The Joplin Globe, Joplin, MO

May 2011 Joplin tornado

November 24, 2012

Master developer: Delay could cost projects

JOPLIN, Mo. — Not pushing forward this week with work to establish a tax increment financing district for tornado redevelopment could cost Joplin some of the projects proposed for the plan, according to Joplin’s master developer.

David Wallace, CEO of Wallace Bajjali Development Partners of Sugar Land, Texas, said the city cannot extend its deadline to act on the proposal as requested by the Joplin School District without risking a loss of potential revenue. Wallace Bajjali has a contract with the city to guide the town’s redevelopment in the wake of the 2011 tornado as Joplin’s master developer.

“The creation of the TIF and doing it this year is a significant component to the capital structure of these $800 million in projects,” proposed to replace housing and build a new library, performing arts center, and retail and mixed-use districts.

“If it does go into effect by January, I believe all of those $800 million (in projects) will be accomplished,” Wallace said last week. “If not, a number of those projects will fall by the wayside. So a successful conclusion will have a significant conclusion on the redevelopment of Joplin.”

The proposal met a hurdle when the Joplin School District said the existing proposal would freeze its revenue base at the assessed value of properties after the 2011 tornado, $34 million lower than before the storm. The school district said it would lose about $22 million over the 23-year life of the TIF. The city has offered a $12 million lump-sum payment, but the school district wants annual payments that increase 1.5 percent a year for the 23 years.

The city has offered the $12 million lump-sum payment because it could be made from grants the city has obtained. But that requires the money be used for construction of Franklin Technology Center, because of requirements that the federal government puts on the use of grant funds, and not for operational costs of the schools.

Additionally, the school district wants the master developer and city to agree to prioritize the redevelopment projects and to issue callable bonds. Call bonds allow the borrower to refinance if interest rates fall. In that case, the bonds could be paid off earlier or refinanced at less interest, resulting in a savings or surplus that could be passed on to the other tax districts in the TIF, such as the schools.

The district also predicts enrollment growth of potentially 2,630 students as a result of the housing construction proposed in the redevelopment projects.

Wallace said last week his firm was evaluating the school district’s numbers for the purpose of trying to settle on an agreement. He would not disclose what was being offered to the district.

While the city would like to clinch a deal this week, school district officials on Friday did not believe the school board would make such an agreement in that amount of time.

But the city could proceed if it has enough votes from the City Council.

TIF districts struggle

Joplin’s tug of war over a proposal to help fund tornado redevelopment with a tax increment financing district is not uncommon.

Many other cities face similar struggles with TIF districts.

In Joplin’s case, the TIF district would take in most of the center of the city, including much of the tornado zone and all of downtown. It would take the growth in taxes from increases in real estate assessments and a portion of sales taxes beyond a designated date to help pay for a program of housing and business development.

Wallace has said the proposal could take in about $60 million that could be used to help pay for $42 million in bonds plus costs for construction of projects.

School administrators also have voiced concerns about using a tax district to finance nontaxable public projects, such as a library or a performance arts center.

The city could proceed if it has enough votes from the City Council, but officials in other cities say it is best to have agreements with all the other taxing entities involved before proceeding.

‘A dirty word’

Kansas City officials are currently trying to resolve a disagreement with the Raytown School District over a TIF proposal there.

That city wants to take $11 million in leftover money from a TIF district it created to develop a business park to invest in building soccer fields with the professional soccer team Sporting Kansas City, which is intended to attract visitors to the city. That move is opposed by the Raytown School District, which believes it should get the money now that the original purpose of the taxing district has been achieved.

“Soccer fields are a pretty good thing rather to dump a lot of money into another office building; a lot of kids would get a lot of good out of it,” said Danny Rotert, communications director for Kansas City Mayor Sly James. “The trick is we often find ourselves fighting about other things such as past TIFs gone wrong. TIF is always a dirty word to some folks. Some oppose this TIF because it’s a TIF. It’s too bad because it’s not always bad and deals can be worked out.”

Allan Markley, superintendent of the Raytown School District, said the stickler in this case is Kansas City wants to use money collected from a TIF in the Raytown district for soccer fields that are located in another school district. City-owned soccer fields do not produce a tax base for future revenue in the district either, Markley said.

“Obviously with a TIF, the purpose is to stimulate economic development in your area so you’re hoping to see long-term gain,” he said. “You give up some short-term gain hoping there would be payoff at the end of the day.”

Closer to home

Even the districts that get everyone’s nod in the beginning can develop stumbling blocks.

The city of Monett tied its economic development future to two TIF districts, one created in 1996 and another in 2005. The TIFs are used for infrastructure improvements on Highway 60 and new Business Highway 60, said Dennis Pyle, city administrator.

Monett straddles the Barry-Lawrence county line. Both have filed lawsuits since voters enacted new taxes, portions of which went to the TIF districts. Barry County challenged them when a 911 tax was approved by voters. Lawrence County objected when part of its capital improvements taxes for road and bridge construction went to the TIFs, but it has since withdrawn its lawsuit.

“The counties receive the same as they received before (the TIFs) plus 50 percent of the sales taxes on the new development” that takes place, Pyle said.

In the case of the Monett School District, it receives all of the real estate taxes it did when the TIFs were formed, but the increase of tax revenue generated by increased assessments since the TIFs were formed goes to the TIF fund.

“The schools are forfeiting future property taxes from the new development” to help foster economic development in the city, Pyle said. “Our relationship with Monett R-1 School District has been exemplary. They have supported both TIF projects we have done and continue to support the TIF.”

Monett has spent $450,000 in legal fees to defend against the county lawsuits, but has taken in $17.5 million that Pyle said it would not have received had it not put the TIFs in place to build highway, streets, sewer and water systems that allow new businesses to become established.

Timeline

The Joplin School District asked, in a letter Nov. 16 to the TIF Commission expressing its concerns, for an extension of the TIF timetable, which calls for a public hearing Friday with a TIF recommendation to go to the City Council for its consideration in December.

Wallace said last week that delaying action is not a possibility.

“If we wait until after Jan. 1, it has a significant impact on what the TIF revenues will be able to generate,” he said. “It will have to do with the county’s interpretation of what you do use and don’t use as assessed value.”

Wallace said that proceeding as proposed, the TIF has a potential to generate $60 million.

“After Jan. 1, that number drops significantly, down to about $35 million,” he said. “If we do that, some of the projects will not happen,” Wallace said.

 

1
Text Only
May 2011 Joplin tornado
  • Local new-home construction catches up to previous pace

    After a slow start early in this fiscal year for Joplin, the construction of new houses has resumed at the pace that existed in fiscal year 2013, when permits for new houses averaged more than 16 per month. Since November, the beginning of Joplin’s fiscal year, permits for 118 houses have been issued for a total cost of $12.8 million. The average value has been about $108,000.

    June 11, 2014

  • 052212 unity walk1_72.jpg SLIDESHOW: One year later, One day of unity, updated Photos from a day of events commemorating the May 22, 2011 tornado anniversary

    May 22, 2012 1 Photo

  • 060314 Farmers rebuild 1_72.jpg Farmers Insurance writes manual based on experience from Joplin disaster recovery

    Joplin’s housing recovery from the 2011 tornado is one for the books. Jeff Dailey, CEO of Farmers Insurance, announced Tuesday that not only will Farmers Insurance stick with Rebuild Joplin to repair and replace the homes left on the local group’s waiting list, but the company also will kick off a similar recovery effort today for the city of Sea Bright, New Jersey, based on a book it has written to expedite disaster recovery that is based on its experience in Joplin.

    June 3, 2014 2 Photos

  • r052214butterflygarden.jpg New park feature opens on tornado anniversary to encourage healing

    Cunningham Park has become an emotional place for Pamela Praytor. The name of her son, Christopher Lucas, is engraved on a monument that stands in the park in memory of the 161 people who were killed in the May 2011 tornado. “Even though I cry when I come, it’s OK,” she said. “It’s part of the healing.”

    May 22, 2014 2 Photos

  • r051214greenbldgs3.jpg Home, business cited as examples of energy efficiency, strength

    Ramona and Charles “Hugh’’ Shields were not the least bit reluctant on Monday to open their new house in the tornado zone to a bunch of strangers who had a lot of questions. “I used to live in a house where I had to wear two pairs of socks in the winter to keep my feet warm — not anymore,’’ said Ramona Shields. “This house is nice and warm in the winter, and nice and cool in the summer.’’

    May 12, 2014 2 Photos

  • Mercy Health System to receive $23 million FEMA grant

    The Federal Emergency Management Agency will provide Mercy Health System of Joplin with $23 million in public assistance funding by the end of the year. The disaster relief was announced Friday by U.S. Sen. Claire McCaskill.

    April 25, 2014

  • Respond With Love flower.jpg Joplin pays it forward with flowers; residents asked to return bulbs ‘fostered’ for other towns

    Suzan Morang’s front yard bloomed brightly last year from a colorful array of bulbs that she will happily pass on to someone else this year. Morang, 1207 Xenia Court, is a participant in America Responds With Love, a national nonprofit organization that distributes bulbs to disaster-stricken cities.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Creator of Joplin-based ‘Dear World’ exhibit features Boston bombing victims in new work

    The messages written on the skin of some Boston Marathon victims may be different, but Joplin residents will recognize the handwriting. Robert X. Fogarty, the creator of the “Dear World: From Joplin with Love” exhibit, took his signature style of photography and inspiration to Boston. Fogarty traveled to Joplin in 2011 and took pictures of community members with inspirational messages written on their bodies in black ink.

    April 21, 2014

  • r041414wildwood.jpg Opening of nursing home another recovery milestone

    Gladys Dutton has done a lot of things in her life, but Monday’s dedication of the Communities at Wildwood Ranch nursing home marked a first. “I’ve never cut a ribbon before,” she said. “I hope I do a good job.” Dutton was one of four residents to participate in the opening of the $8.5 million nursing center that eventually will be home to 120 people.

    April 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • Joplin Redevelopment Corp. preparing for first property sale

    The first sale of property from the Joplin Redevelopment Corp. to Wallace Bajjali Development Partners is scheduled for May 16. The city staff will be working to prepare for that sale, it was discussed on Tuesday at a meeting of the JRC.

    April 9, 2014

Purchase Globe Photos


Featured Ads
Facebook
Tornado: Multimedia coverage
Tornado: Obituaries
Tornado: Columns
Tornado: Mike Pound
Tornado: Lists of missing, fatalities & relief
Tornado: Donate & volunteer
Tornado: Resources & relief