The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO

Top Stories

March 2, 2013

More than 200 former Picher residents claim lowball offers

PICHER, Okla. — It has been five years since Patsy Huffman packed up her belongings to escape the problems that plagued her hometown of Picher, the epicenter of lead and zinc mining in the Tri-State District.

But she will never be able to pack away the memories of the life she lived there or the town she once knew.

“I raised two kids — a boy and a girl — in that house,’’ she said, pointing to the gray remnants of a foundation. “The front porch was here, and the garage was over there. You know, I can hardly picture things now, it has been so long.’’

With the Mahutska chat pile looming in her backyard, Huffman’s house and those of virtually every other property owner in Picher were bought out and demolished by the Lead-Impacted Communities Relocation Assistance Trust.

The decision to do that was based on studies that showed the ground below Picher was so heavily undermined that it could collapse at any time. In 2008 — the year she moved — a shaft leading to the Keltner Mine opened up across the street from her home.

“It was sad in a way, but it was for the best what happened here. We needed out of here,’’ she said.

Huffman used her relocation money from the trust to resettle in nearby Commerce. Some of her neighbors are former residents of Picher.

But she and more than 220 other former Picher property owners believe they did not get a fair shake from the trust and have alleged in lawsuits that their properties were intentionally undervalued by appraisers working for the trust.

The officers of the trust have countered that allegation with statements that everyone was treated equally, that fair prices were paid and that friends of trust officials were not given preferential treatment.

More than 700 pieces of property were involved in the $60 million buyout.

Trust officials also claim that the majority of Picher’s relocated residents received fair deals or they would not have accepted the buyout offers, but some residents said they accepted what they characterized as “take-it-or-leave-it” offers because they thought it might be their only chance to get something for their properties.

Huffman and many other property owners are parties to a lawsuit in which they hope to recover some of the money they believe they are owed.

On Friday, in the District Court of Tulsa County, Associate District Judge Dana Kuehn heard arguments that could decide whether granting class-action status to the group of former Picher residents is warranted against the leaders of the trust, its appraisers and an insurance company that have been named as defendants.

“It’s been a long time coming,’’ Huffman said.

‘I KNOW THE ISSUES’

Five people were subpoenaed to testify at Friday’s hearing: Dr. Mark Osborn, a Miami physician who headed the trust; Larry Roberts, of Miami, the operations manager for the trust; J.D. Strong, former Oklahoma secretary of the environment who served as state adviser to the trust for former Gov. Brad Henry; Ed Keheley, a member of the trust who resigned over the way appraisals were being handled by the trust; and Missy Beets, a former Picher resident now living in Miami.

Instead of soliciting their testimony, Kuehn listened to arguments for and against the certification of the class action by the attorneys representing the plaintiffs and those representing Cinnabar Service Co., one of the appraisal companies.

When it came time to hear from the plaintiff’s witnesses, Kuehn questioned whether additional testimony was necessary.

“I don’t think we need to hear that today. That’s not an issue to fight today,” she said.

Rather, she posed questions to the attorneys for both sides, particularly those representing the defendants. She also said she believed the court had sufficient information — briefs, affidavits and depositions — with regard to the case.

Based on those comments, Kuehn said there was no need for the witnesses to testify because they would not speak to the primary issue that the court would ultimately decide, which is the issue of liability for the defendants.

“I know the case. I know the issues,’’ the judge said.

MAKE OR BREAK

John Wiggins, the attorney for the property owners, said the court, in deciding whether to grant class-action status, must look at the issue of liability as “the common question that dominates.’’

He told the court the appraisers for the trust uniformly demonstrated “a pattern of misbehavior that was common to the class.’’

He said Missy Beets was selected to be the representative for the class because her appraisal was a typical example of the alleged mishandling of appraisals that occurred.

The behavior in the Beets case, he said, demonstrates the common harm to all class members.

“If we lose before a jury with the Missy Beets case, we lose all 221 cases. It is over,’’ Wiggins said. “If we are successful, the question of liability has been answered for all members of the class.’’

He told the court class certification would achieve judicial economy by having one case instead of 221 individual cases. He also admitted to the court that many of those individual cases would not move forward because many plaintiffs do not have the wherewithal to proceed as individuals.

“We must have the power of class action,” he said. “This is the kind of case that class action was designed to serve.’’

Proof, damages vary

Joe Fears, the attorney representing Cinnabar, said it appeared to him that the court must look at “broad-ranging concerns of misconduct by the defendants that affect a broad range of individuals in the same way.’’

He said giving the former Picher residents class-action status would not address the individual issues that are involved with each plaintiff. He also questioned how class-action certification would be managed in terms of the amount of damages.

“The liability and damages are intertwined,’’ he said. “If a plaintiff alleges a lowballed appraisal, they must offer proof they have been lowballed. The proof will have to vary and so will the damages.’’

Fears also said one person might believe their lowballed appraisal might have cost them $1,500 while another might believe $5,000 is more appropriate in terms of their individual loss.

He also said the court would not gain anything by granting class action to the plaintiffs. He said it would essentially shortcut the requirements for proof to get to the damages, which would not be uniform among members of the class.

TOOLS TO RESOLVE DAMAGES

Wiggins said the court has at its disposal tools to resolve the issue of damages once the issue of liability has been resolved for all members of the class.

“Discovery would determine those damages,’’ he said. “It’s liability that unites the cases, and we would decide that question one time.’’

To do otherwise, he said, could lead to inconsistent verdicts for the same behavior.

Wiggins cited instances in Oklahoma in which the liability issue was resolved and then damages were awarded on an individual basis.

Fears said the damages awarded to the class representative might not be representative of what other members of the class would be entitled to receive in terms of damages. He said the court must consider damages and how they might be awarded if it decides to certify the former Picher residents as a class.

Kuehn did not rule on the question of class-action status on Friday but told the attorneys it would not be long before her decision is handed down.

Trust formation

The Lead-Impacted Communities Relocation Assistance Trust was formed in 2006 after a study by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers found that the abandoned mines under Picher, Cardin and Hockerville had a high risk of caving in.

1
Text Only
Top Stories
  • r042314psumove2.jpg SLIDE SHOW: Moving day for biology and chemistry building at Pittsburg State

    They didn’t all go two-by-two, and the person in charge wasn’t named Noah, but nonetheless, critters of all shapes and sizes were on the move Wednesday. Students, volunteers and staff members helped Delia Lister, director of Nature Reach, relocate everything from a pair of prairie dogs to a vocal macaw named Charlie so that Heckert-Wells Hall — the biology and chemistry building where they are housed on the campus of Pittsburg State University — can undergo a $4.4 million transformation in the coming months.

    April 23, 2014 2 Photos 1 Slideshow

  • 3M plant expansion to create 22 jobs

    An $18.7 million expansion at the 3M Co. manufacturing plant in Nevada will create 22 new jobs, a company official said Wednesday. “We started 43 years ago as a small manufacturer,” said Todd Cantrell, plant manager, in a meeting with employees. “We are now the largest 3M plant in the state of Missouri and one of the largest of all 3M plants.”

    April 23, 2014

  • Respond With Love flower.jpg Joplin pays it forward with flowers; residents asked to return bulbs ‘fostered’ for other towns

    Suzan Morang’s front yard bloomed brightly last year from a colorful array of bulbs that she will happily pass on to someone else this year. Morang, 1207 Xenia Court, is a participant in America Responds With Love, a national nonprofit organization that distributes bulbs to disaster-stricken cities.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Missouri lawmakers file three resolutions calling for impeaching governor

    While Gov. Jay Nixon was in Nevada, Mo., on Wednesday, a Missouri House panel led by Republicans began hearing arguments on three measures calling for impeaching him. Nixon has downplayed the proceedings as a legislative “publicity stunt.” One resolution, sponsored by Rep. Mike Moon, R-Ash Grove, is critical of Nixon for waiting several months to call special elections to fill three vacated House seats.

    April 23, 2014

  • 3 To Get Ready

    Three things coming your way in Thursday’s Joplin Globe.

    April 23, 2014

  • Nixon: Tax-cut bill holds fatal flaw; area lawmakers say stance totally false

    Another year has brought yet another tax-cut fight between Democratic Gov. Jay Nixon and the Republican-led Missouri General Assembly, and on Tuesday, Nixon announced that he had found what he sees as a fatal flaw.

    April 22, 2014

  • NEO_Big_Event - Bright.jpg NEO students step up for Big Event

    Leann Hartman has a 30-foot ditch filled with leaves that she has to clean out every spring. For the retired schoolteacher, this usually means paying a company to clean it for her, only to have to do it again the following year.

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • 3 To Get Ready

    Three things coming your way in Wednesday’s Joplin Globe.

    April 22, 2014

  • r042214earthday.jpg Local group launches clean air plan on Earth Day

    It was an Earth Day first for Stephany Aquinaga, a pre-med student and member of the biology club at Missouri Southern State University. “This is the first time I have ever planted a tree,” she said.

    April 22, 2014 2 Photos

  • Neosho teachers express support for Common Core State Standards

    Neosho teachers on Monday voiced their full support for Common Core State Standards. They made their statements to board members during the Neosho Board of Education meeting as an agenda item.

    April 22, 2014