispanics, 1.00 for Asians and 3.51 for Native Americans. The arrest rates for each of the groups was 8.52 for whites, 14.42 for blacks, 14.99 for Hispanics, 1.00 for Asians, and 3.51 for Native Americans.

Local numbers

Several local law enforcement agencies reported a disproportionately high rate of vehicle stops of black drivers in 2011. The disparity index for vehicle stops of blacks in Jasper County was 1.56, in Newton County 2.18, in Carthage 2.17, in Webb City 1.63, and in Neosho 1.92.


Text Only
Top Stories
  • r041514recycledfashion.jpg Joplin High School students to model ‘recycled’ dresses at fashion show

    Audrey Kaman will walk the runway later this week wearing a dress she designed herself — made out of 250 doilies. “I’d say it’s a fun dress,” the Joplin High School sophomore said. “It’s not really elegant because it’s short, but it’s cute.”

    April 15, 2014 4 Photos

  • Shooter in Joplin murder sentenced to life in prison

    The teen convicted of being the triggerman in the murder of Jacob Wages was sentenced Tuesday to life in prison with the possibility of parole. At a hearing in Jasper County Circuit Court in Joplin, Circuit Judge Gayle Crane followed a jury’s recommendations in assessing Daniel D. Hartman, 18, two life sentences on convictions for second-degree murder and armed criminal action, and 15 years on a conviction for burglary.

    April 15, 2014

  • Interchange construction work near Carterville to create safer off-ramp

    As the Missouri Department of Transportation begins rebuilding eastbound ramps at the Missouri Highway 171 and Route HH interchange near Carterville this week, drivers can expect ramp and occasional lane closures. The $1.5 million project, funded by the state, will increase the distance between ramps for drivers traveling northbound on Highway 249 and exiting eastbound to Highway 171.

    April 15, 2014

  • Schreiber Foods schedules Carthage plant expansion

    Plans to expand a Schreiber Foods plant to eventually add 160 new jobs have been endorsed by a Carthage committee working with the company. Andrew Tobish, director of combinations for Schreiber, which is based in Green Bay, Wis., confirmed the project, which he said would be complete by late spring or early summer in 2015.

    April 15, 2014

  • 3 To Get Ready

    Three things coming your way in Wednesday’s paper.

    April 15, 2014

  • Local Jews offer reactions to Overland Park shooting

    Jews in Joplin and throughout the region are struggling to come to terms with Sunday’s shooting at a Jewish community center and a Jewish retirement complex in suburban Kansas City, resulting in three deaths. The suspect has been identified as Frazier Glenn Cross, 73, of Aurora.

    April 14, 2014

  • Suspect in Kansas shooting has long history as white supremacist

    Frazier Glenn Cross drew the ire of Joplin residents in 2006 when several hundred copies of his white supremacist newspaper were landing on lawns in the city. The White Patriot Leader spouted the usual Cross diatribe. A race war was imminent. The “newspaper for white Americans,” as it billed itself, ranted against an invasion of the country by illegal Hispanic immigrants, the proliferation of black culture, and a purported takeover of the government, banks and the media by Jews.

    April 14, 2014

  • r041414wildwood.jpg Opening of nursing home another recovery milestone

    Gladys Dutton has done a lot of things in her life, but Monday’s dedication of the Communities at Wildwood Ranch nursing home marked a first. “I’ve never cut a ribbon before,” she said. “I hope I do a good job.” Dutton was one of four residents to participate in the opening of the $8.5 million nursing center that eventually will be home to 120 people.

    April 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • Mike Seibert elected new mayor of Joplin

    Joplin’s new mayor pledged Monday night that the city will operate with more transparency and that work toward redevelopment will be the City Council’s priority. Mike Seibert, who withstood a challenge by another incumbent councilman in last Tuesday’s election to be the Zone 4 councilman, was elected mayor by a unanimous vote of the panel Monday night.

    April 14, 2014

  • 3 To Get Ready

    Members of the new Joplin City Council, in the wake of the April 8 election and turmoil that roiled to the surface last August, will elect a mayor and mayor pro tem. Read all of the details.

    April 14, 2014